PART 3: He Knew the Name Written on Our Starter’s Lid

Elena Rostova

Wade came out of the walk-in with a trash bag in each hand.

“Unbelievable,” he said. He set the bags down. “You’ve been telling him our business.”

“I’ve never said ten words to him.”

“He knows the starter.”

“So does the whole internet,” I said. “We put it in the newsletter.”

We did not put it in the newsletter. We don’t have a newsletter. I say dumb things when I’m scared.

Gus didn’t come in. He stood on the step, outside the line of the door, hands in his coat pockets. Like a guest who’d been told to wait in the hall.

“Feed her the rye first,” he said to me. “Then the white.”

I looked at the tea-colored card inside the cabinet door. RYE FIRST. THEN WHITE. SHE SULKS.

“How do you know that?” I said.

He nodded at the crock.

“Lift her up. Look underneath.”

That crock weighs about thirty pounds with the starter in it. We feed it where it sits. In fourteen months, I had never once picked it up, and I’d never seen anyone else do it either.

I got my arms around it and tipped it back against my knees. Manny took one earbud out.

On the bottom, scratched into the glaze before it was ever fired, in that same square, slanted hand, were three letters and a date.

G + A. 3/86.

I sat there on the floor with thirty pounds of Agnes in my lap and couldn’t think of a single dumb thing to say.

“So he washed dishes here in the eighties,” Wade said. “Congratulations. Neighborhood’s full of guys who washed dishes here.”

“I didn’t wash the dishes,” Gus said.

“Then what did you do?”

Gus didn’t answer. He looked at the oven. Just looked at it, the way you look at a car you used to own, parked on somebody else’s street.

Wade waited. Gus didn’t give him anything.

And I’ll be fair to Wade, because nobody else in this story is going to be: from where he stood, he had a fired employee on the floor hugging a crock, an old man in the doorway reading the cabinets, a burned row, and a van coming in forty minutes. I’d have been mad too.

The van came at 5:52. I loaded it myself. Sixty loaves for Linwood Coffee, twenty-two of them sourdough with a fat corner of supermarket yeast in them. I didn’t say anything to the driver. I’m not proud of that either.

When the van pulled out, Wade put his clipboard on the steel bench and squared it with two fingers.

“Okay,” he said. “You’re done. For real this time.”

“We had a deal. Through Friday.”

“The deal was he stays on the crate. You let him in my kitchen.”

“He’s standing on the step.”

“And the twenty-two loaves,” Wade said. “That’s nine dollars a loaf. One ninety-eight. It comes out of your last check.”

I did the math in my head, because I always do the math. My last check was going to be about four hundred dollars. Rent was nine fifty. I had zero dollars in my pocket, because I’d put them in an old man’s.

I took my jacket off again. Second time in an hour. I was getting good at it.

Manny put his earbud back in.

Wade picked up the trash bags. Two in each hand. Yesterday’s bread, the white sandwich loaves and the seeded rounds and a dozen baguettes that were fine, honestly fine, I’d have eaten any of them.

He carried them out past Gus and down the alley to the dumpster. I followed him. I don’t know why. To watch, I guess.

“Give me one bag,” I said. “One. For him.”

Wade unlocked the padlock. He lifted the lid. He looked at me, and then he dropped the bags in, one, two, three, four.

“Watch,” he said. “This is what a free loaf costs, Becca. It costs your job.”

He snapped the padlock shut. The sound went all the way down the alley.

Gus had watched the whole thing from the step. He hadn’t moved. His face didn’t do anything, which was somehow worse.

Then headlights turned in at the end of the alley.

A grey Subaru, going too fast for cobblestones. It stopped a few feet from the dumpster with the engine still running.

A woman got out in a long parka and pajama pants with a pattern of little moose on them. Mid fifties, grey hair pulled back in a clip, no makeup. I had seen her exactly twice, both times at the Christmas party, both times from across the room.

Roxanne Lisowski. Who owns this place.

Wade put the padlock key in his pocket and stood up straighter.

“Roxanne. Morning. I’ve got this handled. This guy’s been hanging around the back door, and she’s been—”

She walked right past him.

She walked past me too, without a glance, in her moose pants, across the wet stones and up to the step where the old man stood.

She took both of his big hands in hers.

“Gus,” she said. “Your hands are like ice. Where are your gloves?”

NEXT: PART 4 →

For more stories where an ordinary day takes a startling turn, read about the three men who confronted a 78-year-old regular, the first twentieth that came without the narrator’s money, and the family dinner that changed when a mother read the messages.