My Father Offered My Daughter $600 Beside The Swim Spa

Chloe Bennett

My mother and father cashed in my daughter’s violin for $94,000 to put a swim spa in for my brother’s kids. Mom said, “She can make do with a cheap one. Keep your grandmother out of it.” But when I told Grandma what my daughter thought she’d done wrong, she picked up her phone.

My daughter had started apologizing before anyone explained why her case was empty.

She thought she’d left something unlocked.

I’d come to collect her after practice at Mom and Dad’s house in Elyria.

Usually, she made me wait while she finished whatever passage she’d nearly got right.

That morning, she stood with the case propped against her knees.

“Did somebody take it for repairs?” I said.

Mom scraped her breakfast bowl.

“Ask your father.”

Dad’s laptop stayed open between us, although his fingers had stopped moving.

“Bertram,” Mom said, without turning around.

He lowered the screen.

“We found a buyer.”

I still had my coat halfway off.

“For what?”

He pointed toward the case as though I was wasting his time.

“The violin, Shelly.”

Niamh pressed the lid against her legs.

“It’s been SOLD?”

Dad’s mouth flattened.

“It fetched more than we expected.”

My brother Darrell stood beside the back door with his travel cup.

He kept turning it by the handle.

“Grandma gave that to Niamh,” I said.

“And she’s twelve,” he said. “What does she need with something that costs more than a car?”

I pulled my coat back onto my shoulder.

“How much?”

Mom took her bowl to the sink before answering.

“Ninety-four thousand dollars.”

Outside, a workman carried pipe past the window.

Beyond him, the yard had been opened up around a rectangular hole.

Darrell had shown us pictures of swim spas at dinner the previous month.

I hadn’t asked how he planned to pay.

“You bought that with her violin?”

“It’s staying here,” he said. “My kids will use it when they visit.”

My daughter shifted behind me.

“Your niece visits too.”

“She can swim, can’t she?”

Dad stood up then.

“It’s a FAMILY improvement.”

He looked toward Niamh as though she might agree with him.

“Plenty of children RENT instruments. There’s nothing wrong with that.”

She lowered her head.

I’d heard that tone whenever something belonging to her became inconvenient for somebody else.

Her seat could move.

Her plans could wait.

Now her violin could go.

“Did anyone ask her?” I said.

Mom rubbed at a spot on the counter.

There was flour on the corner of her glasses.

“We didn’t need a committee.”

I took Niamh into the sitting room before she could hear any more.

She opened the case across the seat of a chair.

Her hand followed the hollow where the violin’s neck had rested.

“Was I meant to ask before taking it out?”

“No, sweetheart.”

“I practiced when Grandma wasn’t here.”

“That’s what she wanted.”

Niamh rubbed a finger against the lining until it left a mark in the pile.

“Maybe she was only letting me borrow it.”

I crouched beside her.

“It was GIVEN to you.”

“But somebody let them take it.”

I couldn’t answer that without sending her back into the argument.

So I stayed beside the chair while she fastened the case.

She missed the clasp and tried again.

That evening, Jennifer lent us a student violin from her teaching cupboard.

She adjusted the shoulder rest while Niamh stood with her arms held close.

“Try your usual piece,” Jennifer said.

The opening notes came out harsh enough that Niamh stopped.

She checked where her fingers were.

“Try again,” I said.

She did, more carefully, and stopped in exactly the same place.

“Am I pressing too hard?”

Jennifer adjusted the bow in her hand.

Nobody said the instrument sounded different.

My daughter kept trying to correct herself.

Once she was asleep, I couldn’t stop hearing Mom’s last instruction.

She’d caught my sleeve beside the front door.

“She can make do with a cheap one. Keep your grandmother out of it.”

“Why?”

“Because you’ll get her worked up over something that’s already done.”

Dad had stayed behind her.

“Just KEEP QUIET until she gets used to the other violin.”

They meant Niamh.

They’d given her an adjustment period without telling her.

The following morning, I went to Grandma’s residence.

Halina moved her breakfast tray aside when I sat down.

I started with the empty case.

Then I told her about the collector, the payment and the work in the yard.

She kept her hands beside the tray.

“And Cecilia said you weren’t to tell me?”

“She said there was no point upsetting you.”

Grandma pushed the tray farther away.

“What did Niamh say?”

I had managed the money without crying.

That question nearly stopped me.

“She thinks you might have wanted it back because she used it without asking.”

Grandma’s thumb stopped against the tray’s edge.

“She said that?”

“She wanted to know what she’d done.”

Grandma picked up her phone.

She searched her contacts without asking me anything else.

“Kirk, it’s Halina Epps,” she said. “I need the signed instrument documents.”

Her finger pressed against the phone case.

“The GIFT declaration. And the photographs attached to it.”

I leaned forward, but she raised her palm.

“Yes, bring the complete copy.”

She ended the call and kept the phone in her hand.

“Should I be doing something?” I said.

“Keep her case.”

Five weeks later, Mom and Dad invited us to try the finished swim spa.

Mom called it a family afternoon.

Darrell sent another invitation when I didn’t answer hers.

Niamh wanted to know whether Grandma would be there.

“I think so,” I said.

She packed her swimming robe but left the loaned violin at home.

Tierra and Lukas were already in the water when we arrived.

Darrell stood beside the controls and explained the current to anybody who came near.

Mom passed around plates.

Several relatives said the yard looked wonderful.

I kept Niamh beside me.

She held her robe by its belt, so the sleeves nearly touched the tiles.

“Do I have to go in?”

“No.”

Mom reached toward the robe.

“You might as well enjoy it.”

Niamh moved it behind her back.

The gate latch lifted before I could answer.

Grandma came through with Mr. Kearney beside her.

A document wallet was tucked under his arm.

Mom stopped with a plate halfway toward a guest.

Dad left his chair.

Darrell took his hand away from the controls.

Grandma passed the water without looking into it.

“Somebody’s been spending,” she said.

Mom put the plate down.

“We’ve got company, Halina.”

“I can see that.”

Kearney opened the wallet.

Grandma took the papers and turned toward Niamh before she faced Dad.

“That violin was hers.”

Dad stepped between them.

“You left it in our house. We were looking after everything.”

“You were keeping it here.”

“We thought the sensible thing—”

Grandma lifted the page.

“You can read it NOW.”

He reached for the papers, but she kept the rest and handed him the signed declaration.

From beside him, I could see the instrument photographs attached behind it.

The varnish mark near the chin rest matched the mark Niamh used to rub with her sleeve.

Below the description, a separate line read, “GIFT RECIPIENT: NIAMH EPPS.”

The date was from three years earlier.

Darrell leaned toward the page until Dad pulled it closer to himself.

Mom pressed her lips together and looked toward the gate.

Dad went back to the signature and reread everything above it.

Grandma tapped the amount he’d written in the margin.

“Now account for that $94,000.”

The six bills

Dad took his phone out and opened the installer’s bill.

The swim spa, the digging and the tile had cost $94,000. The bottom said, “Balance due: $0.00.”

I took a photograph of his screen before he could put it away.

“All of it?” I said.

“That’s what you wanted to know.”

Darrell reached past us and switched off the current. Without the water churning, the relatives at the other end of the yard could hear us perfectly.

Mom went inside. She came back with an envelope.

“We anticipated that you’d want to replace it,” she said.

Dad took six hundred-dollar bills from her and held them toward Niamh.

“Your teacher can help you choose something suitable.”

Six hundred dollars. He’d probably spent longer choosing the tile.

I put my hand between his and hers.

“Put it down.”

“Shelly, don’t make this worse.”

“On the chair.”

He laid the bills on the seat. Mom put a plate over them so they wouldn’t blow away.

Niamh leaned against my arm. Tierra climbed out of the water and came toward us.

“Want to help me find something dry for Lukas?” she said to Niamh.

My daughter looked up at me. I nodded.

The girls went inside with Lukas. Darrell followed them with his eyes, then turned back to Dad.

“Tell her what the buyer said.”

Dad slid his phone into his pocket.

“If you want that violin back, somebody has to find ninety-four thousand dollars.”

The case under the chair

That Saturday, I’d brought the empty case in the car. I went to get it while Mom tried to move everyone toward the food.

Grandma stayed beside the chair with the money.

Three years earlier, she’d put that case on this same patio table. Niamh had asked whether she could put a sticker on it.

“On the case,” Grandma said. “Not on the violin.”

Mom laughed and helped her peel the backing off. Dad held the case open while she pressed the sticker down. Then he took a photograph of Niamh holding her gift.

Now the sticker had one corner missing. I rubbed it flat with my thumb and set the case beneath the chair.

Mom reached for the handle.

“Leave it.”

“It’s in the way.”

“So am I.”

She withdrew her hand.

Kearney asked Dad for the sale receipt. Dad went to his laptop inside and returned with two printed pages folded together.

The buyer’s first name was Graham. Dad kept his thumb over the telephone number until I asked him to move it.

“What do you intend to say to him?”

“That I want to speak to him.”

“He bought it honestly.”

“I haven’t said otherwise.”

Dad’s signature filled the bottom of the second page. He signed things the way he parked: across every available space.

Darrell stood between us and the camper he kept beside my parents’ garage.

“You can’t just expect Dad to produce that kind of cash,” he said.

Dad folded the receipt again.

“We have money put away for our trip. We can’t empty everything because you’re upset.”

Their retirement trip was apparently still going ahead. Darrell’s camper was still going camping. My daughter could have a replacement selected from under a paper plate.

Grandma reached for the receipt, but Dad held it against his chest.

Mom touched my elbow.

“Come into the kitchen. Let me talk to you without an audience.”

Mom’s kitchen

Inside that Saturday afternoon, Mom shut the back door and pulled out the chair where Niamh used to sit for breakfast.

“Sit down, Shelly.”

I stayed standing.

She picked a crumb off the chair seat, though nobody was sitting on it. My mother could find housework in a burning building if it postponed a conversation.

“Get the money together,” I said. “Call him. Reverse it.”

“We can’t get all of it together.”

“You got all of it spent.”

“Dad thought this would bring everybody here more often.”

“Then Dad can explain that to the buyer.”

She put both hands on the chair back.

“He has spoken to him.”

My hand stopped on the door handle.

“When?”

“After you started asking for his number.”

I’d asked for it throughout those five weeks. Dad said he’d find it, then that the buyer was away, then that collectors valued their privacy. Apparently, my daughter’s belongings came with better privacy than my daughter did.

“What did Dad say?”

“That there’d been a disagreement.”

“About whose violin it was?”

“About whether we should have sold it.”

“Those are different conversations.”

Mom opened her mouth, then closed it.

I sat down because my knees were doing something embarrassing.

“What did you say?”

She glanced toward the door.

“I told him we’d talk you around.”

There it was. For five weeks, when she’d said she was working on it, she’d meant working on me.

I pulled out the chair beside mine.

“Call him now. Tell him you couldn’t.”

“You don’t have to make me sound like a criminal.”

“You could use your own words.”

She didn’t take out her phone.

Instead, she sat beside me and put her hand over mine.

“Your grandmother has savings.”

I moved my hand.

“She gave the violin once.”

“Nobody’s asking her to give it again. She could lend us the money. We could pay her back gradually.”

“Ask her.”

“You know how she is with me.”

I did. Grandma asked what things cost and waited for an answer. Mom preferred numbers with the edges rubbed off.

“You’ve put her in a mood,” Mom said. “She’ll listen to you.”

I stood.

“If she says no, we’re all stuck,” she said.

I opened the door before she could reach me.

Dad was waiting on the step.

“Well?” he said to Mom.

She looked past me.

“She won’t ask Halina.”

The back step

Dad blocked the step that Saturday, one hand against the doorframe.

“Then I don’t know what you expect us to do.”

“Return what you took.”

“We haven’t got it.”

“You have what you bought with it.”

Darrell crossed the patio.

“You’re not tearing this out. Do you understand what that would cost?”

“No,” I said. “You didn’t invite me to the shopping part.”

He pointed toward the water.

“It’s installed. It’s connected. You can’t take it back to a store.”

I wanted to push him into it. I wanted that badly enough to put both hands in my pockets.

Grandma sat down beside the empty case. Kearney stayed standing near her.

Mom came through the door behind me.

“Halina, nobody meant for this to become a fight.”

Grandma lifted her face.

“Then answer her.”

Dad stepped down onto the patio.

“The buyer paid. We paid the installer. Those transactions are finished. Shelly knows we can’t pull money out of the ground.”

He said this beside an enormous hole he’d filled with my daughter’s money.

Darrell picked up the six bills.

“Take this for now. We can work out something better later.”

I left my hands in my pockets.

He tried Mom. She wouldn’t take them either.

Tierra appeared at the kitchen door. She was dressed now.

“Niamh’s helping Lukas with his shoes,” she said. “We’re going to sit in the front room.”

“Good,” I said.

Her father held out the money.

“Would you give these to your cousin?”

“No.”

“It’s for her.”

“Then give it to her mother.”

He looked at me again. I kept my hands where they were.

Tierra went back inside.

Darrell put the bills back under the plate.

“Now you’re getting my daughter involved.”

“You offered her a job,” I said. “She declined.”

Dad struck the chair back with his palm.

“Enough.”

Several relatives stopped pretending to examine the new tile.

He turned to me.

“Your mother has spent weeks trying to keep this family together. She’s offered you a way to get the instrument back.”

“By asking Grandma to buy it twice.”

“A loan.”

“With what payments?”

“We would work that out.”

Grandma reached toward me. I went to her and took her hand.

Mom’s eyes filled.

“I can’t believe you’re all standing there treating us like this.”

I nearly went to her. My feet actually shifted.

There were whole years of my life in that stupid little movement.

Then Mom pointed at the case.

“She’ll outgrow it anyway.”

Grandma’s hand closed around mine.

“It’s a full-size violin, Cecilia.”

Dad picked up the sale receipt and held it out to me.

“Call the man yourself, then. Tell him where you’re getting his money.”

The brass key

Still beside the spa that Saturday, I took the receipt.

Mom stood close and read it with me.

“Don’t make accusations you can’t take back.”

“I haven’t called him yet.”

“I’m talking about us.”

Dad held out his hand again. For a moment I thought he wanted the receipt.

“The house key,” he said.

I looked at him.

“If we’re people you can’t trust, there’s no reason for you to have it.”

Mom put a hand on his arm.

“Bertram.”

He shook her off.

“No. She doesn’t get to come here and speak to us like this, then use the house whenever it suits her.”

I’d used that key to bring groceries when he couldn’t drive. To sit with Mom after appointments. It also opened the door to every Sunday I’d assumed my daughter would have with them.

I took out my keys.

The little ring wouldn’t separate. My thumbnail bent backward, and I sucked it like an idiot while my father waited.

Nobody offered to help.

I got the key off and put it in his hand.

He closed his fingers.

I wanted Mom to give it back. That was the part I hated afterward. I still wanted her to choose us without being forced.

She didn’t.

Darrell shifted beside the chair.

“Maybe everybody should cool down.”

“No,” I said.

Dad held out the gift declaration. I took it and sat beside Grandma with Dad’s receipt across my knees.

Kearney bent toward me.

“Do you want me to make the call?”

“I’ll do it.”

Mom went inside and shut the door hard enough that the plate over the money jumped.

Dad stayed where he was.

“You can call whoever you like,” he said. “But without the money, that case stays empty.”

The bottom of the page

On the patio that Saturday, I unfolded the second page.

Above Dad’s signature, the receipt said he owned the violin and had the right to sell it. Below that, he had agreed to return the purchase money if that wasn’t true.

I put my finger under the sentence.

“Did you read this?”

“Of course I read it.”

I called the number at the top.

Graham answered. I gave him my name and told him I was Niamh’s mother.

“Your father said the family had agreed to the sale,” he said.

“My daughter owns it. I’ve got the signed gift declaration in front of me.”

“I haven’t seen that.”

“Dad has. He’s standing here.”

Kearney held out his phone. I passed him the declaration and its photographs, and he sent copies while I stayed on the call.

Graham asked me to wait.

Dad reached for the receipt. I moved it onto Grandma’s lap.

After a minute, Graham came back.

“Those photographs match.”

“Yes.”

“Your father needs to refund me.”

“Yes,” I said. “My father does.”

Dad shook his head at me.

I kept going.

“My daughter hasn’t received a dollar. She hasn’t signed anything. Will you return her violin while you collect from the people who sold it?”

Graham didn’t answer immediately.

I pressed the phone harder against my ear. Grandma put her hand on my knee.

“I’ll need to speak to Mr. Kearney about the handover,” Graham said. “And written confirmation from your father about repayment.”

“You can have both.”

Dad stepped toward me.

“Shelly, you can’t promise—”

“I haven’t promised your money.”

Graham could hear him.

“I won’t keep a child’s violin once I’ve seen proof it belongs to her,” he said. “Put your father on.”

I pressed the speaker button.

“Bertram,” Graham said. “We’re discussing your debt now.”

The chair beside the controls

Dad sat in the chair beside the controls that Saturday, with the phone on his knee.

The relatives stayed. Mom opened the kitchen door again.

“I acted for the family,” Dad said. “The instrument was kept at our house.”

Graham asked whether he disputed the gift declaration.

“I’m saying it was more complicated than a child owning something.”

“Do you dispute it?”

Dad massaged his forehead.

“No.”

“Then you weren’t entitled to sell it.”

“We believed we were making a reasonable decision.”

I took the case from under the chair and stood it beside his leg.

He pushed it away with his shoe.

“Don’t do that,” Grandma said.

His foot stopped.

Graham and Kearney agreed on Tuesday at Grandma’s residence for the return. Graham wanted repayment arranged before then. Dad said he’d call him that evening.

I ended the call.

Darrell took a step toward the door.

“Stay,” I said.

“I need to check the kids.”

“Tierra’s with them.”

He stopped.

Mom sat beside Dad and took the receipt from Grandma’s lap.

“Sixty-two,” she said.

He turned toward her.

“Cecilia.”

“That’s what’s in the trip account. Sixty-two thousand.”

Darrell looked from one to the other.

Dad put his hand over the paper.

“We can’t empty that.”

Mom lifted his hand off.

“What else is there?”

He looked at the camper beside the garage.

Darrell followed his eyes.

“No.”

Nobody spoke.

“That’s mine,” Darrell said.

I let him hear his own sentence.

He tried again.

“I didn’t sell the violin. I didn’t sign that receipt. You can’t take my camper because you decided something.”

“You picked the spa,” Mom said.

“You said you could afford it.”

“You knew where the money came from.”

“After you’d sold it.”

“And you told Shelly to stop complaining,” Dad said.

Darrell turned toward me.

“Tell him. I wasn’t there when he sold it.”

“You were there when my daughter opened the case.”

His mouth stayed open for a moment.

Mom began to cry. She wiped under one eye with the heel of her hand and left a mark of makeup.

“We saved for that trip.”

Grandma stood.

“Then you know what it feels like to lose something you were looking forward to.”

“Please don’t,” Mom said.

“Look at Shelly.”

Mom kept her head down.

Grandma waited until she raised it.

“You told her to keep quiet. You told Niamh to get used to something else.”

“I never meant to hurt her.”

“You spent every dollar.”

Dad got up so suddenly the chair moved behind him.

“All right. I sold it. I sold Niamh’s violin without asking her or Shelly. Is that what everybody wants to hear?”

Several relatives were looking straight at him now.

I said, “Yes.”

He looked toward the kitchen window.

Mom put her face in her hands.

Darrell stood beside the controls he’d been explaining to everyone an hour earlier.

“The dealer offered thirty-two for the camper,” he said at last. “Last month. I don’t know if he’ll still pay it.”

“Call him,” Dad said.

“I’ll want it paid back.”

Dad turned toward him.

“From what?”

Darrell took out his phone.

I stood beside him while he made the call. He asked whether the offer was still good, then said he’d bring the camper in Monday.

He didn’t look at me when he hung up.

Tierra came to the back door again. This time Niamh stood beside her.

“Mom?”

I went to my daughter.

“It’s coming home Tuesday.”

She covered her mouth with both hands.

Behind me, Darrell laid his camper keys beside the six bills.

Tuesday at Grandma’s

On Tuesday morning, Dad arrived at Grandma’s residence carrying proof of the payment.

Mom walked beside him. Darrell came alone.

The camper had gone to the dealer on Monday. Darrell’s part was $32,000.00. Mom and Dad’s trip savings supplied $62,000.00.

Graham put the payment confirmation beside Dad’s sale receipt.

“Ninety-four thousand dollars,” he said. “Received.”

Mom stared at the amount.

“That was our whole trip account.”

Graham checked the name on the gift declaration.

“Where’s Niamh?”

She stood next to me with her case. The robe stayed at home.

Graham opened the case he’d brought. My daughter stepped forward, then stopped and looked at him.

“May I?”

“It’s yours,” he said.

She lifted the violin out with both hands.

Her thumb went straight to the varnish mark near the chin rest. She moved it away again, as though she’d remembered something.

Grandma held out her arms.

“Come here with it.”

Niamh carried it over. Grandma kissed the top of her head and held her there until my daughter began to laugh into her shoulder.

“You’re squashing the violin.”

“Then put it down and let me squash you properly.”

I sat on the arm of Grandma’s chair. I hadn’t meant to cry in front of my parents. I’d planned something much more dignified, involving my coat staying on.

Grandma pulled a tissue from her sleeve and handed it to me.

It had a cough sweet stuck to it.

I laughed so hard I had to take another tissue from the box.

Niamh opened her own case on the little table. She checked the bow and settled the violin into the hollow she’d traced with her finger five weeks earlier.

It fitted.

She lifted it out again.

“Can I play something?”

Grandma moved her chair back to give her room.

Niamh played the passage she’d kept stopping in on Jennifer’s loaned instrument. She stopped once this time, moved her finger, and began again without looking at any of us.

When she finished, Grandma put both hands over her mouth.

Dad moved forward.

“That sounded very nice.”

Niamh rested the violin against her side.

“Thank you.”

She turned to me.

“I want to show Jennifer.”

“We’ll take it this evening.”

Mom stood and reached for the case.

“I can carry that down for you.”

“I’ve got it,” I said.

She let her hand fall.

Kearney gave me the gift declaration and its photographs. I put them in my bag. Graham took his receipt and closed the case he’d brought, now empty.

Dad waited until everyone was standing.

“We’ve done what you asked.”

I fastened Niamh’s case.

“You returned what was hers.”

“We found the money. Darrell sold his camper. Your mother and I gave up something we’d planned for years.”

Mom was crying again, quietly this time. Darrell stared at the empty case Graham held.

Dad came closer.

“What more do you want us to do?”

“Nothing today.”

He looked toward Niamh, then back at me.

“Sunday, then. Come over Sunday. We can start putting this behind us.”

“No.”

“Shelly. After everything we’ve paid?”

“You paid a debt.”

I picked up my daughter’s violin and walked out with her.

If this one stayed with you, send it to someone who has ever had to stand between their child and the rest of the family.

Family betrayals have a way of getting even messier – see what happened when an ex used a coat to dry his mother’s chair and when a husband gave his mother a spare house key. There’s more family fallout in the story of a father who moved his daughter’s chair beside the garage.