My work apron was still on when I tried the gate. One pocket held a customer’s loose button. The other held the garage key, which had become useless while I was pressing somebody’s trousers.
It was Tuesday, twenty-three days after Curtis’s burial. Vern Haskell had built a cedar fence six feet inside my yard, cutting off the detached garage and my son’s motorcycle.
“Nobody needs the room now, Debra,” he said.
I was sixty-six. Curtis was forty-one when he died. Apparently that left Vern, seventy and retired, qualified to decide what space I needed.
He stood with a post maul and claimed a survey proved I’d spent twenty-three years mowing his property. When I brought up the slab Curtis poured, Vern claimed that too. Anything beyond his fence, he said, belonged to him.
The stone works needed $2,460 by the first, nine days away. Shannon Mills had offered $2,900 for the motorcycle in my kitchen the morning after the funeral. After twelve years riding and wrenching beside Curtis, she knew she was offering too much. Saturday she would bring a trailer.
At three that night, another picture came back: Vern digging beside my forsythia at seven the morning after the funeral. I’d considered bringing him a casserole.
Curtis had painted a steel rod there yellow the summer he poured the slab.
Wednesday’s forty-minute call to the county produced the words civil matter. Friday I tried canceling the sale. Shannon checked whether Vern would be home Saturday and told me to wait.
At 9:15 Saturday, Shannon and seven riders parked eight motorcycles along my curb in Salina.
Vern came out in slippers, claiming the bike and pointing past Shannon.
“She can go sit with her boy at Fairview.”
Two riders removed their sunglasses. Shannon stepped between us, asked about the forsythia, and crouched where I pointed. Vern ordered her away from the loose earth.
She pressed two fingers into it.
“Funny. Curtis painted that rod yellow so it could never get lost.”
The Hole Beside the Forsythia
Shannon drew her fingers out and rubbed the soil between them.
“There’s no rod here, Mrs. Kowalski.”
Vern took a step toward her. I put my hand on the fence post between us.
“Stay there,” I said.
It surprised him. It surprised me a little. At the dry cleaner’s, I could tell a man his pants weren’t ready while he was wearing his undershirt and carrying a grudge. Somehow this man had reduced me to asking permission to enter my own garage.
Shannon moved the soil aside with her palm. A narrow hole appeared underneath, filled with earth that hadn’t settled.
She didn’t pull out proof of ownership. She uncovered the place something used to be.
“When did you last see it?” she said.
“I can’t give you a date.”
Vern made a noise through his nose.
“But I can tell you when I saw him digging.”
His phone lowered.
“Seven in the morning,” I said. “The day after we buried Curtis. Right there. You had your garden shovel.”
“I was helping with the weeds.”
“Where’s the rod?”
He looked at Shannon.
“That woman has no business digging around my fence.”
“Where’s the rod, Vern?”
The seven riders stayed by the curb. Nobody advanced on him. There was no need. He kept looking at them anyway, as if one might offer him a different question.
He pointed toward the alley.
“Over there. Where it belongs.”
Shannon stood up.
“You moved it?”
“It was a loose piece of steel. People put all kinds of things in yards. Her boy sticking paint on something doesn’t make it official.”
My fingers tightened on the post until a splinter went under my nail.
“You dug it out.”
“I put it on the proper line.”
“And who showed you that line?”
He started talking about the mowing. About the garage roof shedding water. About Curtis leaving tools out during the five winters he rebuilt the bike.
Vern had stored twenty-three years of complaints somewhere behind his teeth. Now out they came, each one apparently worth a strip of somebody else’s land.
Shannon let him finish.
“Who did the survey?”
“I don’t have to show you my papers.”
“Show me,” I said.
He turned to me with the patience he used when explaining trash pickup.
“Debra, you’re upset. You’ve been upset for weeks. We can work this out without an audience.”
“You liked the audience when you sent me to Fairview.”
His mouth moved without a word coming out.
I went inside for my house papers.
Nobody cheered. Shannon didn’t tell me I was brave. She came as far as the porch and waited while I pulled the folder from the bottom of the cabinet.
Curtis’s death certificate was lying on top of it. I moved that aside with both hands.
When I came back, Vern stood in the same place. The oven mitt on his porch rail had been there since Tuesday. A man could claim half a yard before attending to one item of laundry.
I opened the folder against my porch post.
The drawing from when I bought the house showed the garage inside my boundary. It wasn’t a new survey, and Shannon said so before I could treat it like a court order. But the corner by the forsythia was marked, and the measurements didn’t match Vern’s fence.
“Who measured yours?” I said.
He rubbed his thumb along his phone.
“I measured from the pin.”
“The one you moved?”
“It was in the wrong place.”
“Who told you?”
“Anybody could see it. Look where the fence runs.”
The fence was his proof of the line. The line was his excuse for the fence. Even I could follow that particular wash cycle.
Shannon held the drawing while I flattened the fold.
“Did anybody survey this before you built?” I said.
Vern stared toward the curb.
“I paid for the fencing. I paid for the materials. I’m not standing here being called a thief over a few feet of grass.”
“You said you paid for a survey.”
“I knew where it went.”
There it was, spoken in front of me, Shannon, and the seven riders.
He’d dug up Curtis’s yellow rod, planted it farther over, and measured from his own mistake. Then he’d built the fence where he wanted the boundary to be.
We would still need someone qualified to establish the line again. But there had never been a survey supporting his claim.
I took the garage key out of my apron pocket.
“Open the gate.”
“Now hold on.”
“Open it.”
He held his phone up again.
“I can still call the sheriff.”
“Do,” I said. “Tell them about the rod first.”
The Key in Vern’s Hand
Vern pressed the side of his phone, darkening the screen.
“You people think you can ride in here and make demands. I’ve lived next to her all these years. Where were you when her gutters clogged? Where were you when that tree limb came down?”
Shannon handed my drawing back.
“Did fixing her gutter buy you her garage?”
“I never said that.”
“You said the motorcycle was yours.”
“Because it was on my ground.”
He was getting louder. The seven riders stayed where they were. I wished he’d stop looking at their boots and look at my face.
“I don’t want your motorcycle,” he said finally.
“Good,” I said. “The gate.”
“The fence cost money, Debra. You can’t expect me to throw money away because you don’t like where it is.”
I nearly apologized. The words actually gathered in my mouth.
That was the worst part. He’d taken my yard while I was at work, trapped the only thing I could sell to pay for Curtis’s stone, and I almost softened my request so he wouldn’t feel put upon.
I put the house papers under my arm.
“Five days,” I said.
“What?”
“I have five days to pay for my son’s headstone. You knew Shannon was buying the bike. I told you Tuesday.”
“I didn’t stop her buying it.”
“You put a lock between her and it.”
He glanced at Shannon.
“If she wants to pay something toward the fence, we could settle this right now.”
Shannon’s jaw tightened.
I stepped forward before she answered.
“No.”
“Be reasonable.”
“No money for the fence. No trade for the land. You unlock it, and you get it off my yard.”
“You’ll get your bike. But you aren’t tearing down a fence I paid for.”
“I’m not.”
He drew a breath, almost relieved.
“You are.”
For a moment the only sound was a car passing at the end of the block.
Then Vern went into his house.
My knees started shaking as soon as he couldn’t see them. Shannon put a hand under my elbow, and I hated how grateful I was for that hand.
“He’s going to shut the door,” I said.
“Then we stay on your side. We don’t give him anything else to talk about.”
She was forty-four, three years older than Curtis. There was dirt on the knee of her jeans. I wanted my son there so badly that for a second I was angry with her for being the one who could come.
Then she squeezed my elbow, and I covered her hand with mine.
Vern returned holding a key.
He stopped at the gate and tried once more.
“This is temporary access. You understand? I’m not agreeing to anything about ownership.”
“You’re opening a gate,” Shannon said. “That’s all anybody needs you to do this minute.”
The padlock was the size of a coffee cup. He fumbled it, caught it, and pulled it free.
I made him step out of the opening before I went through.
Inside the garage, my key turned as easily as it always had.
Curtis’s bike stood under its cover. The radio sat on the shelf where he left it, tuned to the farm report because everything else came through like somebody frying bacon.
I folded the cover back.
Shannon stayed at the door until I asked her in.
“I thought you were bringing a trailer.”
“It’s at my place. I wanted to know whether we’d be allowed near the garage before we brought it.”
“Will it run?”
“It’ll run.”
She checked the bike while I stood beside the workbench. There was a dark place on the wood where Curtis always set his coffee. I’d wiped everything else. I couldn’t make myself scrub that.
Vern appeared in the doorway.
“There. You’ve got it. We can all quit making a production.”
I turned around.
“You told me I could go sit with my boy.”
He looked behind him. Shannon’s seven riders were still at the curb, visible through the gate.
“I was angry.”
“You were smiling.”
“Debra, I didn’t mean—”
“Tell them.”
His shoulders dropped.
“What?”
“You said it in front of them. Take it back in front of them.”
He stood there long enough that I thought he’d refuse. Then he turned toward the curb.
“I shouldn’t have said anything about Curtis,” he said.
Shannon stepped beside me.
“And the motorcycle?”
Vern rubbed his mouth.
“It’s hers.”
“The garage?” I said.
“I’ll let the survey settle the ground.”
“You’ll let a real survey settle it,” I said.
His eyes came back to mine.
“Yes.”
I took a sheet from Curtis’s workbench and wrote down what I needed: the gate kept open, the boundary checked, the fence removed from my land at Vern’s expense. Shannon stood beside me while I read it aloud.
Vern objected to paying. He objected to signing. He objected to the seven people who’d heard him admit what he’d done.
I held out the pen.
He signed.
Then he tried to hand me the padlock.
“No,” I said. “You keep that.”
The Way Out of the Garage
I set Vern’s signed page inside my house folder before touching the motorcycle again.
Shannon sent one of the seven riders to fetch her pickup and trailer from her place. He left his motorcycle at my curb and went on foot; she lived only a few blocks away. The other six stayed with her while I backed the bike out of the garage.
I didn’t ride. I held one handlebar while Shannon held the other, and we walked it through the gate.
Vern stood against his porch rail beside that oven mitt.
At the curb, Shannon took an envelope from inside her jacket.
“Twenty-nine hundred,” she said.
“I haven’t signed the title yet.”
“We’ll do it now.”
I counted the cash on the seat beneath my hand. My fingers kept catching on the edges.
I’d paid $1,920 toward the $4,380 stone during the week of the service. This would cover the remaining $2,460, with $440 left.
I could do the arithmetic. I still counted it twice.
Shannon waited without helping.
When the rider returned with the pickup and trailer, the seven of them helped load the bike. I went inside with Shannon to sign the title. She sat in the same kitchen where she’d made her offer after the funeral.
“You know it’s more than you’d get selling it again,” I said.
“I’m not buying it to sell again.”
I wrote my name.
My hand looked old around the pen. Sixty-six hadn’t bothered me much until I became older than my son would ever get.
Shannon folded the title and put it away.
“You can come see it.”
“I know.”
“You don’t have to, either.”
That was the kindness that undid me.
I cried into my apron, with the customer’s button still in the pocket, and Shannon sat beside me until I could stand.
Before she left, I called Gail at Harlan Stoneworks from the kitchen. The cash lay in front of me. Shannon waited by the back door.
“I’ll bring the balance Monday,” I said.
“All $2,460?”
“All of it.”
“Then we’ll have Curtis ready.”
For weeks I’d heard his name attached to things I couldn’t bear: certificates, bills, clothes somebody thought I should sort. Gail made it sound like someone expected.
I thanked her twice and hung up.
Outside, Vern approached the trailer.
“I opened the gate,” he said. “I’d appreciate you telling people that part too.”
The seven riders stopped fastening straps. Shannon stood beside me.
I looked at the man who wanted credit for turning his own key.
“I’ll tell it in order.”
He went home.
On Monday morning, I took the cash to Gail and watched her write PAID across my receipt. She turned the stone drawing toward me so I could check Curtis’s name one more time.
I put my finger under each letter.
Then I went home for the survey.
Vern had arranged it under the terms he’d signed Saturday. Shannon came back to stand with me. The surveyor checked the records and the remaining markers rather than using the rod Vern had replanted.
By Monday afternoon, the line was marked.
The garage was mine. The fence was six feet inside my ground.
Vern stood beside us while the surveyor explained it. He started talking about where he’d always believed the boundary ran.
I pointed to the marks.
“Do you understand where it runs now?”
He nodded.
“Say it.”
“The fence is on your property, Debra.”
“And the garage?”
“Yours.”
He paid $875 for the survey. Removing the fence cost him another $640. On Tuesday, one week after he’d put it up, the crew took away the boards and posts while he stood on his porch.
I kept the receipts with his signed agreement.
When the last panel came free, Vern came down his steps.
“I hope this satisfies you.”
I could see my garage from my porch again. The path between them lay open.
“It restores my yard,” I said.
He waited for something else.
I went inside.
That afternoon Shannon brought the motorcycle back for a visit. She parked by the garage, where Curtis used to stop it, and took off her helmet.
Gail had given me an installation day for the stone. The balance was paid before the first. There was $440 in my account that hadn’t been there the week before, and nobody had a lock across my path.
Shannon walked over to the forsythia with me.
The surveyor had reset the yellow rod in its proper place. Vern’s shovel had scraped some paint off it.
I carried out a small tin of yellow paint from Curtis’s shelf.
“You want me to do that?” Shannon said.
“I’ve painted things before.”
“I’ve seen your porch.”
“Then you know to stand back.”
She laughed, and I did too. It hurt a little. I let it.
I knelt beside the shrub while Shannon held the tin. The first stroke covered the scrape. The second left yellow on my thumb.
Curtis had been twenty when he poured that slab, twenty-one years before, and I’d asked him why he was painting an ugly piece of steel beside a perfectly good shrub.
“That way it can’t ever get lost, Ma.”
I hadn’t understood how much I’d need to find it.
Behind us, the bike engine ticked as it cooled.
Shannon lowered the tin so I could reach it.
I dipped the brush once more and painted the top of the rod bright yellow.
For another painful neighbor-and-motorcycle dispute, read the story of Walt’s bike locked behind a new fence. You can also catch up on a mother left upstairs with her shoes on and a bride whose father quit the aisle.