The cap from the itch cream rolled under our bed. I left it there.
At 6:20 that Saturday morning, November 14, I had lifted Curtis’s sleeping shirt and found 42 raised dots across his back. Six rows, seven in each, with the lowest row redder than the rest.
They looked like insect eggs. My husband looked terrified that I had counted them.
For twelve days, since Monday, November 2, he had scratched, shed white flakes onto his work shirts, and blamed the detergent I’d bought in October to save two dollars.
“It’s the new laundry soap, Tonya. Drop it.”
After eleven years of marriage, he suddenly dressed behind a locked bathroom door and slept in a T-shirt. His late Tuesdays and Thursdays came with a smell of hand sanitizer. I suspected another woman.
Changing the soap back on Wednesday, November 11, hadn’t helped. Friday’s drugstore cream was still on the sheet when he caught my wrist that Saturday.
“It’s the soap. Go back to sleep.”
Instead, at 6:45, I left our seven-year-old, Brooke, with Mrs. Kowalski next door, frog-foot pajamas and all. Brooke had avoided his lap since he’d joked at breakfast that bugs caused his itching.
The urgent care on our side of Zanesville was fourteen minutes away, between a dollar store and a nail salon. Curtis begged for the forty-minute drive to the ER instead. In the plaza, he refused to leave the car.
We entered at 7:02, just after opening, first in line.
Gloria, the nurse with reading glasses on a chain, couldn’t persuade him to lift his shirt. Four minutes later, Dr. Hensley could.
One glance turned the doctor’s face gray. He lowered the shirt and stepped away.
“Gloria, call the police. Now.”
As Gloria picked up the phone, Curtis stretched his hand toward his jacket.
Three Doors Down
Dr. Hensley moved aside rather than block him.
“You can leave,” he said. “But please hear me first.”
Curtis stopped with two fingers hooked inside a sleeve. I wanted to take the jacket and throw it into the sink. Apparently eleven years of marriage could leave you standing beside a soap dispenser considering crimes against outerwear.
“Are those things contagious?” I said. “We have a daughter.”
“No sign of that,” the doctor said. “Those look like injuries where something was applied to his skin. I’ve treated two other men with the same pattern this month.”
Curtis let go of the sleeve.
“Did you go to the storefront three doors down?” Dr. Hensley said.
My husband lowered his head.
“They called it a skin patch study,” he said.
“Who did?”
“The people running it.”
The doctor pulled his stool closer. He looked about fifty-five, and whatever had startled him had given way to the business of having a hurt person in front of him.
“That operation isn’t licensed to provide the treatment they’re selling as research. I reported it after the second patient. The police have an investigation open.”
“He’s going to be arrested?” I said.
“He’s someone who needs care. I want the investigators to know there’s another injured participant.”
Curtis rubbed his palms on his trousers.
“They said redness was normal.”
“Did you tell them it hurt?”
“Thursday. They said I was nearly finished.”
“Finished with what?” I said.
He glanced toward the doorway, where Gloria had returned. She was around sixty, with the expression of a woman who had heard every version of a man being fine.
“Six visits,” Curtis said. “Seven patches each time.”
I put my hand on the counter.
He gave the dates when the doctor asked. October 27 and 29. November 3 and 5. November 10 and 12. Tuesdays and Thursdays. Six evenings I had been at home wondering whose perfume could be scrubbed away with sanitizer.
“Why would you keep going?”
“They paid.”
“How much?”
“Nine hundred each time. Cash.”
The doctor waited while I did the sum. I was thirty-six years old, and nobody had ever paid me $900 for an hour of anything. I knew enough about money to be afraid of that.
“Five thousand four hundred dollars?”
Curtis nodded.
“Where is it?”
“The mortgage.”
“We pay the mortgage every month.”
His eyes filled.
“I got laid off in July.”
The exam paper crackled under him. Somewhere beyond the room Gloria’s phone rang, and she went to answer it.
I held on to the counter until my fingers hurt.
“July,” I said.
“I thought I’d find something before you needed to know. Then August went by. I used what was left for groceries and the other bills. I kept thinking the next interview would—”
“How many payments?”
“Four. August through November. Thirteen hundred and fifty each.”
“Did you actually pay them?”
“Yesterday. All four.”
“Show me.”
He took out his phone, opened the mortgage account, and handed it over. A payment of $5,400 appeared as pending. There were the missed payments too, lined up neatly. My husband had acquired two sets of rows while I washed his shirts.
“How did you find this place?”
“Randall.”
His older brother.
Curtis was thirty-eight and could still say Randall’s name with the trust of a boy waiting for someone to get a ball off a roof.
“He said he knew people who’d done it. Said it was easy money.”
“Did he get paid?”
Curtis didn’t answer.
“Did your brother get paid?”
“One hundred and fifty dollars for each person he brought in.”
I set the phone beside his jacket.
Dr. Hensley asked permission to examine his back properly. Curtis agreed, and I turned toward the wall while the doctor checked the sores. I didn’t want my face to make him hide again.
The doctor couldn’t identify the chemicals from looking. He could see irritated skin, open places where Curtis had scratched, and areas he wanted treated and checked again. He explained what symptoms meant we should seek emergency care.
No guessing. No promise that everything would disappear by Monday. For the first time that morning, somebody said only what he knew.
Gloria came back with supplies. The police were sending an investigator.
“Please don’t call Randall,” Curtis said to me.
That got me turned around.
“Why?”
“He’ll say I misunderstood.”
“What would he misunderstand about your back?”
“He told me not to go to a doctor until after the last payment. Said they’d take me off the study.”
Dr. Hensley stopped opening a dressing.
“Did he write that in a message?”
Curtis nodded.
I picked up his phone and held it out to him.
“You need to show that to the investigator.”
He reached for it, then stopped.
“Tonya, please. He’s my brother.”
“And you’re my husband. Unlock it.”
The Message on His Phone
Curtis entered the code and opened Randall’s messages.
The warning was there, sent Thursday afternoon. Finish first. Don’t let some doctor scare you out of getting paid.
Below it was a message from Curtis saying the lower row burned.
Randall’s answer was brief.
Only one more. Think about Brooke having a roof.
I sat down on the chair, moving the jacket onto my knees. My daughter’s name on that screen did more to me than the money.
When the investigator arrived, Dr. Hensley asked Curtis whether he wanted me to stay. Curtis said yes. The doctor left us with the investigator, and Curtis gave his account from the beginning.
I kept my mouth shut while he described lying facedown in a storefront, waiting while strangers put seven small patches across his skin. He had signed something. He hadn’t kept a copy. They told him the burning showed the material was working.
The investigator asked whether anyone there had examined his skin before the next application.
“They looked,” Curtis said.
“Did they ever tell you to stop?”
“No.”
He agreed to photographs and to provide the messages. When he faltered over Randall’s name, I pushed the phone closer to him.
“All of it,” I said.
He gave them all of it.
The investigator explained that officers were working on a search warrant using evidence already collected, and Curtis’s account would be added. He couldn’t promise us what would happen or when.
Then he asked Curtis to save the messages and avoid contacting the people running the storefront.
Curtis looked at the doorway.
“I texted my brother while Gloria was on the phone. Before I told you anything.”
“What did you say?”
“That I was here. That they called the police.”
The investigator took down that detail too.
I closed my eyes. My husband had found enough courage to tell his brother he was in trouble before he found enough to tell me why.
Gloria appeared at the door a few minutes later.
“His brother’s at the desk,” she said. “Do you want him back here?”
“No,” I said.
Curtis spoke at the same time.
“Yes.”
We looked at each other.
“He needs to see it,” Curtis said.
The investigator stepped outside to speak with Randall first. When he returned, he asked again whether Curtis wanted the conversation. Curtis said yes, and said I could stay.
Randall came into the room wearing the same worried face he brought to a flat tire. He glanced at the dressings beside Curtis, then at the investigator.
“Well, this got big fast.”
I stood beside the sink. There were five of us in that room: Curtis, Randall, the investigator, Gloria, and me.
“Tell them,” Curtis said.
“Tell them what?”
“About the money.”
Randall spread his hands.
“I passed along an opportunity. You needed cash. You got cash. Nobody forced you to sign anything.”
“Did they pay you?” I said.
“A referral fee. That’s ordinary.”
“How much?”
“A hundred and fifty.”
“For Curtis.”
“Yes, for Curtis. Look, I didn’t invent the place. I don’t know what they put in those patches. They had paperwork. He could read it just like I could.”
Curtis moved his feet off the exam-table step and stood. His shirt hung loose because Gloria hadn’t finished dressing his back.
“I told you it burned.”
“You said it itched.”
“I sent you a picture.”
Randall looked toward the investigator.
“I’m not a doctor.”
“You told me not to see one.”
“I told you to finish getting paid. You were about to lose your house. Remember that part? You called me, Curtis. I didn’t come looking for you.”
My husband bent his head. Randall took a step closer, as if that had settled things.
“Let’s go home and talk about this without an audience.”
Curtis backed away from him.
“Look at my back.”
“I saw the picture.”
“Look.”
He turned and raised his shirt.
Gloria reached forward to keep the fabric clear of the sores. Randall stared at the six rows. His mouth moved, but nothing came out at first.
Then he said, “I didn’t know it was that bad.”
“You got the picture Thursday,” Curtis said.
Randall rubbed the back of his neck.
“They told me it was normal. I believed them. You’re acting like I stood there and hurt you myself.”
The investigator asked Randall whether he would answer questions separately. Randall said he wanted a lawyer first.
“That’s your right,” the investigator said.
Randall turned back to Curtis.
“Are you really going to let them make me part of this?”
Curtis lowered his shirt.
“You were paid to make yourself part of it.”
For once, his brother had no instruction ready.
“Stay away from our house,” Curtis said. “Don’t call my wife. Don’t call Brooke.”
“Over a hundred and fifty dollars?”
I opened the exam-room door.
“Over what you sold for it.”
The Door Left Open
Randall went past me without offering to return the money.
The investigator followed him into the hall, and Gloria finished the dressing while Curtis sat with his hands pressed between his knees.
“Tell me if this pulls,” she said.
“It pulls.”
She adjusted it.
Such a small exchange. I nearly cried over it. A question, an honest answer, and somebody doing something useful with the answer. We could have started there twelve days earlier.
By the time we were ready to leave, the investigator asked whether Curtis could remain nearby for a little longer. The warrant had been approved, and officers were going to the storefront.
We sat in our car outside the urgent care. I called Mrs. Kowalski and told her we would be longer. Brooke was safe at her house, drawing frogs. She had eaten breakfast.
I asked to speak to her.
“Does Daddy still have bugs?” she said.
“No, baby. He never had bugs. His skin got hurt, and the doctor is helping.”
“Can he come home?”
“Yes.”
Curtis held his hand out for the phone, then waited instead of taking it.
I passed it to him.
“I’m sorry I scared you, peanut,” he said.
He listened for a while, wiping his face with the heel of his hand.
“Yes. I’ll tell you when it hurts.”
I looked through the windshield until he finished.
Three doors down, officers entered the storefront. We hadn’t been asked to identify anybody or approach the entrance, and we stayed where we were.
An officer brought out a man and kept him beside a patrol car while others went in and out. Boxes came through the doorway. The investigator returned to our car and told Curtis they had stopped the sessions and were collecting the records and materials.
“What about the other people coming?” Curtis said.
“We’re working through the appointment list.”
Curtis nodded, then asked how to give them the receipts still in his wallet.
He handed those over himself.
I didn’t get a courtroom ending from that parking space. Nobody could tell us that morning what charges would hold, or how long the case would take. What I could see was the door closed to customers and my husband giving evidence instead of reaching for his coat.
On the drive home, he asked if I hated him.
“I am furious with you.”
“I know.”
“No. You know about the study. I’m talking about July.”
He faced forward.
“I put on those shirts every morning because I couldn’t stand having you look at me and know I wasn’t going to work.”
“Where did you go?”
“The library. Interviews. Sometimes I just drove.”
“And I asked how your day was.”
“Yes.”
The road blurred. I pulled into a grocery-store parking lot and put the car in park.
“You let me think I was doing something to your skin. I washed every shirt twice.”
“I’m sorry.”
“You let me lie awake thinking you were with somebody else.”
His face folded.
“Never.”
“You don’t get credit for the lie I guessed wrong.”
He nodded. Tears dropped onto his trousers.
“And you held my wrist.”
“I shouldn’t have touched you. It won’t happen again.”
I took a tissue from my bag. It had a grocery receipt attached to it. Even at the collapse of my marriage’s bookkeeping, my purse remained a disgrace.
Curtis gave a small, broken laugh when I shook the receipt loose. Then he cried harder.
I handed him the tissue.
“We’re going home,” I said. “You’re going to show me every account. Every bill. I am not finding out about December in January.”
“I will.”
“And you will go back for the follow-up.”
“Yes.”
I started the car.
At home, we sat on the couch with his phone between us before collecting Brooke. He opened the accounts. I wrote down what was paid, what remained, and which calls we needed to make on Monday.
The $5,400 payment was there. The mortgage hadn’t vanished, and neither had the rest of our bills. But the four missed installments were covered. We could work with numbers we were both allowed to see.
Curtis handed me his wallet to check for anything he’d forgotten.
I gave it back.
“Open it yourself.”
He did.
There was no second secret tucked inside. Just the ordinary mess of a man’s wallet, now spread where we could both reach it.
By late afternoon, after we’d brought Brooke home, I went upstairs to change the sheets. Curtis followed with the laundry basket.
I knelt beside the bed and reached under it for the cream cap.
“There it is,” he said.
“Don’t congratulate it. It’s had a better day than we have.”
He took the basket into the bathroom and left the door open. When he came back, he asked me to check whether the dressing had shifted.
I lifted his shirt with his permission this time. One corner needed pressing down. I fixed it, and he thanked me without blaming the soap.
Downstairs, Brooke stood beside the couch in those frog-foot pajamas she had insisted on putting back on.
Curtis sat carefully, keeping his back away from the cushion. She approached him with both hands behind her.
“Will I hurt you?”
“Not if we go slow.”
He held out his arms without pulling her. She climbed onto his lap sideways, arranging her knees with the solemn care she usually reserved for a doll missing a limb.
I sat beside them. Curtis reached for my hand and stopped short of it.
I put my hand in his.
Brooke rested her cheek against his chest.
“No bugs?” she said.
“No bugs, peanut.”
She tucked her frog feet under my leg and settled in.
For more jaw-dropping family betrayals, read how my father handed Travis the keys while I was still paying and how my mother assigned me a foam plate and a $94,000 bill. There’s also the tense estate hearing in my mother asked me to sign away Grandma’s lumber yard.