My sister came to our riders’ gift collection and took a toy straight out of her foster daughter’s hands. “She gets what I say she gets,” she told me. I almost let family business stay family business, until the nine-year-old dropped the replacement and asked where we kept the things nobody wanted back.
I’d already carried their bags toward the exit, so the child had every reason to think I was helping her leave.
She stayed beside the table.
My sister crooked a finger at her.
“Eden. We discussed this.”
The girl moved immediately, though her gaze stayed on the rabbit I’d put beside my helmet.
Jodi had arrived while we were unloading the last donations at Bellbrook recreation center.
Eighty-six motorcycles had brought more toys than our tables could hold.
Mine still had packing tape stuck across the passenger seat.
I’d bought the cheap kind, and Zach had spent half the afternoon picking it off his gloves.
Jodi hadn’t come to help.
She had brought shopping bags folded beneath her arm and a child I’d never met.
“This is my brother,” she said, before I could introduce myself.
Eden studied my silver beard, then the tattoos above my cuffs.
“Does he know?”
Jodi opened a bag.
“He knows you’re here for Christmas things.”
I waited for the rest.
Nothing came.
There were dolls near Eden’s elbow, but she kept her hands inside her coat pockets.
Jodi chose a sealed building set and pushed it toward me.
“That one. Keep the box NICE.”
“Eden, is that what you’d like?”
My sister answered.
“She changes her mind.”
The girl gave a little nod without looking at either of us.
I pushed the open toy bin closer so she could see what was inside.
She pulled out a rabbit by its ear, then corrected her grip and supported its bottom.
Its ears stayed bent.
She smoothed them several times with her thumb, as though getting them straight might matter.
“That one’s yours,” I said.
Jodi took it.
“She has enough rubbish.”
She put it behind the table, beyond Eden’s reach, and asked whether we had anything with the price still attached.
“For exchanges,” she said.
Zach stopped folding cartons.
“We leave those off.”
“Well, that’s stupid.”
Eden’s shoulders rose.
I knew that look from arguments with my sister, though I’d never seen it on a child before.
I reached for the rabbit.
“There’s room in the bag.”
Jodi held the bag shut.
“Hank, don’t START.”
That was when she told me the child got what she allowed, and I stood there with the rabbit dangling from my hand.
I’d spent years letting Jodi end conversations that way.
I could hear Zach pulling another strip of tape, slowly, without breaking it.
“How old are you, Eden?”
She looked at Jodi.
“You can answer him.”
“Nine.”
“Old enough to pick a rabbit, then.”
My sister’s mouth pulled sideways.
“Old enough to understand NO.”
I crouched beside Eden and held the rabbit near her face, where she could take it without reaching past my sister.
Jodi’s hand came forward again.
I kept hold of it.
“Leave this one.”
She stared at me over the bent ears.
Then she laughed through her nose and turned toward the boxed toys.
“Fine. You can deal with her when she gets like this.”
Eden hadn’t made a sound.
She tucked the rabbit beneath her chin, and I stayed crouched while Jodi checked inside the shopping bags.
“Do you take these away later?” Eden said.
“The empty boxes?”
“The things left.”
“We bring them inside.”
She glanced through the entrance, then toward my sister’s car.
“Do people come back for them?”
“Sometimes.”
That answer seemed to spoil something.
She rubbed the rabbit’s ear against her lip and stopped asking.
I stood to lift their bags, and Jodi finally gave me a smile.
“See? That wasn’t difficult.”
I got as far as the door.
Then Eden said, “Could I wait with the ones they don’t collect?”
I lowered the bags.
Jodi made a clicking sound with her tongue.
“She’s being SILLY.”
The girl stepped behind my elbow.
“Only till morning.”
Zach put the tape down.
I asked him to stay by the table while I moved the bags out of the doorway.
Jodi reached for my sleeve instead.
“You’re my brother.”
“I heard you.”
“Then act like it.”
Her fingers pressed through my shirt, and I pulled my arm free without stepping toward her.
Eden held the rabbit higher.
My helmet sat beside her, its chinstrap hanging over the table edge.
I moved it to make space and released the buckle with my thumb.
The click was small.
The rabbit fell.
Eden caught my vest with a fist and pushed the helmet away with her other hand.
“Please keep me here.”
Jodi said her name, sharply enough that the girl pulled against my vest.
“LET HER FINISH,” I said.
My sister went quiet.
I crouched again and laid the helmet on its side so Eden could see my hands.
She touched the released strap, then pressed its button herself.
“Mine doesn’t have that button,” she said.
The loose strap
“What has a buckle, Eden?”
“The strap on my door.”
I put the helmet beneath the table.
There. Out of her way. It was the first useful thing I’d done without consulting my sister’s face.
“Your bedroom door?”
Eden nodded.
Jodi stepped between us.
“It’s to keep her from wandering. Don’t look at me like that. You don’t know anything about it.”
“No,” I said. “I don’t.”
I picked up the rabbit, holding it where Eden could reach it. She took it by the middle this time.
Zach came around the table. He stayed beside me, with space between himself and the girl.
“Would you like to sit inside?” he said.
Eden looked through the entrance.
“With the toys?”
“There’s a chair right beside them.”
Jodi reached for a shopping bag.
“We’re going home.”
I put my foot against the bag’s bottom. Not on her foot. Not in her way. Against a cardboard corner I could feel through my boot.
“Give us a minute.”
“You’ve got no idea what you’re starting.”
She was right about that. I’d come to unload toys, eat something off a paper plate, and complain about my knees. My plans weren’t built for this.
“Who can we call?” I said. “The person you call about Eden.”
“On a Saturday?”
“The same person.”
Jodi looked past me at Zach.
“Could you give us some privacy?”
He looked at Eden.
“Would you like Hank to come inside too?”
The girl nodded, then stopped halfway through it.
Jodi folded her arms.
“He’s my brother, sweetheart. Remember?”
Eden’s hand came off my vest.
That hurt more than the grip.
I wanted to tell her that sisters didn’t own their brothers. At sixty-four, I ought to have been able to provide evidence.
Instead I moved away from the entrance.
“You can go in with Zach. I’ll stay where you can see me.”
She walked around both of us.
Jodi waited until the girl reached the chair.
“Before you call anybody, remember whose name I gave them.”
My name
Six months earlier, Jodi had called while I was fastening a load to my motorcycle.
“They want someone I can count on,” she’d said.
“For what?”
“If something comes up. Family support.”
“You can put me down.”
“You might have to answer a call.”
“I can answer a phone, Jodi.”
She’d laughed. I’d gone back to the strap.
That was the whole conversation. I hadn’t asked what help meant. I hadn’t asked whether putting me down meant I ought to put myself somewhere near the child.
Now she held her phone between us.
“You’re on my backup plan.”
I looked through the doorway. Eden sat with the rabbit on her lap. Zach had taken the chair across from her, sideways, so his knees didn’t block hers.
“What does the plan say?”
“That you’ll help.”
“I said I’d answer a call.”
“And now I’m calling on you.”
My sister was forty-nine. Fifteen years younger than me, which meant she’d spent her childhood hearing me say, “Leave it, I’ll do it.”
Apparently neither of us had retired.
She brought up a contact and kept her thumb above the screen.
“Kate is her worker. She has an emergency number. Are you really going to make me use it because Eden wanted another toy?”
“The toy’s sitting on her lap.”
“You know what I mean.”
“No. Tell me.”
Jodi lowered the phone.
A rider went past us with an empty carton. She smiled at him.
“He’s making me explain the whole thing,” she said. “Brothers.”
The man kept walking. He hadn’t heard enough to know what smile she wanted back.
She faced me again.
“Kate knows Eden has trouble settling. Ida knows it too.”
“Who’s Ida?”
“Where she goes when I need a break.”
“Does Eden know her well?”
“Yes, Hank. I didn’t select her out of a catalog.”
From inside, Eden said, “Ida has the room by the kitchen.”
Jodi’s face changed.
“You weren’t being asked.”
I moved far enough into the doorway that Eden could hear me without my raising my voice.
“Would you like somebody to call Ida?”
“She might be busy.”
“We could ask.”
Jodi put her phone away.
“Ida isn’t the point.”
But Eden had set the rabbit upright. One ear rested against her wrist. She was looking at the doorway now instead of the floor.
I held out my hand to Jodi.
“The number.”
“You’ll embarrass me in front of everyone.”
I nearly said we could step outside. The old solution. Take Jodi away from witnesses until she’d finished explaining why the witnesses were the problem.
Behind me, a chair scraped.
Eden was standing, ready to follow us.
I kept my hand out.
“The number, Jodi.”
She put the phone into it hard enough to sting.
The chair by the entrance
That Saturday afternoon, I made the call with Eden still in sight.
Jodi stood close enough to hear both ends. I didn’t put it on speaker. Eden had already become the subject of enough adult conversations conducted over her head.
Kate answered after the emergency service connected us.
I gave her my name, then stopped talking.
There was a ridiculous little part of me waiting to be welcomed. Hank, the helpful brother. Hank, who showed up when needed.
“Are you with Eden now?” Kate said.
“Yes.”
“Is she safe where she is?”
“She’s inside the recreation center with another volunteer. I’m in the doorway.”
I told her exactly what Eden had said about the door. I repeated the request to wait with the things nobody collected.
Jodi shook her head through every word.
“That’s out of context,” she said.
Kate could hear her.
“I’ll speak to Jodi in a moment. Hank, don’t ask Eden for more details. Can you keep things calm until I get there?”
“I can stay.”
“That isn’t what I asked.”
“No,” I said. “You’re right. I’ll keep things calm.”
Jodi put her hand out.
I gave her the phone.
She walked several steps away, then remembered that leaving me alone with Eden was apparently worse than having her conversation overheard.
“He’s never met her,” she said into the phone. “That’s what I’m trying to tell you. He doesn’t know her habits.”
She stood with her back to the room.
“Of course I’ll wait.”
I went inside.
Zach had put a small carton on the floor for Eden’s feet. He was thirty-four and could still fold himself into a low chair without making a noise a mechanic would investigate.
He stood when I came over.
“Want this one?”
I shook my head.
Eden kept one hand around the rabbit.
“Is Ida coming?”
“Someone named Kate is coming first.”
“She knows Ida.”
“Yes.”
Jodi came through the doorway.
“All right,” she said. “You’ve made your call. Now can we stop acting like something happened?”
Eden pushed herself back in the chair.
I pulled another chair over. Jodi sat before I could offer it.
She always did have a gift for finding the throne in a room full of folding furniture.
“Hank can come over tonight,” she said.
I looked at her.
“We’ll have supper. He can see everything. You’d like that, wouldn’t you, Eden?”
The girl’s thumb worked along the rabbit’s seam.
I wanted a solution I recognized. A house I could visit. A door I could fix. Some task with screws, rather than a child measuring the distance between grown-ups.
“I could come over,” I said.
Eden slid off the chair.
Her feet landed together.
“Do we go now?”
“No,” I said.
Jodi lifted her eyebrows.
“You just said you’d come.”
“I said I could.”
“So there’s no reason to make a production out of this.”
Zach moved the carton away from Eden’s feet.
“Hank,” he said.
Just my name. No little cough to soften it.
I looked at the girl. She was holding the rabbit against her stomach and facing the exit.
I’d offered to come along. She’d heard me agree to take her back.
I sat down.
“That was a bad suggestion,” I said. “We’re waiting for Kate.”
Jodi stood so fast the chair bumped mine.
“You cannot keep promising this child things.”
“I promised we’d wait.”
“She has to learn adults mean what they say.”
Eden looked at me then.
I deserved that look. I’d managed to turn a promise into a loose hinge within three minutes of making it.
“We’re waiting,” I said again.
Jodi bent to collect the bags.
Zach moved them behind the donation table.
“We’ll sort those out later.”
“They’re ours.”
“They haven’t left yet.”
She stared at him. He rested his hands on the table and waited.
Outside, motorcycles began starting in the lot. Eden turned toward every engine.
Jodi put her coat back on.
“They’ll all go home eventually,” she said.
Zach’s side of the table
Before Kate arrived, Jodi tried to get Zach outside.
She stood beside the entrance and nodded toward his motorcycle.
“Can you help me explain something to him?”
“No,” Zach said.
“You don’t even know what I’m asking.”
“You want me to get Hank alone.”
He didn’t move.
I wanted to be grateful. Mostly I wanted him to stop being thirty years younger than me and thirty minutes ahead.
Jodi returned to the table.
“Fine. Stay right there.”
Eden sat with her chair turned toward the donated toys. She could see us without facing us.
Zach began putting loose toys into shallow cartons. He asked her whether the rabbit needed a place while she rested her hands.
She shook her head.
“All right.”
No second offer. No lesson about being polite. He went back to the boxes.
Kate came in while Jodi was explaining that I had no children at home and couldn’t possibly understand.
She introduced herself to Zach, then crouched near Eden’s chair without touching it.
“I’m going to speak to you away from everybody for a few minutes. Is that all right?”
Eden nodded.
They went to the far end of the room, still in sight, beyond the tables we were using.
Jodi started after them.
Kate held up a hand.
“Just Eden first.”
My sister stopped beside me.
“You know what happens when people only hear one side.”
I looked at the two chairs across the room.
“I know what happens when they don’t hear it at all.”
She pushed her hands into her coat pockets.
“That sounded rehearsed.”
It wasn’t. I would have preferred something clever enough to make her sit down.
Kate came back alone. Eden stayed near the far table with the rabbit.
“I’ve spoken to Ida,” Kate said. “She’s available if we need her. Hank, I need you to tell me what you heard yourself.”
I started at the helmet.
Zach put down a carton.
“Start before that.”
I looked at him.
“She asked to stay,” he said. “Before the buckle.”
“I was getting there.”
“No. You started after it.”
Jodi turned toward him.
“Thank you. He keeps changing the story.”
Zach faced her.
“I’m not agreeing with you.”
Then he looked back at me.
“Tell it from the rabbit.”
There were men in the room who’d ridden beside me for years. Two had stopped carrying cartons. One still had a box against his hip.
I wanted Zach to give me a little room. A private warning. A hand on my shoulder outside.
He kept his hands on the table.
So I told Kate about the rabbit.
About Jodi taking it. About the bags. About the things nobody came back for.
“And you were carrying the gifts out?” Kate said.
“Yes.”
“With the expectation Eden was leaving?”
“Yes.”
Jodi gave a short laugh.
“There. He thought everything was fine.”
“I wanted it to be fine,” I said.
Kate let that sit.
It was an ugly sentence. I couldn’t improve it by adding more words.
“How often have you been at Jodi’s home since Eden came?” she said.
“I haven’t.”
“You’ve spoken to Eden before today?”
“No.”
Jodi’s face went still.
“Tell her you’ve been busy.”
I kept looking at Kate.
“No,” I said again.
Kate asked whether I’d agreed to be available for support.
“Yes.”
“Did you understand what that would involve?”
“I didn’t ask.”
Jodi slapped her palm against the table.
“Don’t make yourself sound useless just to make me look bad.”
A toy truck rolled several inches. Zach stopped it with one finger.
Across the room, Eden lifted her head.
My sister lowered her voice.
“You’re the person I put down. You said I could count on you. You don’t get to stand here and pretend you’re some stranger who wandered in.”
“I should’ve come over.”
“Yes. You should have.”
She pointed toward Eden.
“And now you can start helping.”
I looked at Zach. He wouldn’t give me the easy version of myself back.
Kate closed her notebook.
“Hank, agreeing to help Jodi isn’t the same as knowing what happened in that house.”
My sister picked up my helmet from under the table.
She held it out to me by the strap.
“Then come and see it.”
Four o’clock
By four o’clock, the last donations were inside and Jodi had found a plan she liked.
I would come home with them.
I would stay the night.
Kate could telephone whenever she wanted, and my sister would have her brother in the house to prove everyone had overreacted.
She laid my helmet on the table between us.
“He’s on the plan already,” she said. “You can see he’s willing.”
“I haven’t said that.”
“You said you could come.”
Kate looked at me.
“That doesn’t settle tonight. I need to speak with Eden again, and I’m waiting for a call back.”
Jodi put her hands flat on the table.
“What is there left to speak about? You have an adult who can stay. You have a child who’s upset because a room full of people got upset. Let her go home and settle.”
Kate turned away to answer her phone.
Jodi leaned toward me.
“Please.”
There it was. The word that used to arrive after she’d tried everything else.
I could hear the little sister she used to be. I hated that I could hear her while another little girl sat across the room.
“You’ll sleep on the sofa,” she said. “I’ll leave the doors open. You can sit up all night if that’s what you need.”
“What about tomorrow?”
“We’ll deal with tomorrow tomorrow.”
I rubbed my palms over my knees.
My sister had offered me a job I could do. Stay awake. Sit in a chair. Put my body in the house and call it help.
I nearly agreed.
Then Eden came toward us.
Zach moved with her, a few steps behind.
“She wants to ask Kate something,” he said.
“Kate’s on the phone,” Jodi said. “Come here a minute.”
Eden stopped.
I moved my chair out of her path.
“You don’t have to stand there.”
She went to Zach’s side.
My sister pulled the empty chair toward herself.
“Hank is going to help us tonight.”
“No decision’s been made,” I said.
“We’re discussing it.”
Eden’s face folded. She pressed it into the rabbit.
I got halfway out of my chair.
Zach put his hand against the chair back, not against me.
“Give her room.”
I sat.
The girl shook her head into the bent ears.
“Not his house either.”
Jodi turned toward Kate, who had just ended the call.
“You hear that? It doesn’t matter what anybody offers.”
Nobody had offered my house. I hadn’t thought beyond the sofa at Jodi’s.
Eden had.
Kate came over and sat where Eden could see her.
“You don’t have to go to Hank’s house.”
My sister pointed at me.
“He hasn’t done anything to her.”
Kate kept her attention on Eden.
“Would you like Ida to come here?”
The girl nodded.
Jodi threw one hand toward the ceiling.
“Of course. Ida lets her keep things everywhere.”
Kate stood.
“I’ll call her.”
Jodi stepped in front of me.
“Tell her you’ll stay. Tell her she can trust you.”
I looked past my sister at the child who’d gripped my vest less than an hour earlier.
“Eden, I won’t go anywhere with you unless you want me there.”
She shook her head again.
I wasn’t going to be the man who took her away from this. I couldn’t even be the man who sat beside her.
Jodi rested a hand on my shoulder.
“Now do you understand what I’m dealing with?”
Eden moved her chair behind Zach’s.
Hank’s rules
While Kate called Ida, I stayed in my chair.
Jodi’s hand remained on my shoulder. I moved forward until it fell away.
“Eden,” I said, “I’ll stay over here.”
She looked around Zach’s arm.
“I’m sorry I offered to go home with you before I understood.”
Jodi made a sound through her teeth.
I left it alone.
“And I’m sorry I carried the bags toward the door.”
Eden touched one rabbit ear to the other.
“You didn’t come to check.”
“No.”
Jodi stood.
“Hank, that’s enough.”
I looked at my sister, then back at Eden.
“No, I didn’t come.”
The girl’s eyes went to the helmet.
“She said you knew about it.”
I kept my hands on my knees.
“The door?”
Eden nodded.
“She said they’re your rules.”
Zach stopped moving a carton.
My sister picked up her phone. She didn’t look at its screen.
There was the question she’d cut off when they arrived.
Does he know?
Eden hadn’t been asking whether I knew she was collecting Christmas toys. She’d come to meet the man whose name was already in her house.
I’d given Jodi permission to put me down as someone who would answer a call.
My sister had supplied the rest.
I wanted to stand up. I wanted to use all the height I’d spent the afternoon trying not to bring near that child.
I stayed seated.
“I didn’t make that rule.”
Jodi held up her phone.
“Don’t get into this with her.”
“Did you tell her I did?”
“She hears pieces of conversations.”
“Which conversation?”
“Hank.”
“Which one?”
Kate came back to the table. Nobody had to explain why we’d stopped moving.
Jodi turned toward her.
“He’s upsetting her now.”
Kate looked at Eden.
“Would you like to sit with me?”
The girl nodded and took the chair beside her.
I stood then.
“You used my name.”
My sister’s eyes went to the riders behind Zach.
“Lower your voice.”
I hadn’t raised it. That made me want to.
“Tell her.”
“Tell her what?”
“That I didn’t tell you to put anything on her door.”
Jodi pulled at her coat cuff.
“We can discuss this outside.”
“No.”
She leaned across the table toward me.
“You want to help? Then stop making me the enemy in front of her. You’re her backup person. You can’t be both things.”
I took my helmet off the table and put it beneath my chair.
Then I faced Eden.
“Putting my name on a form didn’t give her permission to speak for me.”
The girl’s fingers stopped working at the rabbit.
Jodi pushed the shopping bags toward Zach.
“Get our things. We’re done.”
Kate remained beside Eden.
“Eden is staying here while Ida comes.”
Jodi looked at me.
I pulled the bags back onto our side of the table.
“First, you’re going to tell her.”
Both bags
Jodi stared at my hands on the bags.
“You’d do this to me over a sentence?”
I said nothing.
“That’s what this is now? We’ve gone from a toy to a door to whether I used the exact words you’d prefer?”
Kate stayed seated. Zach moved beside the table, away from the exit. Nobody blocked Jodi in.
She could leave whenever she wanted.
She couldn’t take the room with her.
“Hank, look at me.”
I did.
“You know I’ve had a hard time. You know I’ve called you and you haven’t come. And now you’re standing there acting like you could have handled everything better.”
“I should’ve come.”
“Then say that to them.”
“I did.”
“Say it like you mean it.”
I took my hands off the bags.
She pushed them toward me.
“Carry these out. We’ll talk by the car.”
“No.”
One of the riders at the far table set down his carton. Jodi turned toward him with a smile that lasted about half a second.
“This is a family disagreement.”
He went back to stacking boxes.
She faced Zach.
“You’ve enjoyed every minute of this.”
“No,” he said.
“You’ve been waiting to tell him what a fool he is.”
“I wanted him to listen.”
“I am standing right here.”
“I know.”
My sister looked at the doorway. Then at Eden.
“Come give me a hug before Ida gets here.”
Eden’s hands closed around the rabbit.
Kate said, “She can stay where she is.”
Jodi’s face crumpled.
I hadn’t seen her cry in front of strangers since she was a child. Usually she waited until we were alone, where the tears could be given a job.
“You all think I’m some terrible person,” she said.
Nobody answered.
She wiped beneath one eye with her thumb.
“I’ve done everything. I get her up. I get her to school. I’m the one there at night. You turn up with a rabbit and suddenly you’re the person she needs?”
I looked at Eden’s chair behind Kate.
“She asked for Ida.”
Jodi opened her mouth, then shut it.
Kate said, “Ida is on her way. Eden will stay with her while we address what she’s told us.”
“For tonight.”
“For now. She isn’t leaving with you today.”
Jodi turned back to me.
“Tell her you’ll supervise. Tell her you’ll come tomorrow too. You said you would help me.”
I could have offered. It was right there, the part I’d played since she was small enough to reach my coat pocket.
I would go. I would fix it. Jodi could tell everybody Hank was handling things.
“I’ll tell Kate what I heard,” I said.
“And what about me?”
“You still haven’t told Eden.”
She hit the table with both hands.
“What do you want me to say?”
The girl pulled the rabbit against her coat.
My sister saw it. Her hands came off the table.
I waited.
Jodi turned toward Eden.
“Hank didn’t tell me to do it.”
Eden looked up.
Jodi looked back at me, as though that ought to buy something.
“All right? He didn’t know.”
“Did I say she had to obey my rules?”
“Oh, for God’s sake.”
“Did I?”
“No.”
She said it toward the room.
Then she faced Eden.
“No. He didn’t.”
Eden’s shoulders lowered. She kept both arms around the rabbit, but her feet moved forward from beneath the chair.
Jodi reached across the table.
“There. Now can you help me?”
I moved my hand away before she could take it.
“Not by sending her back.”
She cried harder then. She said my name twice, the second time like she was calling me in from somewhere.
I stayed on my side of the table.
Kate told her they would need to speak privately about the next steps. Jodi would have a chance to answer. Nothing was going to be settled by a promise from her brother beside a pile of toys.
Jodi shook her head.
“No. He can hear it. He wanted everyone involved.”
Kate didn’t take the bait.
“When Ida arrives, we’ll speak over there.”
Jodi lifted the first bag.
Zach put a hand against its side.
“Those were selected for Eden.”
“They were given to us.”
“Which ones does she want?”
My sister looked at the girl.
“Tell him you want the building sets.”
Eden held up the rabbit.
“This.”
Jodi’s mouth opened.
I shook my head.
She stood holding the bag for another few seconds. Then she let it drop onto the table.
Zach opened it.
The sealed boxes came out one at a time. My sister reached toward one, then folded her arms instead.
He emptied the second bag too.
Two shopping bags. Not one toy Eden had chosen inside either.
Jodi pressed her palm against the boxes.
“You’re humiliating me.”
I moved the rabbit’s empty carton away from her hand.
“These stay.”
The rabbit went first
Ida arrived before the tables were folded.
She came through the entrance without calling across the room. Eden stood as soon as she saw her.
Ida stopped a few feet away.
“Kate said you might want to come stay.”
“Is my room there?”
“It is.”
“The one by the kitchen?”
“That one.”
Eden went to her. Ida bent, and the girl held on around her middle with the rabbit between them.
I turned toward the donations and picked up a box I didn’t need to pick up.
Zach took it from me.
“You’ve already put that one away.”
“Then it’s especially well put away.”
He set it down.
My eyes were wet. I wiped them with the back of my hand, which still had glue on it. That was a fitting finish to my afternoon’s management.
Kate and Jodi moved to the far end of the room. Jodi kept looking back.
Ida stayed beside Eden.
“You want to choose anything else before we go?” Zach said.
Eden looked at the tables.
“Can I keep this at your house?”
Ida touched the rabbit’s bent ear.
“Yes.”
“In my room?”
“Wherever you want to put it.”
Eden looked toward me.
I kept my hands at my sides.
“Does it have to come back?”
“No,” I said. “It’s yours.”
She held it away from her coat and examined the place where one ear folded.
“It won’t stay straight.”
“They came that way.”
She tried it once more, then let the ear lie down.
“That’s all right.”
Zach slid the building sets back among the donations. He turned the boxes so the pictures faced the chairs where the next children would sit.
Jodi’s bags lay empty beside them.
When she came back, she reached for one of the sets.
I put my hand on the box.
“Eden chose.”
“I’m taking it for later.”
“No.”
She pulled her hand away.
Kate stood beside her, and Ida remained with Eden. Nobody pretended to be busy this time.
Jodi folded her shopping bags. She made each crease with the side of her hand.
“Am I even allowed to talk to you anymore?” she said to me.
“You can talk. You can’t put my name down again.”
She looked at Kate.
“You heard him agree he’d help.”
Kate said, “I’ve heard what he’s willing to do.”
I faced her.
“Call me about what happened here. I’ll answer. Don’t put me down as someone who’ll take Eden back there.”
Jodi shoved the bags under her arm.
“So that’s it.”
I didn’t give her an answer she could argue with.
Ida helped Eden fasten her coat. Then she let the girl carry the rabbit without offering a bag for it.
At the doorway, Eden stopped beside me.
“Are you still her brother?”
“Yes.”
Her eyes went toward Jodi.
“Do you have to go with her?”
“No.”
She looked at my helmet in my hand.
“You’re going on that?”
“Once I get the tape off the seat.”
Zach held up his gloves.
“I recommend scissors.”
Eden smiled at him. Small, but there.
Then she held the rabbit toward me.
For a second I thought she was returning it.
“His ear got folded under,” she said.
I freed the ear from beneath her thumb.
“There.”
She tucked the rabbit against her coat and walked out with Ida. Kate went with them to the car.
I stayed by the entrance until Eden was buckled in and Ida took the wheel.
Jodi came up beside me.
Her empty bags made a dry sound against her coat.
“You could still tell them I meant well,” she said.
“No.”
“Hank. I’m your sister.”
I picked up my helmet.
“Not your excuse.”
I walked past her toward my motorcycle.
If this one stayed with you, send it to someone who knows that helping family can mean telling them no.
Family members making decisions that aren’t theirs seems to run in the family – see what happened when a mother gave away the bench her dad built with her and a father hid a car key under a college form. And when another father interfered with his son’s music lessons, it led to a coat in a work bag.