My Husband Wrote “Gift” Beside My Retirement Money

Victor Hugo

Once I wired $138,000 to bail out my husband’s motorcycle company, he waited one night before handing me a divorce filing. “You’ve paid for your place here. Now leave,” he said while his girlfriend ate from my bowl. But he’d invited my brother to carry my things out, and neither man knew what I’d actually paid for.

My brother had already carried a tub containing my winter clothes to the door.

He’d taken care to keep the lid shut.

That bothered me more than the papers at first.

Jermaine thought he was helping.

At 8:47 that Thursday, I’d approved the wire tied to Anil’s motorcycle-hauling company.

Five motorcycles stood behind that borrowing.

They were company machines he used for demonstrations and loaned to customers when deliveries ran late.

For months, he’d brought the overdue balance into bed with us.

He’d read messages from the lender while I brushed my teeth.

Then he’d leave his phone beside my pillow.

“You can stop this, Latoya.”

He never asked what stopping it would cost me.

Eventually, I agreed to arrange the money.

He heard PAID.

I hadn’t used that word.

Friday morning, I came downstairs to find Connie kneeling beside an open laundry bag.

My clothes were pushed inside it.

She’d caught a sleeve in the zipper and kept pulling.

“Leave that,” I said.

She tugged again.

Across the kitchen, Danica held my breakfast bowl near her mouth.

She handled bookings for the business.

Anil had introduced her that way at a cookout, then corrected me whenever I called her his assistant.

She wore my cotton dressing gown.

I’d shortened its sleeves myself because they dragged through dishwater.

The crooked stitching sat against her wrist.

I couldn’t stop looking.

Anil lifted the papers from beside the bread bin.

He held them toward me instead of putting them down.

“There’s a pen attached.”

Behind him, Jermaine came back for another tub.

His shaved head was damp from carrying things, and his graying beard had caught a bit of fluff.

He wore his riding vest over a faded tank top.

The tattoos on his forearms moved as he reached for the handles.

Then he read the heading.

His hands stopped.

“What happened to the plumbing?”

Anil’s mouth pulled sideways.

“We needed the stuff moved either way.”

Jermaine straightened.

“You said the floor had to come up.”

Connie closed the laundry bag.

“Please don’t make this difficult.”

Three motorcycles waited outside our house in Batesville.

My brother had brought friends because Anil said I needed HELP moving my belongings while repairs were done.

They’d come before work.

Anil had even asked them to bring straps.

I looked at my husband.

“You called him yesterday?”

“After the payment.”

He answered that easily.

Danica scraped her spoon around my bowl.

There was a chipped place on its base that made it wobble unless I put a napkin underneath.

She kept nudging it flat.

Connie reached for my mother’s picture beside the telephone.

“That can go with the personal things.”

She slid it between folded towels without looking at it.

“All of this is personal,” I said.

“You know the difference.”

I did.

Anil had waited until the money moved.

Then he’d arranged for my own brother to do the lifting while his mother decided what I could take.

Danica hadn’t even waited for me to leave before getting dressed.

My teeth hurt.

I loosened them.

“You can stay with Jermaine,” Anil said.

My brother stepped away from the tub.

“You haven’t asked either of us.”

“She’s got somewhere to go. That’s the point.”

Danica lowered the bowl.

“We could get through this without an audience.”

She’d said WE.

I put my shoulder bag beside the bread bin.

Anil followed it with the papers.

“Don’t settle in.”

Jermaine moved beside me.

He was broad enough that Anil had to shift to keep pushing the pages toward my face.

“Give her room,” my brother said.

His hands stayed open.

Anil grinned past his shoulder.

“She’s had plenty of room. She’s had seven years of this house.”

Seven years since I’d paid to redo the kitchen.

Longer since I’d bought the house itself.

He’d called it OURS so often that his mother had started offering rooms to visiting relatives without asking me.

I hadn’t corrected her in front of them.

That morning, she was stacking my bedding in a tub.

Anil tapped the pen against the paper.

“The business is clear now. We can separate everything cleanly.”

“Clear?”

“The debt. Don’t do that thing where you pretend you don’t understand.”

He still hadn’t asked where the money went.

He’d seen a payment confirmation and stopped reading.

Danica put the bowl down.

“There’s no need to make him explain.”

I turned toward her.

“That’s my dressing gown.”

She folded her arms over it.

“He said I could use it.”

“Put your clothes back on.”

Anil brought the papers higher.

“YOU’RE THE ONE LEAVING.”

Jermaine stepped between the papers and my face.

Nobody touched anybody.

Connie held the tub lid against her legs.

I pulled my cell from the front pocket of my bag.

The account I’d used the day before had sent a notification at 8:56.

Completed.

Beneath it was the reference for the agreement Anil had signed when he still wanted my money.

I opened the message.

The balance hadn’t been forgiven.

And those motorcycles hadn’t been released.

Anil leaned sideways to see.

“What are you checking?”

“The part you skipped.”

His pen stopped tapping.

I closed the message before he could read it.

“Move your things instead.”

Anil looked at me, and I pointed toward the door. “You can start carrying them out now.”

The word beside the amount

Anil put the filing down and pulled a second sheet from underneath it.

It was his proposed division of our property. Beside the $138,000, he’d written one word.

Gift.

He underlined it while I stood there.

I took the sheet before he could write anything else. Below the amount was a sentence saying neither of us would owe the other money.

“That needs your signature too,” he said.

My husband had attached a pen to my divorce like a restaurant attaching a mint to the bill.

“Who called it a gift?”

“You’re my wife.”

Danica got up. For a second, I thought she was going to change.

She carried my bowl to the sink.

“At least rinse it,” I said.

Jermaine made a noise through his nose. Anil turned on him.

“You don’t need to stand over us.”

“I’m standing beside her.”

Outside, one of the other riders called through the door.

“Where do you want this?”

He held another tub against his chest. Terry owned the shop that serviced Anil’s company motorcycles. He’d brought a friend and left work waiting because my brother asked.

“Back where you found it,” Jermaine said.

Anil raised his hand.

“Leave it there until we’ve sorted this out.”

Terry lowered it to the floor. He stayed in the doorway.

I laid the proposed settlement beside the filing, then put my phone on top of both.

“Nobody carries anything else.”

Connie pulled the laundry bag toward her.

“We can’t stand here all morning, Latoya.”

She looked at Anil, not me.

He moved his finger from the word he’d written to the signature line.

“Then sign, and we can all get on with our day.”

The money on Thursday

The Thursday before, Anil sat in that same chair while I opened the agreement on my laptop.

“Both places?” he said.

“Where they’ve marked them.”

He signed for the company first. Then he scrolled down and signed again.

He wanted to know whether the money could move before lunch.

I wanted him to read.

“These are my retirement savings.”

“I know.”

“Then stop looking at the clock.”

He put his hand over mine. I left it there.

That was the part I kept returning to on Friday: I’d left it there.

Now he sat beneath the cabinet I’d measured myself when we redid the kitchen seven years earlier.

The door still needed a lift before it would close. Anil always said he’d fix it.

He found time to arrange an affair and three motorcycles’ worth of moving help. That cabinet had apparently required a rarer skill.

I pulled his proposed division closer.

He’d assigned the house to himself, with a note saying we’d discuss its value later.

His business went to him.

His savings stayed with him.

Eighteen thousand dollars.

“Your savings aren’t helping with any of this?” I said.

“I need operating money.”

“They’re listed as personal.”

“Don’t start picking at the wording.”

Connie put her hand on his shoulder.

He covered it with his.

I’d sat beside Connie during her appointments. I’d taken her calls when Anil said he couldn’t manage another conversation about her knee. She used to tell me I was the sensible one.

That morning she pressed her thumb into his shirt as if he were the person who needed holding together.

“Where did you expect me to live?” I said.

“We said your brother’s,” she said.

“For how long?”

“Until you’re settled.”

Terry shifted at the doorway. His shop bought and sold used motorcycles as well as repairing them; Anil used to send customers there with a warning to check every price.

He’d still trusted Terry with all five company bikes.

I trusted him to keep standing where he was.

Anil reached for the paper.

“You’re making this into something it doesn’t have to be.”

I held the corner down.

“You wrote my house under your name.”

“We can discuss that privately.”

I wanted one conversation without his mother touching him or his girlfriend wearing my sleeves.

“Then come upstairs.”

He brought the pen.

The bedroom door

It was just after nine when we reached the bedroom.

Anil stepped around a laundry bag and went straight to the dresser.

My drawers stood open. His were shut.

One of my bras lay across a tub handle. I pushed it inside before I could stop myself, and hated that too. He could humiliate me in my kitchen, but I was still tidying the evidence for him.

“Tell them to leave,” I said.

“Jermaine can go whenever he wants.”

“Your mother and Danica.”

“They’re helping.”

“With what?”

He laid the papers on my side of the bed.

I wanted him to have the decency to look uncomfortable there.

Instead, he smoothed a page against the quilt.

“You’re going to get advice. So am I. It’ll cost both of us money, and we’ll wind up agreeing to something like this.”

“Something where you get everything?”

“You can take what you brought.”

I put my palm against the bedroom wall.

“This came with me.”

He gave me the smile he used when a customer asked whether a late delivery would be free.

“You get my meaning.”

“No. Explain it.”

He sat on his side of the bed.

“We’ve both put years into this house.”

“I bought it before I married you.”

“And I lived here. I worked here. You think none of that counts?”

He spread his hands.

I’d spent months with those hands rubbing my shoulders while he talked about losing the company.

Now they were measuring out how much of my house he thought should go with it.

“Was she here yesterday?”

“Don’t do this.”

“While I was arranging the money?”

“Latoya.”

He could put more irritation into my name than some people put into a complaint about a broken refrigerator.

I sat on the edge of the bed because my legs needed it.

For one ugly second, I wanted to ask what I could do.

Change my hours. Stop bringing up the overdue bills. Become a woman who ate breakfast in somebody else’s dressing gown without worrying about the laundry.

I pressed my hand into the quilt until that second passed.

“Would you have handed me those papers if the money hadn’t moved?”

He picked up the pen.

“The timing was never going to be good.”

I got up.

He stood too.

“We could keep the business arrangement separate,” I said. “You could leave the house, and we could work out what you owe.”

“I don’t owe my wife for helping our business.”

“Our business?”

“You get my meaning.”

That was twice. Apparently understanding him required me to stop listening to the actual words.

He held out the page.

“Sign this much. Leave the house line open if it makes you feel better. We’ll settle that later.”

I read the sentence beneath his thumb.

It gave up any claim either spouse had against the other, including money advanced to the company.

“Take your thumb off it.”

He did.

“That means the money too.”

“It means a clean break.”

I put the page on the bed.

He moved between me and the doorway, then stepped aside when Jermaine called my name from downstairs.

I didn’t need carrying.

I did need him to keep calling.

On the bed, Anil’s pen lay across the sentence that would wipe out my $138,000.

The sleeve in the zipper

Back downstairs, Connie had reopened the laundry bag.

She held the caught sleeve between two fingers.

“If you’d let me finish, we’d have been done by now.”

“Put it down.”

“It’s stuck.”

“Then stop pulling.”

She gave it one more tug.

The seam opened.

We both looked at the strip of fabric still held in the zipper.

It was an ordinary shirt. I’d bought it on sale and worn it until the collar needed pressing to behave. There was little reason for me to care that much.

I took the bag from her.

“Why would you keep doing that after I asked you to stop?”

Connie sat down.

“Oh, Latoya. It’s a shirt.”

I wanted to put it over her head.

Instead, I worked the zipper backward and freed the sleeve. My hands were having more luck with a broken shirt than my mouth was having with any of them.

Danica came down wearing her own clothes. My dressing gown was folded over her arm.

She laid it on top of the bag.

“There.”

I lifted it off again.

“You could have brought it to me.”

“I just did.”

Anil returned with the papers.

He put them beside my bag, still open to the sentence I’d refused.

Terry stepped inside. The other rider stayed by the motorcycles.

“Anil, are we moving anything or not? We came out of work.”

“Give me ten minutes.”

“You said there was a plumbing problem.”

“There is a problem. We’re dealing with it.”

Jermaine picked up my mother’s picture from between the towels.

He wiped the glass with the bottom of his tank top before putting it back beside the telephone.

That nearly finished me.

My brother could polish a picture without making a ceremony of it. My husband couldn’t hand me a divorce without selling tickets.

“Connie,” I said.

She looked up.

“Did you know this was what he planned?”

Anil cut in.

“Don’t put her in the middle.”

“She was inside my laundry bag.”

Connie folded her hands.

“He told me the marriage was over.”

“When?”

“That’s between you and him.”

“You told me on Wednesday that I should help him.”

“I thought you should.”

“You said he couldn’t sleep.”

“He couldn’t.”

I leaned on the counter. I had called her because I was frightened about using the money. I’d needed somebody who loved him to tell me whether I was being foolish.

She’d stayed on the phone until I agreed.

“Did you know about Danica when we spoke?”

Connie looked at her son.

He shook his head once.

She turned back to me.

“I wasn’t going to discuss his private life behind his back.”

There it was.

My marriage qualified as his private life. My savings qualified as a family concern.

Jermaine put his hand on the counter beside mine.

I kept my eyes on Connie.

“You let me tell you I was scared.”

“You’ve always had more security than he has.”

“Answer her,” Jermaine said.

Connie stood.

“I won’t be spoken to like that in my son’s home.”

Terry moved away from the doorway so nobody was blocked.

I put the torn shirt down before I did something with it that would become the whole story afterward.

Anil took his mother’s chair.

“Can we stop dragging this out? She was trying to help.”

“She did.”

He pushed the papers another inch.

Danica stood behind him now. She put a hand on the chair, close enough to his shoulder to make the point.

Jermaine pulled out the chair beside me.

I couldn’t sit. If I bent my knees, I wasn’t certain the rest of me would remember its job.

Connie picked up the laundry bag.

“Leave my things alone,” I said.

She let go.

The bag fell on its side, and my clothes spilled across my kitchen floor.

The chair he offered me

At half past nine, I sat down because Anil said something that made standing feel like a concession.

“You’re getting worked up. Sit.”

I took the chair at the head of the table.

He’d meant the little one beside the door.

Danica moved her hand off his chair.

Anil opened the filing again.

“Nobody’s saying you get nothing. I’m saying we don’t need to spend everything fighting.”

“Then cross out the gift.”

“No.”

“Cross out the sentence giving up the money.”

“No.”

He didn’t soften either one.

Terry stood near the side door, helmet under his arm. Jermaine remained beside me.

Anil looked between them.

“You’ve brought your brother into our finances now?”

“You called him.”

“To move some things. I didn’t ask for an audience.”

I pushed the page toward him.

“You can take this back. We can each get advice. You can pack a bag yourself.”

“I’m not leaving my home because you’re embarrassed.”

Connie sat down again, close to him.

Danica stayed standing.

The room had arranged itself with considerable efficiency. I could have saved years if we’d tried these seating positions before the wedding.

“You can stay with your mother,” I said.

Connie’s head came up.

“My place isn’t suitable.”

“But my brother’s is.”

“He’s family.”

Jermaine put both hands on the chair back.

“She’s got a home.”

Anil pointed at the papers.

“And we can settle what happens to it, if she’ll stop making threats.”

I hadn’t threatened anything.

I’d asked him to stop claiming my savings were a present.

He tapped the amount.

“This is what you’re going to fight over? After all these years?”

“Yes.”

He put the pen down hard enough to leave a mark in the paper.

“Then understand what that means. The company borrowed the money. The company barely has anything beyond those bikes and the hauling rig. You knew that before you agreed.”

Danica looked at him.

He went on.

“You can spend your retirement chasing a business with no cash. I can’t produce money that isn’t there.”

His eighteen thousand dollars sat two pages underneath his hand.

I could picture the balance in my own account after the wire. I’d left enough for ordinary life, because I’d thought ordinary life was what would happen next.

A furnace breaking, perhaps.

Not this.

Jermaine bent toward me.

“We can go out for a minute.”

I nearly said yes.

I could put my feet on his porch and let him find me something to eat. He’d give me his bedroom and pretend the sofa suited his back. By noon, he’d have my mother’s picture standing somewhere safe.

Anil could spend that same hour describing how I’d left.

I put my bag on my lap.

His shoulders lowered.

“That’s better,” he said. “We can talk when you’ve calmed down.”

I took out my phone.

Connie reached for the settlement.

“Leave her the pen, Anil.”

I had asked these people for twenty minutes to stop treating me like a visitor.

My husband was already checking the time.

He slid the pen toward me with one finger.

“Take the loss, Latoya. You’re going to anyway.”

His second signature

I opened the agreement on my phone and put it in front of him.

“Read the heading.”

“I’ve read it.”

“Then read it to your mother.”

He pushed the phone back.

I moved to the page with his signatures.

The first was for the company. The second was his own promise to repay the debt if the company couldn’t.

He’d signed that promise when he first borrowed. On Thursday, he’d signed again to confirm it stayed in force when I bought the lender’s debt.

My money had bought their place.

It hadn’t erased his obligation.

“That’s just the transfer paperwork,” he said.

“Transfer to whom?”

He said nothing.

Danica leaned over the table.

“What transfer?”

Anil put his hand over the screen.

“Don’t start. She knows what the understanding was.”

I lifted the phone out from under his palm.

On Thursday I’d told him plainly that I couldn’t give away my retirement. He’d said he understood. Then he’d asked how soon the money would move.

Now he pointed at the divorce settlement.

“We can put this right here.”

He meant the word gift.

I turned the phone toward Connie.

“The company owes me. If it can’t pay, he does.”

Anil stood.

“You’d do that to me?”

I left him standing.

“Terry. What would the bikes and the rig bring together?”

Anil turned toward the door.

“Don’t involve him.”

Terry looked at me before answering.

“I’d need to inspect everything. I know the bikes. I could make a written offer through the shop.”

“This isn’t a sale,” Anil said.

“No,” I said. “It’s a debt.”

He picked up the settlement and folded it against his palm.

For all his talk about clean breaks, he was suddenly having trouble with one sheet of paper.

I put my phone back in my bag.

“You can arrange repayment, or I’ll have the agreement enforced. You can get advice before you choose.”

Danica pulled out the chair he’d vacated.

“Anil,” she said. “What did you sign?”

The people he called

Anil didn’t answer Danica.

He pointed at Terry instead.

“I know what you’ll do. You’ll give me some insulting price because you think I’m stuck.”

“Then don’t sell to me,” Terry said.

“I’ve sent you work.”

“And I’ve charged you for it. Same as everybody else.”

Jermaine took the settlement from my husband’s hand and laid it flat on the table.

He didn’t tear it up. I’d have enjoyed that for about three seconds, then needed another copy.

Anil pulled it back.

“This is between my wife and me.”

Danica stared at him.

He turned toward her.

“You get my meaning.”

Apparently he was offering a group discount on that sentence.

I took the page and drew a line through gift.

Then I crossed out the sentence giving up the debt.

“I’m not signing this.”

Anil held out his hand.

“Give me the pen.”

I set it down.

He stayed standing over the table.

“You knew I was under pressure. You knew what would happen if the lender took the machines. Now you’ve put yourself in the same position and you’re going to act like I should thank you.”

“I haven’t asked for thanks.”

“You were supposed to help me.”

“I did.”

Connie began to cry.

I had never been able to sit through her crying without reaching for something. A tissue. Her hand. My purse.

I stayed in my chair.

“You’ll ruin him,” she said.

“He’s got the same debt he had yesterday.”

“He can’t pay it all at once.”

“He could have asked about that before he packed my clothes.”

Anil leaned toward me.

“Fine. We slow everything down. Nobody has to move today. Danica can go home, Mom can go home, and we talk.”

Danica pushed her chair back.

“Don’t send me home because you haven’t sorted your money.”

“I’m trying to sort it.”

“You told me it was sorted.”

She looked at my bag, then at him.

“You said the company was clear.”

“Because the payment went through.”

“To buy the debt,” I said.

Anil hit the table with his palm.

“I understand that now.”

Terry set his helmet on the floor.

He didn’t move toward Anil.

Jermaine stepped closer to my chair.

My husband looked at both men, then pulled his hand off the table.

I wanted to shout. I wanted to read every message he’d sent about that company and make him sit through each one.

Instead, I pulled the divorce filing toward me.

“These can go through the proper way. That page you wrote doesn’t decide anything.”

He looked at the filing as if I’d changed its contents.

“And tonight?”

“Pack your things.”

“You can’t just throw me out.”

“You can choose to go. Or we can deal with the house separately. I’m not leaving it.”

Connie wiped her face.

“Come with me, Anil.”

Her unsuitable home had developed capacity.

He didn’t look at her.

“If I sell the machines, there’s no company.”

Terry picked up his helmet.

“I can inspect them tomorrow. No promises about a price until then.”

Anil’s eyes went to Danica.

She folded her arms.

“Don’t look at me. You said she agreed.”

I stood and took my dressing gown off the laundry bag.

“You can take advice,” I said. “You can find another buyer. But my money isn’t a gift.”

For a moment, he looked toward my brother as if there might still be some reasonable man-to-man arrangement available.

Jermaine picked up the tub nearest the door.

“Where does this go, Toya?”

“Upstairs. Back in my room.”

He carried it past Anil.

Terry moved the next tub out of the doorway. His friend came inside when he called, and the two of them took it upstairs together.

Anil remained beside the pen.

Nobody asked him where anything went.

The clothes going upstairs

By ten that Friday morning, my things were moving back into my bedroom.

Anil packed a bag while Jermaine stood in the hall.

I stayed downstairs.

Connie knelt to collect the clothes she’d spilled. She folded the torn shirt with the damaged seam tucked underneath.

“That one goes on top,” I said.

She put it on top.

Danica lifted my bowl from the sink.

“I’ll wash this.”

“Yes.”

She washed it. She dried it too.

Then she set it on the counter, where it wobbled.

I put a folded napkin beneath it.

Neither of us said anything about that.

Anil came downstairs carrying his bag.

He stopped beside me.

“Are you really going to make me sell them?”

“I’m going to require repayment.”

“And if Terry’s price is low?”

“Find a better one.”

He shifted the bag to his other hand.

There was no kiss at the door. No attempt to touch my shoulder.

He looked at the papers.

“I need those.”

I gave him his proposed settlement. I kept the copy of the filing he’d brought for me.

The word gift had a line through it.

Connie followed him out. Danica went after them with her own bag.

Jermaine returned to the kitchen as their car doors closed.

He stopped in front of me.

“I carried your clothes out.”

“You put them back.”

“I should’ve called you before I came.”

“Yes.”

He nodded.

I hadn’t wanted an apology that required me to spend another half hour telling a man he’d done nothing wrong.

He put his arms around me.

I pressed my face against his vest and cried hard enough that I had to move my mouth away from the leather to breathe.

He held on.

Terry came down with the last empty tub.

“Saturday morning,” he said. “I’ll inspect the bikes. You don’t have to come.”

“I’ll come.”

My brother loosened his arms.

I picked up the torn shirt.

“First, help me get this upstairs.”

Five motorcycles and the hauling rig

On Saturday, Terry inspected all five motorcycles and the hauling rig with Anil and me present.

He wrote down what needed work. Anil argued over a tire until Terry handed him the gauge.

The reading didn’t improve when my husband held it.

Terry offered $120,000 for the lot.

Anil had the following week to seek a better price and take advice. He did both. By Friday, he accepted Terry’s offer.

On Monday, ten days after that kitchen scene, we met at the yard.

Terry’s shop bought all five motorcycles, the truck and its trailer. The full $120,000 went toward the debt.

Anil stood near the trailer while the bikes were strapped down.

Jermaine checked the straps with Terry.

This time, my brother knew exactly what he was helping to move.

Anil came over to me before they closed the trailer.

“That’s everything I built.”

I looked at the machines.

“That’s part of what you borrowed.”

He opened his banking app.

The remaining $18,000 of principal came from the savings he’d assigned to himself in his proposed settlement.

He showed me the confirmation.

I checked my own account.

“Received.”

He put his phone away.

“Then we’re done.”

“Interest.”

He shut his eyes.

The agreed payoff included $226.85 in interest through that Monday. He’d received the figure before coming to the yard.

He took his phone out again.

Danica wasn’t there to handle the booking.

Connie wasn’t there to call things difficult.

He entered $226.85, showed me the screen, and sent it.

That cleared the debt. I signed the receipt and the releases for the vehicles.

Terry took the keys.

Anil lost five company motorcycles and the hauling rig. His $18,000 savings balance went to zero.

I received $138,226.85.

The later divorce agreement left my house in my name. Anil collected his remaining belongings from the porch himself.

When he asked whether I’d found his pen, I handed it to him.

“That’s yours.”

If this one got to you, send it to someone who’s been told their savings belong to everybody but them.

For more family drama tangled up with money and old resentments, read the story of a brother who counted Dad’s ring against a debt and the sister who put their mother’s helmet under Kasey’s chair. And for another painful family slight, there’s the daughter who set a neighbor’s supper tin beside the trash.