My Ex Turned My Voicemails All the Way Up at Deandre’s Wedding

James Carter

The lasagna pan was still on the stove when it started, with the corner piece gone because Joon always took the corner. He ate two helpings, put his fork down at an angle like a man signing off on a report, and said he wanted to leave.

“You’ll land on your feet. You always do.”

I asked if it was someone else. He said her name was Taryn, the way you’d name a restaurant. Then he looked at me as if I might boil over and asked if I was going to cry.

So I gave him crying. My face buried in my hands, the shoulders, the works. His chair creaked as he settled back, happy, and he told me I felt everything at full volume and Taryn didn’t. For twelve years he had supplied the explanation for every fight we had. Behind my hands I worked out what he wanted now: proof that his departure had wrecked me. A woman doing fine would get visited again.

So I stayed wrecked. “Not great,” I told him on Tuesday. Over six weeks he kept the house, both cars, and $9,400 of our $11,200, which left me $1,800 and his soft voice telling me to start smaller. I asked for my grandmother’s cedar chest, the one she bought in 1971. He wrote it in his spiral notebook like a gift. On a Friday I signed at the mediator’s with a tissue, and he gave me another.

That night Perla took me to karaoke until 1:40. In the parking lot, barefoot, I called Joon and cried into his voicemail. There were seven in the end. He left two messages of his own, one before the signing and one after. I kept those.

Five weeks later, at my cousin Deandre’s wedding, in a cobalt-blue dress, I watched the evening fall apart for him. Taryn walked out. I told my family the crying was on purpose. Yosef said, “Let her finish.”

Joon smiled, set his phone between the centerpieces, turned it all the way up, and pressed play.

The Centerpieces

My own voice came out of that phone like a cat stuck in a dryer.

“Joon. It’s me. The apartment is so quiet I can’t stand it.”

The sniff that followed was, I’ll admit, excellent work. Aunt Kamala put her hand on her chest. My cousin Yosef looked at me, then at the phone, then at me again, like a man checking two prices on the same can of soup.

Joon spread his hands at the table. Here she is, folks. Exhibit A.

“I just want you to hear it,” he said. “This is what I’ve been dealing with.”

Then something else came out of the speaker.

Behind my sobbing, faint but clear, there was a bass line. The kind that comes through a cinder-block wall from a bar where somebody is murdering a song about a highway. And then a man’s voice, very drunk, very close to the parking lot, yelling, “ONE MORE, ONE MORE.”

Joon’s thumb went for the screen.

He was too slow. The last two seconds were Perla.

“What are you doing?”

And me, not crying at all, perfectly cheerful:

“Nothing.”

The voicemail beeped off.

Nobody at that table moved. Deandre’s new wife had come over from the head table with her train looped over her arm, and she stood there holding it like a bag of groceries she’d forgotten to put down.

Perla raised one of her two drinks.

“That was me,” she said. “We’d been at it since nine. She did the high part of a song she did not know.”

Somebody behind Kamala laughed and turned it into a cough.

Joon’s face did something slow. He’d been so sure of that phone. He’d carried it to the wedding in his jacket, against his heart, like an engagement ring.

“That’s one,” he said. “That’s one night. She called me seven times.”

“I know,” I said. “I was there for all of them.”

He scrolled. His thumb was not steady now, and I noticed I was enjoying that more than a Christian woman at a wedding should.

“Listen to this. Listen.” He pressed the next one.

“I couldn’t get dressed this morning,” my voice said, wobbling. “I just sat on the edge of the bed.”

He looked up at my family. See? See?

And Perla, God keep her, took out her own phone.

“What day was that one?” she asked him.

Joon didn’t answer. The screen said it for him, because he’d laid it face up for everybody. Thursday, 10:12 a.m.

Perla turned her screen around to Kamala. “Thursday, 10:04 a.m.,” she said. “That’s her at the farmers market in a yellow sundress, holding a peach the size of a softball. She made me take it. She said the peach looked like Joon’s head.”

Aunt Kamala took the phone in both hands and held it at arm’s length because she won’t wear her glasses at parties.

“It does look like his head,” she said.

That was when the table broke. Not all at once. Somebody snorted. Deandre put his face in his hand. My cousin Yosef laughed out loud, a big ugly honk, and then said, “Sorry, sorry,” and laughed again.

Joon stood up.

“This isn’t funny,” he said. “She’s sick. She’s been on pills for weeks. Ask anybody.”

“I’m asking you,” Yosef said. “Which pills?”

Joon opened his mouth.

“You told my mother she couldn’t leave her apartment,” Yosef said. “She was at the farmers market.”

“She sat outside the pharmacy for an hour,” Joon said. “She told me. It’s on there.”

“I did sit outside the pharmacy,” I said. “I was waiting for Perla. They have the good parking.”

The bride let her train drop to the floor.

Joon looked around that table, at my aunt holding a photo of a peach, at my cousins, at the bride, at the groom. He’d spent twelve years at these tables. He carved the turkey at Kamala’s when Uncle Ramon’s shoulder went. He knew every one of these people by their drink.

None of them were looking at him like he was the reasonable one anymore.

He picked the phone up off the tablecloth and held it against his chest.

“Fine,” he said. “You want to do this, Mariela? Let’s do this.”

I set my glass down.

“Okay,” I said. “But it’s my turn to play something.”

Tuesday, 6:50 P.M.

I want to be clear about one thing, since this is my story and I can be clear about whatever I want.

I didn’t plan to play anything that night. I’d planned to eat a piece of wedding cake, dance with Perla to one song with a horn section, and go home in the dress I liked. That was the whole plan.

But I am the kind of woman who keeps the warranty card for a toaster. When Joon left me messages, I kept those too. He’d left two. I’d listened to them maybe four times each, at the kitchen counter, with my grandmother’s cedar chest sitting in the corner of the apartment where his couch used to be.

I took my phone out of my clutch.

“He called me back after my second one,” I told the table. “I was crying, so he called me back. That was nice of him.”

Joon said, “Don’t.”

It was the first time all night he’d said one word.

I pressed play and set my phone right next to his, between the same two centerpieces. Little jars of baby’s breath. Deandre’s wife had made them herself, forty of them, over a month of weekends. I tried not to get any of this on the baby’s breath.

His voice came out warm. That kind voice. The one he used on the waiter when the order was wrong.

“Mari, hey. Got your message. Listen, I’m glad you’re letting it out. That’s healthy. But do me a favor. Don’t call Taryn, okay? And don’t go talking to a lawyer about the savings. You’re not thinking straight right now, and a lawyer’s just going to confuse you. It’s simpler this way. I’ll handle what to tell everybody. I’ll tell them you’re not well, so nobody bugs you about it. Okay? Get some rest.”

Beep.

Kamala put the peach photo down on the table very gently, like it might go off.

“You’ll handle what to tell everybody,” she said.

“That’s not what that means,” Joon said.

“Then what does it mean?”

“It means I was protecting her. People ask questions. She can’t handle questions.”

“I’m handling them now,” I said.

He didn’t look at me. He was looking at Kamala, because Kamala was the one he needed. Kamala was the one who’d hugged him at our wedding and said, “Now I’ve got a son who can fix a gutter.”

“Auntie,” he said. “You know me.”

“I thought I did.”

“She did this. The crying, all of it, she just admitted she faked it. Doesn’t that tell you who’s lying here? A person who’d fake that—”

“Play the other one,” Yosef said to me.

I played the other one.

This one came before any of mine, the Wednesday before the mediator. Joon again, softer still.

“Mari. Just a heads-up so Friday isn’t a shock. I moved the savings into my account so it’s safe. Ninety-four hundred. There’s eighteen left in ours, which is plenty for you, you won’t need as much now. Don’t bring it up Friday, it’ll just drag things out. Trust me. Love you, okay? I mean it. Bye.”

He said love you. I’d forgotten that part. Hearing it in front of my family, I nearly laughed, and then I nearly did the other thing, the real one, for the first time in eleven weeks.

I didn’t. I picked up my glass again and held it.

Deandre had come around the end of the table. My little cousin. He used to throw up on long car rides and I held the bag. Now he was twenty-nine, in a tuxedo with a boutonniere going sideways, and he looked about forty.

“You took her money,” he said. “And then you came to my wedding and bragged.”

“It was a joint account.”

“You told Mom she was on pills.”

“Deandre, this isn’t the place—”

“It’s my wedding,” Deandre said. “I decide what the place is.”

The DJ, who had no idea, chose that moment to start a slow song. Something about forever. It played over all of us.

Joon pushed his chair back so hard it hit the next table, and somebody’s water went over.

“You know what she is?” he said, louder. “She’s a performer. She’s been performing for twelve years. Everything with her is a show. You all just got the matinee.”

“Then you bought a ticket for six weeks,” Perla said. “Front row.”

He pointed at her. “You stay out of it.”

“I’ve been in it since the parking lot,” she said.

That was the moment Joon understood the room was not his. I saw him understand it. His shoulders came up, then went down, then came up again, like he couldn’t find the right size for himself.

Then he did the thing I knew he’d do, because he’d done it for twelve years.

He turned to me with his eyes wet.

“Mari,” he said. “Can we just go outside and talk about this like adults?”

The Coat Check

“No,” I said.

It was the second time that night. It got easier.

“I’m not going outside with you. Whatever you have to say, say it here. You brought the speaker.”

He stood there. The slow song kept going. Some of the guests on the dance floor had stopped dancing and were just holding on to each other, watching us over their partners’ shoulders.

“What do you want?” he said finally. “Is that what this is? You want something?”

“I want my half.”

“There is no half. You signed.”

“I signed after you told me not to bring it up,” I said. “On a voicemail. With love you on the end.”

Kamala stood up. She is sixty-six and has two bad knees and it took her a while, and every one of us waited for her to do it.

“Joon,” she said. “Give her the money.”

“Kamala, with respect, this isn’t family business.”

“You’ve been telling my family she’s on pills,” she said. “So I’ve decided it’s family business.”

He looked at Yosef. Yosef was holding a dinner roll for some reason and didn’t put it down. He looked at Deandre, at the bride with her train in a heap on the floor. He looked at the doorway Taryn had walked out of forty minutes before.

“Is it about Taryn?” he said to me. “Is that it? You wanted to wreck that?”

“I wanted to eat some cake,” I said.

The bride laughed. One sharp sound, then she covered her mouth.

“You’ll get the money,” Joon said. “Okay? Fine. I’ll send something. Can we drop it?”

“How much is something?”

“Mari.”

“Thirty-eight hundred,” I said. “That’s what makes us even. Fifty-six each. I have eighteen.”

He stared at me. Joon did the math for twelve years. Our tax returns, the car loans, the tip at the restaurant, he did all of it out loud so everyone could hear that he could do it. He never once guessed I’d been doing it right along with him in my head.

“I’m not doing this in front of people.”

“You did everything else in front of people,” Deandre said.

And then Deandre did the thing I’ll love him for until I die. He walked over to the little table near the door where his wife’s sister had set up a card box, the white one with a slot in the top, and he took out his own phone.

“Do it now,” he said. “Send it now. Or you’re leaving my wedding, and you can explain to everybody on the way out why.”

There was a long moment where Joon looked at the door and then at the room, and you could see him try to work out which was worse.

The room was worse. The room was everybody who’d ever passed him a plate.

He took his phone back off the tablecloth, where it was still sitting on the voicemail screen with my seven messages lined up like ducks. He pressed something. He pressed it hard. He typed.

My phone buzzed on the table next to his.

I picked it up. Three thousand eight hundred dollars and zero cents.

“There,” he said. “Happy?”

“Yes,” I said.

He hadn’t expected that answer. I think he wanted me to say no so we’d have something left to fight about.

He grabbed his jacket off the chair. Nobody stopped him. Nobody walked him out, which at a family wedding is its own kind of announcement. At the coat check he turned back once, like he might say one more thing that would put it all back where it was.

Kamala got there first.

“Don’t come for Thanksgiving,” she said. “Ramon’s shoulder’s better. He’ll carve.”

The door closed behind him on the slow song.

Ninety-Four Hundred

The rest of it came in pieces, over the next three weeks, and I’m going to tell it like a grocery list because that’s how it arrived.

Taryn never moved into the house. She called me the Monday after the wedding, which I did not see coming. She said she’d been in the parking lot when I played the second voicemail, through the open door, and she’d heard the part about not calling her.

“He told me you were dangerous,” she said. “That I shouldn’t ever talk to you.”

“I’m a dental hygienist,” I said.

She laughed, and then she said she was sorry, and I believed her, mostly.

Without Taryn’s half of the payments, the house Joon kept was more than he could carry on his own. It went on the market on a Thursday. The blue sedan went the week after. He kept his truck, which I think he loves more than any person he’s ever met, so I’ll let him have that.

He wasn’t at Thanksgiving. Uncle Ramon carved, badly, and everybody told him it was the best turkey in years.

The thirty-eight hundred sat in my account for exactly one day. Then I paid the first month on a little place across town with a porch and a window over the sink, and I paid Perla back for every karaoke round she’d covered over five weeks, which came to more than I want to admit.

The last thing I did, the Saturday after the house went on the market, was open my grandmother’s cedar chest.

Joon never once did, not in twelve years. Not even when he wrote it down in his notebook as his to give away.

There was nothing hidden in it. No secret money, no deed, nothing a story would want. There were her quilts. Her church hat with the net. A stack of Christmas cards from 1971 on, tied up in red yarn, and a recipe card for lasagna in her handwriting, with “too much ricotta is never too much” underlined twice.

Perla sat on the floor of my new living room and held the church hat.

“So he gave you a box of blankets,” she said.

“He gave me my grandmother,” I said.

She put the hat on. It was crooked and the net covered one eye. She looked like a lady at a funeral who’d come to read the will.

I took the cobalt-blue dress out of my closet, folded it the way Grandma folded quilts, in thirds, and laid it on top. Then I closed the lid. The cedar smell came up at me, the same as it did when I was nine.

Perla took out her phone.

“Smile,” she said. “For the record.”

I didn’t cover my face this time. I smiled, all the way, and she took the picture.

If this one got to you, send it to the friend who’d sit in a parking lot at 1:40 in the morning and only ask you once.

For more family drama that turns a family gathering into a reckoning, see the neighbor who put fence posts through a late husband’s ramp and the brother who seated his sister by the bus carts. There’s also the mother-in-law who borrowed against her daughter-in-law’s grandmother’s house.