Thirty-Four Bikers Parked Below My Courthouse Steps at 7:40

Marcus Chen

The coffee at my post goes cold by 7:15 every morning, and that Thursday I never even took the lid off.

I was watching four people at the top of the Calder County courthouse steps. Nagel, his two associates, and his investigator, standing there with briefcases like commuters. I’d heard Nagel two months earlier in the hallway, close enough for Lauren to catch every word: “She’ll forget what she saw by the next date.” That was after continuance number five. Five times a 7-year-old named Sadie had put on court clothes for nothing.

My Katelyn made that walk at ten. I was a deputy three years then. Fourteen now. Even now, she refuses to drive by the building.

At 7:40 the steps started humming under my boots.

They came up Loudon Avenue in pairs. I guessed thirty-something. At the curb, backed in neat as a ruler, I counted thirty-four. Thirty-four riders. Not one word out of any of them.

Lauren’s dented sedan pulled up. Sadie got out in a purple coat with sleeves past her fingers, saw that row of machines, and froze with her shoes aimed back at the car. Up top, Nagel smiled.

The oldest rider, Abe, gray beard, ink to his wrists, came around slow and went down on one knee on the cold concrete.

“You never have to look at him,” he said. “You look at us.”

She took his hand. They closed around her and her mother and walked them up all twenty-two steps. Nagel’s people slid aside. Nagel held a second longer, blinked, and moved.

At 9:15 Abe came out alone, sat on the top step, and put his face in his hands. I left my post and sat with him.

“Mine had her hair just like that,” he said.

Then Sergeant Hahn came over my radio: “Volkov. Inside, now. Defense just filed an emergency motion and the judge wants every deputy who was on those steps.”

Abe turned and looked at the doors like he’d already read it.

Courtroom 3B

I took the stairs instead of the elevator because the elevator in that building thinks about things.

Hahn was waiting outside 3B with his arms folded and his reading glasses pushed up on his head, which is how you know he’s been reading something he didn’t like.

“You left your post,” he said.

“Man was crying on the steps.”

“Man is the subject of a motion.” He handed it to me. “Read the second page. Then don’t make a face in there.”

The second page asked Judge Gaskins to bar “members of an unidentified motorcycle organization” from the courthouse and its grounds for the length of the trial. Witness intimidation. Jury taint. A “coordinated show of force designed to influence the testimony of a minor.”

I made the face out in the hallway so I wouldn’t make it inside.

“He wants them gone before she takes the stand,” I said.

“He wants a lot of things,” Hahn said. “Today he might get one.”

There were three of us who’d been on the steps. Me, Enzo, the new kid who’d asked me if we should call it in, and Wojciech from the side door, who never says anything about anything. We sat in the first row behind the rail like kids outside the principal’s office.

The jury wasn’t in. Sadie and Lauren weren’t in either. Somebody had them in the witness room down the hall with a box of crayons and a vending-machine honey bun. The gallery was reporters and the defendant’s people, and they were humming.

Nagel stood up like he’d been waiting his whole career for it.

He was good. That’s the thing nobody wants to hear about Nagel. He didn’t raise his voice once. He said the words “thirty-four” four times, I counted, and every time he said it softer, so it sounded bigger.

“Your Honor, my client is entitled to a trial without a gang lining the street. This morning a child witness was physically escorted past defense counsel by a wall of men in leather. We were forced aside on public steps. The message to this witness, and to any juror who drove past, could not be clearer.”

Judge Gaskins is sixty-four and has a face like a closed mailbox. “Forced,” she said.

“Crowded off, Your Honor.”

“Did anyone touch you, Mr. Nagel?”

“It was the implication.”

“I see.” She looked at the rail. “Deputies. Who was closest?”

Hahn didn’t even turn around. Enzo looked at me like I was the lifeboat.

I stood up.

They swore me in right there, which I’ve seen happen to other people maybe twice. My knees felt like they belonged to somebody who’d had a worse morning than me.

Nagel came to the podium for me himself. He didn’t send an associate. I took that as a compliment, the way you take it as a compliment when a dog bothers to bark at you.

“Deputy Volkov. How many motorcycles?”

“Thirty-four.”

“How many men?”

“Thirty-four riders.”

“Wearing club colors?”

“Vests. No patches. Blank.”

That stopped him a half second. He’d written “organization” in his motion and the organization didn’t have a name on its back.

“Were they blocking the sidewalk?”

“They were parked legally. Rear tires to the curb. Better than you park, sir. I’ve seen your Lexus on Tuesdays.”

Somebody in the press row laughed. Gaskins didn’t. But she didn’t stop me either.

“Did they surround the witness?”

“They walked with her.”

“Surrounded her.”

“Front, back, and both sides. Yes.”

“And defense counsel was made to step aside.”

“Defense counsel was standing in the doorway of a public building at the time a witness needed to come through it. Everybody steps aside for that. I’d have asked you to myself.”

He leaned on the podium. Calm voice. This was the move. I’d watched him do it to a little girl.

“Deputy, in fourteen years have you ever seen thirty-four bikers arrive at this courthouse on the morning a child testifies?”

“No.”

“So this was unusual.”

“Yes.”

“Organized.”

“I don’t know who organized it.”

“Intended to intimidate.”

“Intimidate who?”

“Answer the question, Deputy.”

“I’m asking which one you mean. Because the only person on those steps who looked scared was a seven-year-old in a purple coat, and the only person who smiled at her was you.”

The room went quiet the way a room does when a tray hits the floor and nobody wants to be the one to pick it up.

Nagel straightened his notes.

“Did any of these men say anything to the witness?”

And there it was. The one thing I knew for sure.

“One,” I said. “The oldest. He knelt down on the sidewalk so she was taller than him, and he told her she never had to look at your client. He told her to look at them.”

“That’s coaching.”

“That’s a man on one knee in November, sir. The other thirty-three didn’t say a word to anybody. Not to her. Not to you. Not to me. Not to the reporters, and the reporters tried.”

The reporter from the Calder Ledger nodded like she wanted it on record.

Gaskins wrote something. Then she looked at Nagel over her glasses for long enough that he started to adjust his tie and then stopped himself.

“Parking legally and standing quietly on a public street is not intimidation in my courtroom,” she said. “Walking a frightened child up a flight of stairs is not intimidation in my courtroom. The motion is denied. If any one of them so much as raises his voice on these grounds, I’ll revisit it. Otherwise the gallery is a public gallery. The witness takes the stand at one-thirty.”

Nagel said, “Note our objection.”

“Noted,” she said. “Sit down.”

I sat down. Enzo patted my knee twice like I was a horse that had done something brave.

When we came out into the hallway, Abe was standing by the water fountain, hat in his hands. He’d come in after all. He’d gone through the metal detector, his belt buckle had gone off, and Wojciech said later Abe took the belt off without being asked and handed it over like a man who’d been through that particular door before.

That’s when I noticed he wasn’t looking at me.

He was looking at Nagel coming out of 3B.

Nagel looked back at him. Just a glance. The glance you give a man you’ve seen somewhere and can’t place.

Abe saw that he couldn’t place him.

And Abe’s whole face went gray under the beard.

I got between them before either of them moved, which neither of them did, and I took Abe by the elbow and walked him to the bench under the window.

“Abe.”

“He doesn’t remember,” he said.

“Remember what?”

He pulled his wallet out of his back pocket. It was the old kind with a chain. Behind his license there was a school picture, soft at the corners from being carried. A little girl with hair cut straight across the front and long in the back, same as Sadie’s. Missing a tooth.

“Miriam,” he said. “Three years ago she was eight. Room 3B. Same chair Sadie’s going to sit in.”

The air left my chest.

I’d been in that gallery three years ago. I’d watched that girl cry so hard the judge called recess. I’d watched Nagel straighten his notes and wait.

I’d never known her name. I’d only known her as the one I couldn’t stop thinking about.

“She never went back after the recess,” Abe said. “Her mother and me, we couldn’t make her. The DA said without her there wasn’t a case. The man walked out that afternoon. Moved two counties over.” He put the picture back behind the license, careful. “She’s eleven. She sleeps with the hall light on.”

“And you called them.”

“I called them,” he said. “I read in the Ledger who was defending this one. And I called every man I ever rode with. Thirty-three said yes. I told them not one word to anybody. Not one.”

“They listened.”

“They’ve got daughters,” he said.

Down the hall the witness-room door opened and Lauren stuck her head out, looking for somebody.

She found Abe.

And Sadie came out under her mother’s arm, still in the purple coat, honey bun icing on her chin, and said, “Is it time?”

One-Thirty

Lauren had changed her mind by one-fifteen. I could see it from across the hall.

She’d been brave all morning and somewhere around the vending machine it ran out. She came up to me with her purse strap wound so tight around her hand her fingers had gone white.

“I can say no,” she said. “Right? I’m her mother. I can say she’s not doing it.”

“You can,” I said.

“Because I watched him. On the news, a few years back. I saw what he does.” She looked at Abe on the bench and didn’t know she was talking to the father of what he does. “I’ve got a shift at four. I already lost five shifts. If she goes up there and he does that to her and she cries and it falls apart anyway, then what did I do it for?”

I wanted to tell her everything would be fine. I’ve worked that building fourteen years. I don’t say that sentence in it.

“My daughter testified at ten,” I said. “Right in there.”

Lauren looked at me.

“She’s twenty-one. She still won’t drive past this building. And I’ll tell you what she said to me once, at the kitchen table, when she was about sixteen and mad at me about something else. She said, ‘The worst part wasn’t him. The worst part was nobody let me finish.'”

Lauren unwound the strap from her hand.

Abe stood up off the bench. He didn’t come over. He was very careful that whole day about not coming over.

“Ma’am,” he said from where he was. “Your call. We’ll be in the back row either way. We’ll be at your car either way.”

Sadie tugged her mom’s sleeve. “Are they coming in?”

“Some of them,” Abe said. “Judge said the back row’s public.”

“Can you sit where I can see?”

“That’s the only place I’m sitting.”

And that was that. Seven-year-olds decide faster than lawyers.

Twelve of them came in. Gaskins’ bailiff counted them at the door and Hahn told me it was twelve, because the back two rows of 3B hold twelve, and the other twenty-two stood outside on the steps in the cold like a fence somebody forgot to paint. Twelve men in blank vests, hats off, hands on their knees. Abe was dead center.

I had the rail. I’d asked Hahn for the rail, and Hahn, who has two granddaughters, gave me the rail without a word.

They brought the jury in. They brought Sadie in.

They’d put a cushion on the witness chair so her chin cleared the wood. She sat on her hands. Lauren sat in the first row behind the prosecutor, and the prosecutor, Tanya Cobb, who was about thirty-four herself and had argued against every one of those five continuances, did her direct quiet and short.

Sadie answered. Little sentences. What she saw, where she was standing, what color his truck was. She looked at the back row between almost every answer like a kid checking the parking lot for her ride.

Then Tanya sat down.

And Nagel stood up.

He buttoned his jacket. He smiled at her, a small one, the grandpa kind. He didn’t go to the podium. He walked over and stood near the jury box so that if she wanted to look at the jury she’d have to look past him.

He’d planned that. I’d seen him plan that before.

“Sadie, that’s a pretty name. How old are you?”

“Seven.”

“Seven. And this happened when you were six.”

“Yes.”

“That’s a long time ago, isn’t it? Nine months.”

“You kept moving it,” Sadie said.

A juror in the front coughed into her hand to cover something.

Nagel kept the smile. “Let’s talk about the truck. You said it was blue.”

“Blue.”

“Dark blue or light blue?”

“Blue.”

“Like the sky?”

“Like a truck.”

“But you’re sure it was blue and not black. At night.”

“It was in the morning.”

“Earlier today you said morning. Are you sure you didn’t say night to Ms. Cobb last spring?”

Tanya was up. “Objection, mischaracterizes.”

“I’ll rephrase.” Calm voice. “When you first told your mommy, what time did you say it was?”

And here it came. I knew this road. Same question, other words. Morning, then the time, then the light, then the clock in the kitchen, then the color of the sky. Nine times, ten times, until a little girl can’t tell what she’s already said and starts guessing what he wants.

Sadie’s chin started to go.

I felt it in my own chin. I’m not ashamed of that.

She looked at Nagel. She looked at the table where the defendant sat. Her hands came out from under her legs and twisted in the purple sleeves.

Then she did what she’d been told on the sidewalk at 7:40 that morning.

She looked past all of them. To the back row.

Abe didn’t nod. He didn’t wave. He just sat up straight in his chair, and down that row eleven men sat up straight with him, like it was church and somebody had stood for the hymn.

Sadie took a breath.

“Morning,” she said. “I said morning. I said morning to my mom, and Ms. Cobb, and the police lady, and the man with the camera, and I’m saying it to you. It was morning, the truck was blue, and he did it.” She wiped her nose on the purple sleeve. “You can ask me again. I’ll still say it.”

Nobody in that room breathed.

Nagel opened his mouth.

“Mr. Nagel,” Gaskins said, “I’ve counted. That’s six times. Asked and answered. Move on, or sit down.”

He looked at his notes. He had a whole page left. I could see it from the rail, a whole page of the same question in different hats.

He turned it over.

“Nothing further,” he said.

Sadie said, “Can I go now?”

“You can go now, honey,” Gaskins said. And then, which I’ve never heard a judge say on the record in fourteen years: “You did very well.”

Sadie climbed off the cushion, walked down the aisle past the jury, past her mother who reached out and missed her, and went all the way to the back row and stood in front of Abe.

“I didn’t look at him,” she said.

“I saw,” Abe said.

His voice cracked straight down the middle on it, and the man next to him, a shaved-head rider with a bandage on one knuckle from God knows what, put a hand on his shoulder and kept it there.

Gaskins called a ten-minute recess.

Nagel came out of 3B fast, the way people leave a party where they said something wrong. His associates trailed him, the investigator last.

Abe was already in the hallway. He’d gotten up when Sadie did.

He was standing right in front of the elevator. The elevator that thinks about things.

Nagel stopped. He couldn’t get around him without making it look like going around.

“Excuse me,” Nagel said.

Abe didn’t move.

Twenty-Two Steps Down

It was a full hallway. Lauren with Sadie on her hip, Tanya Cobb with her files, twelve riders behind Abe, the reporter from the Ledger with her phone held low, two of Nagel’s people, Hahn coming out of 3B, and me, between all of them, with my hand resting on nothing in particular on my belt.

“Sir,” I said to Abe. “Not here.”

“I’m not going to touch him,” Abe said. “You know I’m not.”

I did know. That was the problem. I had no reason to move him.

Nagel smoothed his tie. “If you’ve got something to say to me, the gentleman can call my office.”

“I called your office,” Abe said. “Three years ago. Your girl at the desk told me you don’t speak with the families of complaining witnesses.”

Nagel’s face did the thing old paint does. I’ll give him this. He tried to place it. You could see him flipping through files behind his eyes.

“I don’t recall.”

“Room 3B,” Abe said. “Same chair with no cushion on it because nobody thought to bring one. Eight years old. Hair cut straight across like the one in there. You asked her about a door. Whether it was open or closed. You asked her twelve times.”

Nagel stopped flipping.

“I counted,” Abe said. “Same as the deputy counts things.”

Hahn stopped behind me. I heard him stop.

“Her name is Miriam,” Abe said. “She cried so bad the judge called a recess, and you straightened your papers. I was in the fourth row. You looked right at me while you straightened them.”

“I represent my clients zealously,” Nagel said. “That’s the job. I’m sorry for your—”

“Don’t,” Abe said.

It wasn’t loud. It was the loudest thing anybody said all day.

“She never came back in after the recess. The man walked. He moved to Hollis County and he has a girlfriend with a little boy now. And you said to your friend out here, two months ago, right where you’re standing, ‘She’ll forget what she saw by the next date.'” Abe tipped his head at Lauren. “Her mother heard. The deputy heard. I read it in the paper, because the deputy put it in her report and the paper got the report.”

Every head turned to me. I hadn’t known that last part either. I’d written it down because I write everything down. I had not known anybody read my reports.

“Mine never forgot,” Abe said. “Eleven years old. Hall light on every night. She remembers what she saw and she remembers you. That’s the two things she remembers out of that whole year.”

The associate who’d been at Nagel’s elbow, Hoang, the young one, maybe twenty-six, stepped back away from him. Not much. A foot. But everybody in that hallway saw that foot.

Nagel looked at the reporter’s phone. He looked at the twelve men behind Abe, none of whom had said a word, none of whom would. He looked at Sadie on her mother’s hip, who was looking straight at him now. She’d decided, I think, that she’d already done the hard part and could look at whoever she wanted.

“I have a client,” Nagel said.

“You do,” Abe said. “Go on and see to him.”

And Abe stepped aside. Slow. One step. Just like Nagel had done on the steps at 7:40, except Abe did it on purpose, and everybody knew the difference.

Nagel got in the elevator.

The doors took their time closing. They always do. He stood in there with his briefcase, looking at the floor numbers, for six full seconds while thirty people in a hallway watched him not look at them.

Then the doors shut.

Here’s how it came out, in order, since you came this far.

The jury got the case Friday at noon. They were out two hours and forty minutes. Guilty on every count.

The Ledger ran the hallway on Saturday, with Abe’s quote and without Miriam’s last name, because Abe asked them to leave it off and the reporter, Naomi something, actually listened.

On Monday morning, which is today, Hoang filed a notice withdrawing from Nagel’s firm. Hahn heard it from the clerk. The investigator went with him.

Hollis County’s sheriff called our office Monday at ten wanting the file from three years ago. Tanya Cobb sent it over herself. She drove it.

And Nagel’s name is off the list of attorneys the Calder County court appoints for indigent defense, effective December first. Gaskins signed that one. I wasn’t in the room. I’d have liked to be.

That’s the counting. Here’s the rest.

Thursday at 4:10 p.m. the doors opened and Lauren came out holding Sadie’s hand. Lauren had called her manager from the hallway and said she wasn’t coming in, and the manager had said fine, and Lauren had cried about that harder than about anything else all day, because the manager had seen the noon news.

The twenty-two riders who’d stood outside all afternoon were still standing outside. The twelve from the back row came out behind Lauren and went down to join them. Thirty-four again. Rear tires to the curb, same angle, every one.

Abe stayed at the top with me.

Sadie stopped on the top step and looked down the whole flight. Her sleeves were rolled up now. Somebody, I think the rider with the bandaged knuckle, had rolled them for her in the witness room so she could hold her juice box.

“How many are there?” she said.

“Twenty-two,” I said. “I counted this morning.”

“That’s a lot.”

“You did them already.”

“I did them up,” she said. “Up’s different.”

Abe held his hand down to her. Big scarred hand, ink to the wrist. She looked at it.

Then she shook her head.

“I can do down,” she said.

And she went. One step at a time, both feet on each one, counting out loud. Lauren went beside her not touching. Abe went on the other side, not touching. I stayed up top because somebody has to, and because my throat had closed up again and I didn’t want her to see a deputy look at the flagpole twice in one day.

At the bottom, all thirty-four of those men started clapping. Not loud. Leather gloves on leather gloves. It sounded like rain on a tarp.

Sadie got to twenty-two and stood on the sidewalk, the same sidewalk where she’d stopped dead that morning with her shoes pointed back at the car.

She turned around and looked all the way up at me.

“Twenty-two,” she said.

I got my phone out that night after my shift and called Katelyn. I didn’t know what I was going to say. I told her about a purple coat.

She was quiet a long time.

Then she said, “Mom, what time does your shift start tomorrow?”

“Seven.”

“I’ll drive you,” she said. “I’ll go the Loudon Avenue way.”

Stories of people standing up when it matters continue in the vice principal who took a boy’s flag on Veterans Day and the biker deal that stunned one family. For another family showdown, see the fiancé who asked for the shop deed at the reception.