My Husband Checked His Watch While I Lay Beneath the Bench

James Carter

The clasp on my purse was broken. I’d meant to replace it before the hearing, but at twenty-nine weeks pregnant with twin girls, bending over a department-store counter ranked below sitting down.

When Shelby shoved me into the rail, everything fell out.

My husband’s twenty-five-year-old “office manager” waited until Wade, the deputy, turned toward the exit. Then she claimed I’d lost my balance. Her white sneaker pushed Tuesday’s ultrasound beyond my hand.

Darren checked his watch.

“Get up, Kris, nobody’s buying it.”

Seven years married, and he sounded annoyed about a dropped grocery bag.

He wanted my signature on an offer I’d kept for nineteen days: $22,400, while he retained the house, our joint checking and the nursery fund. His lawyer, Gerald Pruitt, also had a parenting plan for daughters neither of us had held.

Marcy knelt beside me. I told her I’d landed on my side. Both girls kicked while Pruitt produced exhibit six.

February. The ice storm. Darren had shut me in the garage, locking the door into the house, and I’d fallen in slippers coming around the side. At the hospital, with him holding my coat, I’d blamed the recycling.

My keys stopped below the judge’s steps.

Judge Whitcomb had white hair now, but I’d recognized her immediately. At nine, when my name was Krista Pell, I’d lived with her for seven months. Before the county returned me to my mother, she’d clipped her phone number to my coat in a bus-pass sleeve.

At fourteen, I’d called and reached a disconnected line.

The sleeve stayed.

She stood and directed Wade to bring her the keys. She examined the green handwriting, removed her glasses, and stopped Pruitt’s denial.

“I WATCHED HER DO IT, COUNSELOR.”

Darren said we’d met eight years ago.

The judge held my keys.

“I met her twenty-six years ago,” she said.

The Number in Green

Pruitt pulled his chair closer to Darren. The legs scraped the floor, and my husband leaned toward him as if the two of them could get smaller together.

Judge Whitcomb set the keys beside her gavel and picked up the desk phone.

“Whitcomb, courtroom four. Get me the DA. I’ll hold.”

Shelby uncrossed her arms.

“I said I barely touched her.”

“Stay where the deputy directs you,” the judge said.

Wade moved between Shelby and me. He looked younger than twenty-six, but he no longer looked distracted.

Marcy put her folded jacket behind my head. I wanted to sit up, collect my crackers and make the room stop staring. Thirty-five years old, on a courtroom carpet, and I was still concerned about inconveniencing people.

“An ambulance is coming,” Marcy said. “Don’t get up for him.”

Darren stood then.

“Nobody needs an ambulance. She’s talking.”

Marcy turned her head.

“Sit down, Darren.”

He looked toward the bench for somebody to object to her tone. The judge was speaking into the receiver.

“I witnessed an assault on a pregnant litigant. I need an investigator here. I’m a witness, and I also have a prior personal relationship with the injured woman. Another judge will need to handle the underlying case.”

She gave the room number again and put the phone down.

Darren reached for his settlement folder.

“Then we should finish what we came here for before this becomes something else.”

Judge Whitcomb looked at the folder.

“There will be no settlement entered today.”

“We’ve been working on this for weeks.”

“She has not signed it.”

“She agreed to consider it.”

“That is all she agreed to.”

Pruitt rose halfway out of his chair. He began to speak about exhibit six and medical history, and she stopped him.

“The characterization you just made will be struck. That exhibit is not admitted. Any future request to admit it belongs before the next judge, with proper foundation.”

His mouth stayed open a moment.

“And I am recusing myself from the divorce,” she said. “The clerk will arrange reassignment. Today’s proceeding is adjourned.”

Nothing in Darren’s folder had become an order. No house awarded to him. No money handed over. No signature.

He’d brought a pen for me and left it uncapped beside his hand.

Shelby tried to move around Wade.

“Darren, tell them.”

He looked at Pruitt.

For once, she had to wait longer than half a second for his response.

By the time the paramedics reached me, an investigator was taking Shelby’s name at the doorway. Wade retrieved my belongings, including the ultrasound, and gave them to Marcy. Shelby left with the investigator and the deputy, protesting that everyone was making too much of a touch.

Her sneakers made no sound on the carpet.

Darren started toward the stretcher.

I lifted my hand.

“No.”

He stopped close enough for me to see the suit fabric. I’d bought that charcoal suit before his sister’s wedding. I’d hemmed the trousers sitting on our bedroom floor because he didn’t want to pay the alteration charge.

“Kris. Come on.”

“Don’t come with me.”

He looked past me at the judge.

“This is because you know her?”

“No,” I said. “It’s because I know you.”

Marcy walked beside the stretcher. Behind us, Darren was left with Pruitt, an unsigned offer and a morning that had produced nothing he wanted.

Judge Whitcomb came to the doorway carrying my keys.

She had taken off her robe. The plum cardigan beneath it had a loose button near the bottom, and for a second I could almost smell the rice she used to cook.

“I won’t discuss your case,” she said. “Marcy, you should stay.”

“I’m staying,” Marcy said.

The paramedics paused while she put the keys into my hand.

“I called,” I said.

Her fingers stopped against mine.

“When?”

“I was fourteen. From a gas station pay phone. It said the number wasn’t in service.”

She closed her eyes.

“Oh, Krista.”

I’d imagined plenty of explanations over twenty-one years. She’d moved. She’d forgotten. She’d been relieved when the seven months ended.

I hadn’t imagined that face.

“It was the public defender’s line,” she said. “They disconnected it after I left the office. I thought my forwarding information would reach you.”

“It didn’t.”

“No. It didn’t.”

She opened her handbag and took out a wallet. Behind a photograph was a card, cleaner than mine, with the same phone number in green.

“I made two,” she said. “Yours and one for my purse, so I could give people the office number without hunting for it.”

She held it against my sleeve. Same uneven seven. Same heavy dot after the area code.

“I kept it after you left. I asked the county for news, left letters to be passed along. They couldn’t give me your family’s address. Later, I searched for Krista Pell.”

“I married.”

“I know that now.”

Her thumb pressed the edge of her card.

“I didn’t stop wanting you to call.”

I began crying then, with the stretcher straps across my legs and a stranger checking my blood pressure.

She bent close enough that I didn’t have to speak loudly.

“I thought you’d gone.”

“I’m here,” she said. “May I come to the hospital?”

This time, I didn’t make myself ask twice.

The Chair Beside My Bed

“Yes,” I said, and she stepped back so the paramedics could take me through the doors.

Marcy rode with me. Lorraine followed separately.

I called her Lorraine in my head because that’s what I’d called her at nine. Calling her Judge Whitcomb while she held my purse would have been like calling my old school shoes formal footwear.

At the hospital, the monitors went around my belly. I lay still while a nurse found one heartbeat, then the other.

There was no instant announcement that everything was fine. There were questions, examinations, and waiting. Every time someone adjusted a strap, my hands went cold.

Marcy sat on one side of the bed. Lorraine waited near the foot until I pointed to the other chair.

“You can sit.”

“I didn’t want to crowd you.”

“You used to check my forehead while I was asleep.”

“You used to sleep with a knitted hat on.”

“It had a horse.”

“It had half a horse. You cut the rest off.”

I laughed, then cried again. Pregnancy had reduced my emotional controls to a light switch somebody else’s children could reach.

Lorraine passed me a tissue without telling me to calm down.

Marcy put the ultrasound on the bedside cabinet. There was a faint mark across the corner where Shelby’s shoe had touched it.

I rubbed it with my thumb.

“You don’t have to clean it now,” she said.

“I know.”

I kept rubbing.

After the doctor left us waiting for another stretch of monitoring, Marcy took out her notebook.

“We can do this later.”

“No,” I said. “Ask me.”

She glanced at Lorraine.

“I can go outside,” Lorraine said.

“Stay. Please.”

Marcy rested the notebook on her knee.

“Tell me about February.”

My eyes went to the coat hook on the back of the door.

Darren had held my coat at that hospital, too. Such a husbandly thing, a man holding a coat. People had smiled at him.

“We argued,” I said. “I went into the garage to get space. He shut the door between the garage and the house. Then he told me to come around the front.”

“During the ice storm?”

“Yes.”

“Did he know you were in slippers?”

“He looked at my feet.”

The monitor kept up its noise. Lorraine sat with both hands clasped around her wallet.

“I fell coming around the side. He let me in after I knocked. At the hospital he told the nurse I’d been taking out the recycling. When she asked me, I said yes.”

Marcy wrote without interrupting.

“Did he tell you what to say?”

“He said we didn’t need people thinking he couldn’t look after his wife.”

The sentence sounded worse in that room. There was no kitchen to clean afterward, no television to turn up, nowhere for it to disappear.

“I lied,” I said.

“You repeated his account while he stood beside you,” Marcy said. “We’ll correct it. In your words.”

“What if they don’t believe me?”

“We give them the facts we can support. We don’t promise what anyone will decide.”

That answer steadied me more than a guarantee would have.

Lorraine reached across the bed, palm up. I put my hand in hers.

For seven years, I’d made Darren’s version easier to live with by helping him tell it. That morning, he’d tried to use my help as evidence against me.

Marcy slid the notebook closer.

“Do you still want to accept the offer?”

“No.”

“Then I’ll reject it in writing today.”

I stared at the monitor.

“He says if I fight, there won’t be anything left.”

“He has six tire shops,” Marcy said. “We can afford to ask where the money is before deciding there’s none.”

I let out a breath that shook all the way through me.

“I can’t afford to keep you forever.”

“We’ll discuss costs before we take each step. Today, your job is staying here until the doctor says you can leave.”

Lorraine squeezed my hand.

My phone began vibrating inside the purse.

Darren.

Marcy set it on the cabinet where I could see the screen without reaching.

I let it stop.

A message arrived.

We need to talk before your lawyer makes this worse.

Then another.

Shelby is upset too.

I handed the phone to Marcy.

“Keep those.”

She saved them while I watched. That mattered. I needed to see myself permit a small piece of his behavior to exist somewhere he couldn’t talk me into deleting it.

Lorraine took a pen from her handbag.

“May I?”

She pointed to the cracked sleeve.

I pulled the keys closer.

“Don’t throw that card away.”

“I wouldn’t.”

She wrote her current number on the back of a fresh card, then put her old card beside mine.

“This one is my cell. You can test it before I leave.”

I dialed.

Her handbag rang against the chair. She answered without looking away from me.

“Hello, Krista.”

My throat hurt.

“Hello.”

Marcy looked down at her notebook. She was kind enough to give us that much privacy.

The monitoring continued through the afternoon. When the doctor finally said both girls looked reassuring and I could leave with instructions, I asked Marcy where I should go.

Lorraine didn’t answer for her.

She waited until I turned toward her.

“I have a spare room,” she said. “You can have the door open or shut.”

I cried harder at that than at the offer of the room.

Marcy stood and handed me my purse.

“I’ll tell Darren communication goes through me.”

For the first time that day, I reached for my own shoes.

The Unsigned Page

Lorraine held the chair while I put them on. Then she drove me to her house, and Marcy sent the rejection before we left the hospital parking lot.

I slept that night with the bedroom door open.

The following morning, I sat beside Lorraine while she called a locksmith to change her spare-room window latch. It stuck, and she didn’t want me struggling with it.

She asked before making the call.

Such a small question. I almost answered it with an apology.

Six weeks later, Marcy met me outside a conference room at the courthouse. I was thirty-five weeks along, and my feet had become an argument with every shoe I owned.

Lorraine waited downstairs. She had no part in negotiating my divorce. Her statement about the shove had gone to the investigator, and another judge handled the case.

Inside the room, Darren sat beside Pruitt. Shelby sat near the door with her own lawyer. The assault case had brought us back on the same morning; the settlement discussion afterward was our choice.

I had agreed to hear an apology from Shelby. I hadn’t agreed to make her comfortable giving it.

She looked at my belly before she looked at my face.

“I shouldn’t have pushed you.”

Darren shifted in his chair.

Pruitt put a hand flat on the folder in front of him.

Shelby swallowed.

“I told them you fell. That was a lie.”

“Yes,” I said.

“I was angry.”

I waited.

Her lawyer leaned toward her, but she kept looking at me.

“I thought you were dragging everything out. That’s what Darren kept saying.”

Darren sat forward.

“I never told you to touch her.”

“No,” Shelby said. “You just sat there afterward.”

He opened his mouth, then looked at the lawyers.

There was nowhere friendly to put his eyes.

Shelby’s case ended that morning with a guilty plea to the assault charge, probation, community service and an order to have no contact with me. The exact consequences had been read aloud in court. Here, she had to say what she’d done without calling herself an office manager or calling me unsteady.

“I’m sorry,” she said.

I held the purse on my lap.

“You could have hurt my daughters.”

Her eyes filled.

“I know.”

“Remember that.”

She left with her lawyer. Darren didn’t follow her.

Pruitt opened the divorce agreement, the one negotiated after Marcy demanded the financial records and corrected the story attached to exhibit six.

Darren had spent the intervening weeks proposing variations on the same arrangement: he kept control, and I accepted a smaller sum for the privilege of ending the argument.

Marcy had kept answering with numbers.

Now the house would be sold. After the mortgage and sale costs, we would divide the proceeds equally. Half the joint checking balance would be transferred to an account in my name. The nursery fund would remain intact for the girls, with neither parent allowed to empty it alone.

He would keep the six tire shops and pay the agreed amount for my share of the marital business value: $186,400.00.

I read the cents twice. Two zeroes had never looked so respectable.

Medical expenses and support had their own terms. Parenting arrangements would be considered after the babies arrived, based on their needs, rather than the page Darren had drafted before birth.

The $22,400 offer lay beneath the new agreement in Pruitt’s folder.

Darren tapped it.

“We could have avoided all this.”

Marcy turned the signature page toward him.

He ignored it.

“Kris, you know I’m going to have to borrow against the business.”

I said nothing.

“You think money just sits there? There are employees. Equipment. You’ve never had to worry about any of that.”

Pruitt said his name.

Darren pushed back from the chair.

“And now the house. You wanted that house.”

“I wanted to be safe in it.”

He rubbed his forehead.

“I was angry in February. I shouldn’t have locked the door. But you made it sound like I threw you out into the street.”

Marcy’s pen stopped.

Nobody had asked him to explain February. He’d volunteered.

Darren looked at me.

“You could say something.”

“I did.”

He stood beside his chair for another moment. Then Pruitt tapped the page, and he sat down to sign.

His hand shook enough to make the paper move.

When he finished, he pushed the pen across to me. The same brand he’d brought to the first hearing.

I used Marcy’s.

Outside the room, he came after us.

“Kris.”

I stopped. Marcy stayed beside me.

He looked tired now. I could acknowledge that without offering to fix it.

“You’re really going to let seven years end like this?”

“You ended them on the floor.”

I walked toward the elevator before he could tell me what I meant.

The house sold after the girls were born. The agreed transfers cleared. Marcy showed me each amount, and I checked each one against the agreement instead of asking whether Darren thought it was fair.

I rented a place near Lorraine, with room for two cots and a chair wide enough to feed one baby while the other slept against my shoulder.

On moving day, Lorraine stood at the nursery door holding the ultrasound. I’d put it in a frame without trying to erase the mark on its corner.

“Here?” she said.

“A little lower.”

She moved it down.

The girls were asleep in their cots. I stood between them with my keys in my hand, the cracked sleeve hanging beside the new house key.

Lorraine reached for her coat.

“I’ll let you settle.”

“You can stay.”

She took the coat off again.

I put my keys on the hook by the nursery door, then lifted one of my daughters into her arms.

For more stories about family betrayal and the strength it takes to stand your ground, read “My Daughter Kept My Deed and Brought Her Key”, “My Sister Left My Son Off the Dinner Order”, and “My Son’s Wife Left My Spare Key On My Stair”.