The baby camera went up in July. Kristen stood on a kitchen chair at five months, screwing a little white bracket into the cabinet over the bottle station, and when I told her to get down she said, “Then do it yourself, Derek.” I didn’t. I had somewhere to be. I always had somewhere to be that summer.
I’m Derek Lusk. I’m thirty-one, I estimate commercial flooring for a company in Fort Wayne, and I cheated on my pregnant wife with Wade Ferris. Wade has been my best friend since I was eleven. He sat at our dinner table the night we told him about the baby, looked Kristen in the eye, and promised her nobody would ever hurt this family while he was around. She cried a little. I passed him the rolls.
She’d kept the baby’s sex sealed at the twenty-week scan. Nobody knew it but her, not me, not my mother, not the girl at the front desk who handed her the envelope.
I kept up a routine that third trimester. A kiss on her forehead every morning and “you look beautiful.” Then a text at eleven that said STILL BUILDING A BID. Nobody bids flooring at midnight. She never asked. I mistook that for trust.
At 1:10 on a Thursday morning, thirty-two weeks and a day, she woke to an empty bed and came down the stairs. Wade’s hand was on my shoulder. I was laughing. The third stair creaked, and I decided it was the house.
For nine days she was sweet to me. She ordered the cake herself and wouldn’t say which bakery.
The next Saturday, twenty-two people stood in our backyard with their phones up, and Wade wore a white button-down like he was somebody’s uncle at a christening.
“You want to cut it with me?” I said.
“Go ahead,” she said. “I’ve waited nine days for this.”
The sponge inside was white. On top of the bottom layer, under the frosting, was a picture. My mother looked at it, then at me.
“DEREK… WHAT THE HELL IS THAT.”
The first slice
It was a photograph. Edible paper, the kind they print kids’ faces on for birthdays, laid flat between the layers so the first cut would lift a corner of it like a page.
It was our kitchen. Gray, grainy, shot from high up over the bottle station. You could read the time in the corner: 1:10 AM. You could see the counter, and me leaning on it in the gray T-shirt I sleep in, and Wade beside me with his hand on my shoulder. And you could see my face turned up at his. I’ve looked at a lot of photos of myself. I’d never seen that face. I had never once looked at Kristen like that.
The knife was still in my hand. That’s the stupid thing I remember. I was holding a cake knife with frosting on it, and the frosting was white too, and I thought, she did the whole cake in white.
Nobody spoke. Twenty-two people, and one of them was my Uncle Ray, who has never been quiet in his life, and even Ray had his phone lowered to his belly like he’d forgotten it was there.
Then Kristen took the knife out of my hand.
She did it gently. She did everything gently that day. She cut the slice the rest of the way free, slid the cake server under it, and turned the plate so the yard could see.
“That’s the baby camera,” she said. “Derek watched me put it up. He didn’t help.”
My mother made a noise like she’d been stepped on.
“Kris,” I said. I didn’t have the second word.
“I came down the stairs,” she said, to the yard, not to me. “The third one creaks. Everybody who’s been in this house knows the third one creaks. He heard it. He kept going.”
Wade said, “Kristen, this isn’t—”
“You’re in a white shirt,” she said. “I picked white for the cake because I knew you’d wear white. You wore it to the baptism. You wear it when you want to look like the good one.”
He looked down at himself. I swear he looked down to check.
Somebody’s kid, one of my cousin’s, asked, “Is it a boy or a girl?” and his mother hushed him so hard he sat down in the grass.
Kristen laughed. It was a real laugh, the first one I’d heard out of her in nine days that wasn’t for show, and it scared me more than anything else.
“No, he’s right,” she said. “That’s what we came for.”
She reached into the pocket of her sundress. I knew the envelope before it was out. White, the clinic logo in the corner, her thumb over the seal like she’d been holding it there for weeks. She’d told me it was in her nightstand. I’d never looked. It never occurred to me to look at anything of hers.
She tore it and held up the scan picture.
“It’s a girl,” she said.
Somebody started to clap and stopped.
“And I’m leaving,” she said. “I’m going to my sister’s tonight. The bags are in the car. They’ve been in the car since Sunday.” She looked at me then, finally. “You drove behind it to work all week. You didn’t notice.”
I hadn’t. Her Corolla in the driveway, back seat full, a blanket over it. I’d backed around it every morning.
I said, “Can we go inside. Please. Can we just go inside and talk.”
“We talked,” she said. “Every morning. You told me I looked beautiful.”
My mother put her hand flat on the cake table. Paula Lusk is fifty-eight, sells real estate, and has never in my memory been at a loss in a room. She was at a loss for about four seconds. Then she wasn’t.
“Wade,” she said. “Come here.”
He didn’t move.
“Wade Ferris. I have fed you since you were eleven years old. Come here.”
Nine days
He came. That’s what twenty years of my mother’s pot roast will do. He walked across our grass in his white shirt with twenty-two phones turning to follow him, and he stopped in front of her the way he used to stop in front of her when we broke her porch light with a baseball.
“Mrs. Lusk,” he said.
“Don’t.” She took the scan picture out of Kristen’s hand, very carefully, the way she handles closing papers, and held it up near his face. “Look at that. Look at her.”
“I’m not gonna stand here and—”
“You told this girl at her own table,” my mother said. “I was there. I was at that dinner. You said nobody hurts this family while you’re around.”
Wade’s jaw went loose. He looked at me. He actually looked at me for help.
And here is the thing I have to put down, because if I’m telling this I’m telling all of it. I almost gave it. I almost stepped toward him. Twenty years of being the two of us against whatever, and my body started to do it before my head caught up.
Kristen saw. She didn’t say anything. She just watched me take that half step and stop.
“He’s got nothing to say to you,” Wade said to my mother. “This is between me and Derek.”
“Then where’s Derek?” Kristen said.
I was standing at the cake table. I was right there. She meant something else and everybody knew it.
Wade tried a different face. He’s good at faces. In high school he talked us out of two speeding tickets and a fight behind the Dairy Queen with that face, open and sorry and a little bit wounded.
“Kristen. I never wanted you hurt. You have to know that. It just happened. We didn’t plan—”
“You planned beers,” she said. “Four nights a week. I know what nights, Wade. The camera’s motion-activated. It sends me a clip when someone’s in the kitchen after midnight.” She turned to me. “You both came in through the garage. Every time. You’d get water. You’d stand there.”
I felt sick. Not guilty, not yet, that came later. Sick the way you get when you find out a door you thought was locked has been open the whole time.
“How many,” I said.
“Clips?” she said. “Thirty-one.”
My Uncle Ray said, “Jesus Christ,” out loud, and his wife smacked his arm.
“I watched every one,” Kristen said. “In the bathroom. With the fan on. Then I’d come out and you’d ask what’s for dinner.”
“Why didn’t you—” I said, and stopped, because there wasn’t an end to that sentence that I was allowed to say.
“Why didn’t I scream?” She put both hands under her belly the way she’d started doing in the last month. “Because I’m thirty-three weeks, Derek. Because my blood pressure was already up at my last appointment and I wasn’t going to give it to you. I wasn’t going to cry in our kitchen at one in the morning while you two stood there. I was going to do it once. In daylight. With your mother here.”
My mother made the stepped-on noise again.
“And I wanted her to find out about her granddaughter the same minute she found out about you,” Kristen said. “So nobody could tell me later I lied about any of it.”
Wade said, “This is crazy. This is a crazy way to do this. There’s kids here.”
“There’s kids at every party you’ve ever been to,” my mother said. “You did fine.”
“Paula—”
“It’s Mrs. Lusk again.” She put the scan picture down on the table beside the cake, squared it to the edge, and took Wade by the elbow. Not hard. The way you’d take a man who’d had too much at a wedding. “You’re going to your truck.”
“I’m not leaving Derek here with—”
“With his wife?” she said.
Wade looked at me one more time. I should have said something. Anything, either direction. I stood there with frosting on my thumb and didn’t.
My mother walked him the length of the backyard. Past the cooler, past the folding chairs, past the pink and blue balloons Kristen’s sister had tied to the fence because Kristen asked her to, so nobody would guess from the decorations. Twenty-two people and not one of them stepped aside to let him by easier. My cousin’s husband actually stood up into his path, and my mother said, “Sit down, Kevin,” and Kevin sat.
At the gate Wade turned around. “Derek,” he said. Just my name, the way he’d said it a thousand times, from his truck window, from a hospital bed when I broke my collarbone at fourteen, from my kitchen at one in the morning.
My mother shut the gate on it.
The latch clicked. Then his truck started out front, the bad muffler he’d been promising to fix since March, and pulled away, and the whole street heard it go.
Kristen picked up her purse from the chair.
“Wait,” I said.
The cake table
She waited. She owed me nothing and she waited, and that is the most generous thing anyone has ever done for me, and it was the last thing.
“Say it,” she said.
I’d had nine days. She’d had nine days of watching me, and I’d had nine days of not knowing I was being watched, and I came to that table with nothing. I’d spent the whole morning worrying the frosting would melt.
“I’m sorry,” I said.
“For what.”
“For—” Twenty-two people. My aunt had her hand over her mouth. My cousin’s boy was picking at the grass. “For him.”
“No,” she said. “Try again.”
I looked at the photo in the cake. My own face turned up.
“For the bids,” I said. “For lying about the bids. For every night. For the nights she kicked and I wasn’t there. For the stairs. I heard you on the stairs. I heard it and I didn’t turn around.”
She nodded. Something went out of her shoulders.
“I’m going to my sister’s,” she said. “Tonight. Jen’s going to drive the Corolla behind me. I already talked to a lawyer, Thursday on my lunch. You’ll get papers. You’ll get to see her. I’m not going to keep your daughter from you.” She touched her belly. “I’m going to keep me from you.”
“Kris, please. I can fix this. I’ll go to somebody, I’ll go to counseling, I’ll—”
“You’ll do that anyway,” she said. “For her. Not for me.”
My mother came back across the yard. She’d taken off her sunglasses, and her eyes were red, and I had not seen my mother cry since my father’s funeral. She didn’t come to me. She went to Kristen and put both arms around her, around her and the baby both, and held on.
“I’m so sorry, honey,” she said. “I’m so sorry I raised that.”
“You didn’t,” Kristen said into her shoulder. “You raised the one who’d walk Wade out.”
They stood like that a long time. Nobody filmed it. I noticed that later, going through the videos people sent, and the ones people posted, and the ones my cousin swore she deleted. Every phone in the yard was up for the slice. Every phone went down for that.
Then Kristen’s sister Jen came from the driveway with the car keys and stood at the edge of the patio and didn’t look at me at all, which I’d earned.
People started leaving. That’s the other thing nobody tells you. A party doesn’t end, it drains. Uncle Ray patted my shoulder on his way out, two hard pats like he was checking a melon, and said, “Well, son,” and left it there. My aunt took the potato salad. Kevin folded the chairs without being asked, stacked them by the garage, and nodded at me once, and I’ll love Kevin for that nod until I die.
Kristen came back to the cake table last.
She picked up the scan picture and looked at it. Black and gray, the little curve of a nose, a fist up by the face. I’d never seen it. Thirteen weeks it sat in her nightstand.
She set it down in front of me.
“That’s yours,” she said. “I have the other copy.”
“What are you going to name her?”
“We had a list,” she said. “You never looked at it.”
She walked to the gate. My mother went with her as far as the driveway. I heard the Corolla start, and the car behind it, and then nothing, the kind of nothing you get in a backyard in Fort Wayne in October with the cicadas done for the year.
My mother came back alone. She stood across the table from me and looked at the cake.
“Your father would’ve put you through that fence,” she said.
“I know.”
“I’m not going to.” She picked up her purse. “Call me when you’ve talked to somebody. A real somebody. Not Wade.”
“Mom.”
“I’ll be there when she’s born,” she said. “Kristen asked me to be.” She went out through the gate and closed it, softer than she had for Wade, and that was somehow worse.
So it was me.
Me and a white cake with one slice gone, and the photo still in it, curled at the corner where the knife had lifted it. The pink and blue balloons on the fence knocking together in the wind. The folding chairs by the garage. Twenty-one paper plates nobody used.
I sat down in the chair Kristen had sat in. I picked up the knife.
I cut the photo the rest of the way out, the whole kitchen, the whole 1:10 a.m., and laid it face down on a plate. Then I took the scan picture and set it where the photo had been, right on the bottom layer, a little girl with her fist up by her face.
The upstairs light was off. The third stair would be quiet tonight.
I didn’t eat the cake. I sat there with the knife in my hand until the frosting went soft, and I looked at her.
If this one hit you somewhere, send it to the person who’d have walked Wade to the gate for you.
For more family drama and shocking moments, read about a Thanksgiving gathering that took a cruel turn and a wedding day upended by the groom’s mother. There’s also a birthday celebration with a costly family betrayal.