My youth leader kept me outside during games, then our pastor told my mother, “He should try a different group.”
Their church had taken $5,200 to include children like me.
I was beside her when he said it, and by the next service I had decided which part I wanted everybody to hear.
I wanted to stay with my friends, and I wanted somebody to ask ME before choosing another place.
The pastor kept talking over my head while Mom rubbed the same spot on my sleeve.
I’d already taken my coat off.
I pulled it back on.
About a month earlier, I’d come home from Brookfield Chapel with the game still going in my head.
It was a passing game, and I knew exactly who I’d pass to.
“Reagan would’ve caught mine,” I said.
Mom was trying to get my zipper unstuck.
“Did she miss it?”
“I didn’t get a turn.”
She stopped pulling.
I told her Colette had put me on the bench beside the coat hooks while everybody else played.
“All through the game?”
“Until the snack.”
I was nine, and I had Down syndrome, and I knew the difference between waiting for a turn and never getting one.
Sometimes instructions came too fast.
I asked people to say them again, and sometimes they answered Mom instead.
That annoyed me more than getting the instructions wrong.
Mom called Colette while I was still beside her.
She put the call on speaker because I’d asked to hear what happened.
“The running worries me,” Colette said.
“Then change the game,” Mom said.
“We have to think about SAFETY.”
Colette was paid to run the children’s group, but she kept saying there weren’t enough helpers.
Mom said she’d come early next Thursday.
“I can stay.”
“We’ll see,” Colette said.
Mom believed the running part.
So did I.
I practiced catching with her anyway, because I wanted to be ready if they let me play.
My habit was asking everybody their favorite snack before I remembered to say hello.
Reagan always said pickles, which I said should get her arrested.
She laughed even when she’d heard it already.
I’d been going there for five years, and I wanted her on my team.
The next Thursday, Colette let everybody choose partners while I waited with my hand up.
When the last pair moved away, I kept it up a little longer.
“You can HELP by watching,” she said.
I hadn’t offered to help.
In the car, Mom asked whether staying with the group had gone better.
“They picked everybody.”
She turned the radio off.
“Who picked you?”
I pressed the seat belt button before we’d stopped, and she told me to leave it alone.
“Nobody needed another person,” I said.
At home, she wrote to the associate pastor, Terrence, with me beside her.
She read the message before sending it, and I made her change the part about me being upset.
“Put that I wanted a partner.”
She did.
His answer arrived while I was eating breakfast.
Mom read it once without speaking, then I asked her to read it to me.
“He says they CARE about you.”
“What else?”
“He says Colette’s working with what she’s got.”
I asked whether he meant the game equipment or me.
Mom pushed her breakfast away.
She was thirty-four, and she’d been doing all the pickups since my dad, Brock, left when I was three.
I knew her tired face.
This was different.
That weekend we met Haley and Reagan in the supermarket checkout line.
Mom asked whether Reagan had liked the group game.
Haley stopped moving things onto the belt.
“Ask her about the bench,” she said.
Mom turned toward Reagan, but I asked before she could.
“Did Colette say I had to sit there?”
Reagan nodded and held the shopping basket against her knees.
“She said we should leave you alone so you wouldn’t get confused.”
“I wasn’t confused.”
“I know.”
Reagan said she’d tried to sit beside me, and Colette had sent her back to the group.
Then she’d told everybody to give me SPACE.
I remembered Reagan getting up.
I’d thought she didn’t want to sit with me anymore.
That part hurt.
Mom asked if anybody had said anything else, and Reagan rubbed her thumb along the basket handle.
“Some kids copied how he said the game name.”
“Did Colette hear?” Mom said.
“She said to get on with it.”
I wanted Reagan to stop talking, but I also wanted to know the rest.
So I kept my shoes planted beside hers.
Mom didn’t call Terrence again.
For the next eight days, she asked parents whether she could record what they remembered.
I stayed beside her for the calls I wanted to hear.
Sometimes I went away, and afterward she told me which parts were about me.
Thirteen parents spoke to her.
Some had seen the bench.
Others had heard Colette tell children not to pick me because she’d find me something easier.
Mom asked each person whether they’d say it again if someone challenged them.
That question made people take longer.
We used her tablet, the same one I used for spelling practice.
Its case smelled faintly of the hand cream she always spilled inside her bag.
She downloaded the church rules and made the words bigger so we could read together.
“They wrote EVERY child,” I said.
“Yes.”
“Does that mean on game nights too?”
She saved that page.
Then she opened a spreadsheet showing a $5,200 grant for making the children’s group accessible.
The spending column was empty.
She checked another page, then went back.
“Nothing spent?” I said.
“That’s what these records show.”
I helped name the files, and I kept asking her to play the beginning of my recording again.
It was just me explaining the bench.
I wanted the words right.
Then came the Thursday when Terrence told Mom I should try another group.
I was close enough to touch his sleeve, but he spoke as though I’d already gone.
“We think the change would suit him,” he said.
Mom asked whether he’d read her message.
“We’ve discussed it.”
“With who?”
He pressed his lips together and glanced toward the classroom door.
I asked if missing the catch in practice had got me taken out.
Mom bent down so fast her bag slid off her shoulder.
“No,” she said.
“Then I want to tell them.”
She asked whether I meant Terrence.
“I mean everybody who thinks I wanted the bench.”
At the Saturday service, I carried the tablet through the entrance myself.
Mom had offered to leave me with Haley, but I wanted to stay until they’d heard my recording.
My stomach hurt as soon as we got inside.
I sat against the lobby wall, and Mom crouched beside me without asking me to stand.
“We can go,” she said.
I held the tablet tighter.
“PLAY MY WORDS FIRST.”
She nodded, and we went in before the announcements finished.
When she stood, I passed her the tablet with the recording already open.
“I’ve brought the accounts and the parents’ recordings,” she said.
Terrence reached for the microphone.
Aisha caught his sleeve, and Colette moved toward the exit.
Before Mom could press play, Haley stood beside the aisle with her phone held out.
“Kaitlin, this turned up in the church’s drive yesterday evening.”
Haley turned the screen toward her.
“Somebody uploaded it using your account.”
Row nine
Mom took the phone in both hands, the way she carried soup to the table.
I leaned on her arm to see. It was a letter.
Mom’s name was at the bottom, KAITLIN, in big black letters, with a lot of small words above it in a hurry.
“What does it say?”
Mom answered Haley instead of me. “I didn’t write this.”
“I didn’t think you did,” Haley said. “I’m asking who did.”
So Mom read it to me, quiet, the way you read a price you think is wrong.
It said she was sorry. It said she’d made up the bench.
It said she’d asked Colette to keep me out of the games because I got confused, and she’d pushed other parents into saying things they never saw.
It said please don’t spend the $5,200 on me, because I’d be happier with another group.
That last part was Terrence’s sentence. Now it had Mom’s name under it.
Haley put the song words up on the big screen on Saturdays, so she could see into the church’s folders.
She said the letter had popped up at the top of the list last night while she was putting in the hymns.
People turned around in their seats.
We’d sat in row nine for five years, on the end, so I could be first out for snack.
Today it was the worst seat in the building.
Up front, Terrence pulled his sleeve out of Aisha’s hand.
Aisha was his wife.
She did the flowers and the prayer list, and she always gave me two cookies when Mom said one.
He tapped the microphone. It boomed.
“Kaitlin,” he said, out of every speaker at once.
“I’ve had a copy since this morning.”
Five years of Thursdays
He read it like the potluck notices, slow, his glasses on the end of his nose.
Mom stayed standing in the aisle with Haley’s phone in one hand and my tablet in the other.
I stayed standing too. Sitting down would have looked like agreeing.
Here’s a thing about my name.
Colette did the stickers at the door on Thursdays, and she wrote JACKSON, big capitals, a C and a K where my X goes.
I fixed it with Mom’s pen every week and stuck it inside my coat.
Mom said stickers on the car window were a crime, but inside my coat was my own business.
By now the lining was mostly Colette’s handwriting with my X’s on top.
“It’s an X, Colette,” Mom told her once, laughing.
Colette hugged me so hard the sticker folded.
“I’ll get it one day, sweet boy.”
Grown-ups said she was a saint for doing Thursdays.
She said “sweet boy” so often I thought for a while it was my middle name.
On the Thursday Mom came early to stay, Colette met us at the office with her laptop, the one with sunflowers on the lid.
Mom couldn’t go in the room until she’d done the helper form, Colette said. For SAFETY.
So Mom sat at the desk and typed her whole life into boxes while the game started without either of us.
I wanted to press Enter, because I was good at Enter.
Colette pressed it herself, and the little box with the tick too.
“There. Now you’ll never have to remember it.”
She said it like she’d done Mom a favor.
She didn’t let me press one thing.
Then she took me to the game, and Mom answered questions in the office until it was time to go home.
Terrence got to the end. “For everyone’s safety,” he read. “Kaitlin.”
He folded the paper twice. “It came from your own account, Kaitlin.”
“I don’t use that account,” Mom said.
“It came from your account,” he said again, like saying a thing twice made it truer.
Mom held up my tablet and pressed play.
My voice came out of it, small.
“My name is Jaxon. J, A, X—”
Terrence leaned into the microphone.
“Thank you, Jaxon. Let’s give this family some privacy. Let’s pray for them.”
Every head went down.
My recording kept talking into the bowed heads about the bench.
I’d practiced that beginning eleven times.
Praying for somebody who’s standing right there is just whispering about them with your eyes shut.
Mom pressed stop.
We walked up the aisle. Colette was at the back doors.
She held one open for us, the way she did when Thursday was over.
Haley’s front step
On Sunday I asked to go to Reagan’s, and Mom drove me because she didn’t have a better idea.
I brought pickles, the big jar.
You don’t bring the small jar to say sorry for something you didn’t do.
Haley opened the door about the width of a cat.
“Kaitlin, I can’t do this on the step.”
“Then let us in,” Mom said.
Haley didn’t move. “I showed you that letter because I wanted you to look at me and say it wasn’t you.”
“It wasn’t me.”
“Then how is it in your account?”
Mom opened her mouth, and nothing came out for a long time.
“I don’t know,” she said.
She said that to me about dinosaurs.
I’d never heard her say it to a grown-up.
Haley held up her phone.
“Seven parents have texted me since last night. They read it. It says you pushed them, and some of them believe it.”
She looked at the pickles and then away from them.
“Delete mine. Please. Reagan’s still in that group. I can’t have her in the middle.”
“Reagan’s the one who told us,” Mom said.
“She’s ten.”
“She’s the only one who tried to sit with him.”
Haley went red at the edges.
Reagan came down the stairs in her socks and stood behind her mom’s elbow. “Are those pickles?”
I held up the jar.
“Upstairs,” Haley said.
“I’ll say it again,” Reagan said.
“I’ll say it to Pastor Terrence. He can’t make me say it different.”
“Reagan. Upstairs.”
She went up one step at a time, the slowest anybody has ever climbed stairs.
Mom’s phone buzzed. Then again. Her mouth went flat.
“How many?” Haley said.
“Four more.”
Mom sat down on Haley’s step with the tablet on her knees and opened our folder.
I’d named every file myself, the person and their favorite snack, because that was how I kept people.
Haley Grapes. Beard Dad Beef Jerky.
Every one of them had told me their snack, even Beard Dad, who didn’t talk.
Mom held her finger on Haley Grapes until the little trash can came up.
“Mom.”
“They said yes to me, baby. Now they’re saying no.”
It made the crumpled-paper noise. “That’s the rule.”
Twins’ Mom Raisins. Beard Dad. The lady with the walker, Peppermints.
The man who sang too loud, Licorice.
I counted out loud because I couldn’t stop.
Around nine, Haley went inside and shut the door, gently, which was worse than a bang.
Thirteen.
Then Mom’s thumb slid to the last file, and I put my hand flat over the screen.
“Not that one. That’s mine.”
She looked at me a long time. Then she took her thumb away.
Thirteen parents had spoken for me.
Now the folder had one file in it.
JAXON BENCH.
The gift bag
On Tuesday Colette came to our house at half past four with a gift bag, tissue paper sticking out the top.
She’d never been to our house.
She looked around our kitchen the way people look at a gas station bathroom.
“I brought his things,” she said to Mom.
His things were my things. Spare socks. My spelling folder. My rain hat.
My water bottle, with a new sticker on it. JACKSON.
I peeled it off while they talked, fixed it with the pen from the drawer and stuck it inside my coat on the hook.
My coat was getting heavy on one side.
At the bottom of the bag was a flyer.
A group across town, Mondays, “for children with additional needs.”
“Smaller,” Colette said. “Quieter. Kaitlin, it could be a fresh start for both of you.”
I asked her favorite snack. We’d skipped hello, so I was allowed.
“Oh, sweet boy.” She patted my head and turned back to Mom.
Five years of Thursdays and I still didn’t know Colette’s snack.
I knew the bus driver’s, and the bus driver didn’t even like me.
“Did you delete them?” Colette said. “The recordings. People are worried.”
“The parents asked,” Mom said. “They’re gone.”
Colette’s shoulders came down like somebody had let air out of her.
“That’s best for everyone. Now this can stay small.”
“He’s going on Thursday.”
“Thursday isn’t a good idea.”
“He’s gone for five years.”
“And look where it’s got everybody.”
Colette put her hand on Mom’s arm, and Mom moved the arm.
“I’m trying to help you land softly. You put a lot of good people in a bad spot.”
“I didn’t write that letter, Colette.”
“Honey.” Colette picked up her car keys.
“It came from your account. Nobody’s ever going to think anything else.”
When her car had gone, Mom stood in the kitchen holding the flyer.
Then she put it on the fridge, under the pizza magnet.
Ten past six
On Thursday I put my coat on at four o’clock.
Group started at six.
“You’ll cook in that,” Mom said.
“I’ll be ready.”
The children’s wing had a glass door, and through it you could see the bench by the coat hooks and the big room behind.
Terrence was standing in front of the glass.
He was never there on Thursdays.
Colette was beside him with her clipboard, and Aisha was holding a box of juice cartons like she’d been on her way somewhere else and stopped.
“Kaitlin,” Terrence said. “He isn’t on the list tonight.”
“I’m on the list,” I said. “I’m always on the list.”
Terrence looked at Mom. “We talked about this.”
“You talked,” Mom said.
“Let him in. I’ll sit there the whole hour. I’ll sit on the bench myself.”
“Kaitlin.” Aisha shifted the juice box. “Let it go. For his sake.”
Through the glass the passing game was starting. Reagan had the ball.
Haley was in the lobby chairs by the drinking fountain with her phone, and she didn’t look up, not once, which is hard when somebody you know is ten feet away.
I went under Colette’s arm. I was good at under arms.
I got the door open and two steps inside, and Reagan saw me and lifted the ball.
Colette had my elbow before the third step.
“SAFETY, Jackson,” she said, loud enough for the whole room, and walked me back out.
The whistle went. Reagan held the ball one more second.
Then she threw it to somebody else.
Mom got down on her knees on the hall carpet.
I’d never seen her kneel for anything except my shoelaces.
“Please,” she said to Terrence.
“Five years. One more Thursday. I’ll do whatever you say.”
“The letter says you don’t want him here.”
“I didn’t write it.”
“Then who did, Kaitlin?”
Mom stayed on her knees with nothing to say back.
Colette wrote something on the clipboard.
In the car Mom didn’t start the engine.
She put her forehead on the steering wheel and cried, the loud kind, the kind she did in the shower when she thought the fan covered it.
It didn’t. I kept my seat belt on and didn’t touch the button.
When she sat up, her face was wet all the way to her ears.
“Maybe she’s right, baby,” Mom said. “Maybe we try the other group.”
Spelling practice
At home Mom ran a bath and stayed in it with the fan on.
We did spelling at seven every night, even on my birthday, even the night my dad called from wherever he lived now.
So at seven I got the tablet out by myself.
Our folder was still open. JAXON BENCH, and under it the letter.
Haley had sent it to Mom on Saturday night.
Mom had saved it and said she was never opening it again, and every time I asked her to read me the whole thing, she answered something else.
People read things to Mom about me all the time.
Nobody had read this one to me.
So I opened it and made the words big with two fingers, the way we did for spelling.
I was a slow reader, but I didn’t skip.
I am sorry. I made up. Bench.
SAFETY, in capitals, the way Colette said it, like it was yelling from the next room.
SPACE. Capitals again.
Then my name. J, A, C, K.
I put my finger under it and went again.
J, A, C, K, S, O, N.
Mom had never spelled me wrong.
Not on one form, and not on the birthday cake the year the bakery did, because she made them scrape it off and do it again while we waited.
I took my coat off the hook and turned it inside out on the kitchen table.
JACKSON. JACKSON. JACKSON. Rows of them, my X’s on top in Mom’s pen. Big capitals.
I put the tablet down next to the coat.
Then I carried both to the bathroom and knocked with my elbow.
“Mom. Come see how Colette spells me.”
She came out in her robe, dripping on the hall floor, and looked at the coat and the tablet and the coat again.
“She writes loud,” I said. “Like how she talks.”
Mom put her finger on SAFETY. “But it came from my account, baby.”
“Colette pressed the box.”
“What box?”
“On the sunflower computer, when you did the helper form. I wanted to press Enter and she did it, and the box with the tick.”
I said it in Colette’s voice. “Now you’ll never have to remember it.”
Mom sat down on the hall floor in her robe, like somebody had switched her legs off.
“She never logged me out,” she said.
Then she laughed, and she cried, and some of it went on my coat.
She hung my coat by the front door, inside out, where we’d see it first.
The big screen
On Saturday we sat in row nine.
Mom said you don’t sneak into your own church.
I wore my coat inside out.
Mom said I looked like a scarecrow with paperwork.
Colette was at the back doors with her lanyard and her keys.
Terrence was in the big chair up front, and Aisha was in the first row with the flowers.
Haley sat at the little desk at the side where she ran the screen, and Reagan was next to her on a folding chair, swinging her feet.
When the announcements started, I got up, walked to Haley’s desk and put the tablet down next to her laptop.
“Play my words first.”
Haley looked at Terrence. Terrence was already getting out of the big chair.
“Thirty seconds, Haley,” Mom said behind me. “He’s waited a week.”
Reagan reached past her mom and plugged the cord in herself.
My voice came out of every speaker.
“My name is Jaxon. J, A, X, O, N. On Thursdays I sit on the bench by the coat hooks while everybody plays. Reagan tried to sit with me and Colette sent her back. I’m not confused. I want a partner. I want somebody to ask me.”
That was all of it. I’d wanted it right, not long.
“Thank you, Jaxon,” Terrence said into his microphone. “Kaitlin, we were very clear—”
“I’m not finished,” I said.
I took my coat off and held it up by the shoulders, so the whole church could see the lining.
“This is how Colette spells me. Every Thursday.”
Mom came up beside me. “Haley. Put the letter up.”
Haley looked at Reagan.
Reagan looked back like she’d tip the chair over if she had to. Haley typed.
The letter came up on the big screen, huge, and Mom walked to the front and pointed.
Not at the bench part. At my name.
“Jackson,” she said. “C, K. I’ve spelled my son’s name right since the day he was born. And I have never typed SAFETY in capital letters in my life.”
She turned to the back doors. “Colette does. Every week.”
Every head turned around, which was the opposite of last Saturday.
Colette laughed too high. “Half this room spells it that way, Kaitlin.”
“Mom doesn’t,” I said.
“So somebody got into your account. That’s awful. It wasn’t me.”
“You pressed the box,” I said.
Mom said it louder, for the back rows.
“The day I did the helper form, on your laptop. You ticked it and told me I’d never have to remember my password again. Where’s the laptop, Colette?”
Colette didn’t answer.
“In her office,” Haley said. “It’s always in her office.”
Aisha stood up and put the flowers down on the pew.
“I have the office key.”
She walked up the side aisle past Colette without looking at her.
Nobody sat down while she was gone.
Terrence stood on the step with the microphone hanging by his leg.
Mom held my hand so hard my fingers went white, and I let her.
Aisha came back with the sunflower laptop and gave it to Haley.
The password was on a sticker on the bottom, because Colette was a sticker person.
The church drive came up on the big screen.
In the top corner it said who was signed in.
KAITLIN.
On the laptop’s desktop, between a picture of a cat and the Christmas rota, was a file called KAITLIN LETTER FINAL.
Saved Friday, 7:38 in the evening.
At 7:38 on Friday, Mom and I were at our kitchen table doing “because.”
I always forgot the A.
Colette came down the aisle fast, her face blotchy, talking to everybody.
“Do you know what Thursdays are? Twenty-two children. Me and one helper, and the helper is eighty-one. I asked for help for two years. Then a grant comes in, five thousand two hundred dollars, and I go to him,” she pointed her keys at Terrence, “and he says hold it. He says the boy won’t be here by spring, and then it can go where it’s actually needed.”
“Colette,” Terrence said. “That’s enough.”
“The roof,” Colette said. “He wanted it for the roof.”
Aisha turned around and looked at her husband. “Terrence. Is that true?”
He didn’t answer, which was an answer. Even I knew that one.
“I didn’t hurt anybody,” Colette said, and her voice cracked down the middle.
“I put him on a bench. I gave him a SEAT.”
“You gave him a seat,” Mom said.
“And you put my name on your letter.”
Colette yanked her lanyard over her head. It caught on her earring.
She threw it on the front pew with the keys, and they slid off onto the floor, and she left them there and went out the nearest door.
It was a heavy door. It banged.
Then it was just Terrence on the step.
Aisha held out her hand, and he gave her the microphone.
“Ask him,” she said. Not into the microphone. Just to him.
Terrence came down the step.
He was a big man, and he wasn’t used to being short.
He got down on one knee on the carpet, the way Mom had knelt for me on Thursday, and his face was level with mine.
That had never happened before.
“Jaxon,” he said. “Which group do you want to be in?”
I put my coat back on, stickers and all.
“Mine,” I said.
The spending column
In the car Mom laughed so hard she missed our turn and went round the block twice.
Then she parked by the gas station and read me the whole letter out loud, every word.
Every time it said Jackson, I said “X.”
By the end she was saying it with me.
The pickles had been riding in our back seat since Sunday.
Haley had found us in the parking lot after the service, with Reagan pulling her by the sleeve.
“I should have let you in,” Haley said.
“Yes,” Mom said. “You should’ve.”
Then Mom hugged her anyway, because she couldn’t hold out longer than about four seconds.
Reagan took the pickles.
Colette’s job ended on Monday.
She’d run Thursdays for eleven years, and by Monday afternoon her keys were in Aisha’s desk with the sunflower laptop.
Terrence’s name came off the board in the lobby on Wednesday.
Mom drove past on purpose to check.
He wasn’t going up in the big chair again until after Easter.
Aisha said he’d sit on the pews with the rest of us.
Row three. She’d picked it.
On Tuesday after school Aisha came to our kitchen with the spreadsheet and a pen, and she gave the pen to me, not Mom.
“What should it buy?” she said.
I took forty minutes, because I didn’t skip.
A helper for two hours every Thursday, paid.
Haley signed up the same evening.
Soft balls that didn’t hurt when you missed.
Picture cards with the rules of every game, so nobody had to say them twice, or say them to Mom instead.
Blank stickers, so everybody wrote their own name.
Pickles for snack once a month.
Mom said pickles weren’t accessibility.
Aisha said they were now.
On Wednesday night Mom opened the spreadsheet on the tablet.
The spending column had five lines in it, and at the bottom it said $5,200.00.
She checked the cents. There weren’t any left over.
The coat hooks
On Thursday I wrote my own sticker at the door. JAXON. Big capitals.
I’d learned that from somebody.
Nobody was on the bench by the coat hooks.
Haley had put the picture cards on it.
Colette was down the hall with a cardboard box.
Her whistle was in it, and her mug.
Aisha stood a little way off with the keys, waiting for her to finish.
Colette saw me and put the box on her hip.
Her face did the thing it did before a hug.
“Jackson,” she said. “Sweet boy. You know I always did my best by you.”
I hung my coat on my hook, inside out, all her stickers facing the hall.
“It’s an X,” I said.
Then I walked into the big room.
Somebody handed me the new ball, and Reagan put her hands up.
She caught it.
If Jaxon got to you, send this to somebody who always asks the kid first.
For more stories about people being treated unfairly by those close to them, read My Boss Put My Daughter’s Name On An Envelope and My Aunt Moved My Chair Away From My Sister. My Husband Took My Name Off Our Office Door is another story of someone standing up for herself.