My Date Smiled at the Menu Beside My Parked Road King

Marcus Chen

I folded my riding gloves together before I sat down. One thumb kept sticking out, so I tucked it in again. Forty-six years old, and apparently that was what my hands did when I wanted a woman to like me.

Colleen was forty-four. We’d matched on a Monday, nine days before our Wednesday dinner, and spent four days messaging. She was funny on a phone. I hoped some of that would make it across a booth.

Before choosing a restaurant, we’d agreed to split the check. She’d said she wanted the same.

At seven, I backed my Road King into the side lot of the roadhouse she’d picked outside Fort Wayne. Wednesday was bike night. Through our window, she saw me park and smiled down at her menu.

The motorcycle was my only vehicle. To her, apparently, it came with a dinner allowance.

Dominic, our waiter, was about twenty-four, with a dinosaur bandage around his thumb. Colleen interrupted his greeting to order the forty-ounce porterhouse, medium rare. At $136, it was the menu’s most expensive meal.

I ordered half a roasted chicken.

Over dinner, I heard about her cousin’s engagement, her neighbor’s remodel, and her landlord’s refusal to fix a water heater.

Then Dominic brought our $196 check. Her steak and two Manhattans accounted for $162.

I offered my card for half.

She refused to pay, then admitted she’d never expected me to hold her to our agreement. Six of the twelve riders in the bar room behind her turned toward us.

She pushed the check across.

“A man with a bike like THAT can afford to feed a woman.”

My ears burned. All twelve riders had seen me park.

A man behind her said, “Colleen. That makes FOUR.”

Dominic returned my untouched card.

“Sir, put that away,” he said.

The Man Behind Her Booth

I picked up the card, but I didn’t put it in my wallet. I held it between two fingers like I might still need identification to get out of there.

Colleen turned toward the bar.

The man who’d spoken stepped down into the dining room. He wore an apron with a pen clipped to it. There was a dish towel over his shoulder, and he took it off before coming to our booth.

“Four what?” she said.

He stopped beside Dominic.

“Four riders you’ve brought here since summer. Four dinners where the man found out at the end that you weren’t paying.”

She gave a short laugh and looked at me.

“I have no idea what he’s talking about.”

The man pulled the check around so he could read it.

“I’m Wade. I own the place,” he said to me. “I run bike night.”

Then he faced her again.

“After the third time, I told Dominic that if you came back, he was to bring the check straight to your table. No handing it to your date while you were in the restroom. No putting it on somebody’s bar tab.”

Dominic kept his hands at his sides. That little dinosaur looked cheerful enough to be working somewhere else.

“You make it sound like I stole something,” Colleen said.

“The other men paid,” Wade said. “They didn’t want a scene. That’s what happened.”

I slid my card into my wallet.

For a second I wanted to thank him so hard it would have been embarrassing. Then another thought caught up.

“You recognized her when we came in?”

Dominic glanced at Wade.

“I did,” he said. “I told him. He told me to bring the bill here and let you both handle it.”

“Why didn’t somebody tell me?”

Colleen put a hand over her heart.

“Listen to this. Now I’m something you warn people about?”

Wade left his attention on me.

“She can eat here and pay for her food. I wasn’t going to walk up during your dinner and tell you about her other dates.”

That answer irritated me because it was reasonable. I’d been preparing to enjoy being angry at everybody.

“Then I heard her tell you she wasn’t paying,” he said. “I heard the part about your motorcycle, too.”

Colleen shifted toward the edge of the booth.

“This is private.”

I looked behind her. Twelve riders sat in the bar room, and not one was pretending to watch the television anymore.

“It was private when we agreed,” I said.

She turned back to me.

“Russ. Really? You’re going to let some restaurant owner talk about me like this?”

I wanted to ask if there was a particular number of restaurant owners I should allow. My mouth was warming up to do something unhelpful.

Instead, I took my phone out.

She reached across and touched my wrist.

“Don’t be weird.”

That almost worked. There’s something about a person saying you’re making a fuss that can make you forget whose hand started the fuss.

I opened our messages.

My question about splitting was still there. Her answer was underneath it. No teasing face. No qualification. Just agreement.

I laid the phone between us.

“You said that was fair,” I said.

She didn’t look down.

“Oh, I said it. I just didn’t think you’d HOLD me to it.”

She’d said it before Wade came over. Hearing it again, with him standing there, took the last bit of confusion out of the room.

Dominic lowered his eyes to the phone, then back to her.

Colleen pulled her hand off my wrist.

“Most men understand that women say things to be polite.”

“Not this man,” I said.

Wade pushed the original check toward Dominic.

“Separate what they ordered.”

Colleen sat forward.

“He offered half.”

“I did,” I said.

“Then he can pay half.”

The arithmetic had suddenly become interesting to her. Five minutes earlier, she’d wanted no part of it.

Dominic didn’t move yet.

I looked at the check. My chicken was $27. My draft beer was $7. Her two Manhattans were $13 each, on top of the steak.

I’d offered $98 toward a meal where I’d eaten and drunk $34. Even my attempt at fairness had come with a side order of foolishness.

“I offered half before you told me you never meant to pay anything,” I said. “Bring me my own.”

Wade nodded to Dominic.

Colleen pushed her plate away, though there wasn’t much left on it to push.

“You all planned this?”

“No,” I said.

“Because it sure looks like it. A whole room full of men waiting for a woman to make one mistake.”

Wade rested a hand on the back of the empty seat beside me.

“Three other men paid to get out of this conversation,” he said. “Russ doesn’t have to be the fourth.”

She looked at my wallet.

“Are you really going to sit there and let him do this?”

I put the wallet in my jacket.

“Yes.”

The $162 Check

Dominic went to separate the bill, and Colleen waited until he was out of earshot before leaning toward me.

“We could have handled this ourselves.”

“We were handling it. You said you weren’t paying.”

“Because I thought you liked me.”

I did like her, before dinner. I’d reread a couple of her messages while waiting at a gas pump that afternoon. I wasn’t proud of how much that small hope hurt now.

“You could have told me you wanted me to buy dinner,” I said.

“And then what? You’d have canceled?”

“Maybe.”

She sat back.

“There it is.”

I left that where it landed. She could be disappointed that I wouldn’t buy a stranger a porterhouse. I could survive being the villain in that very small movie.

Wade stayed beside the booth without leaning over her. The path to the door was clear. Nobody had stood up in the bar room.

Colleen looked toward the riders anyway.

“Enjoying yourselves?”

Wade turned halfway.

“Give us some room, folks.”

Stools turned back. A conversation started near the television, low at first. I hadn’t understood how badly I needed that until I could hear somebody talking about a tire instead of listening to my date explain my deficiencies.

Colleen picked up her phone.

“I could write about this. I could put this whole thing online.”

“You can,” Wade said. “Your dinner still costs what the menu said.”

“Your waiter should have explained how big that steak was.”

“You ordered it before I finished saying hello,” Dominic said.

He’d returned with the separate checks. He set hers in front of her, not in the middle, not next to my elbow.

Colleen looked at him.

“I’m talking to your boss.”

“He heard you,” Wade said.

I nearly smiled. I covered it by moving my gloves off the edge of the booth. I didn’t want Dominic taking the heat because I found something funny.

She tapped the paper.

“One hundred and sixty-two dollars? For dinner?”

“The porterhouse was $136,” Dominic said. “The Manhattans were twenty-six.”

“That’s ridiculous.”

“The price was beside the steak,” he said.

Her eyes dropped to his thumb.

“Can you at least bring someone who knows what they’re doing?”

Dominic’s hand closed around his pen.

That was the moment I stood up.

Too fast, probably. My knee struck the underside of the booth, which took some dignity out of the operation. I stood there with a sore knee and my jacket in my hand.

“He’s done his job,” I said.

Colleen looked up at me.

“Sit down, Russ.”

“No.”

I didn’t raise my voice. I didn’t have much room left in it.

“You agreed to split. You ordered what you wanted. He brought it. Leave him out of it.”

She looked from me to Wade, then to Dominic. Nobody supplied the smile she’d been getting from me all evening.

“You don’t have to humiliate me.”

I wanted to tell her about the six stools turning. About my card lying face up. About sitting across from somebody who’d decided my feelings were less expensive than her dinner.

But I was tired of handing her things she could turn around.

“Pay for your food,” I said.

For a while, she only looked at the bill.

Wade took one step away so Dominic could stand beside the booth without crowding her.

“Card or cash?” Dominic said.

Colleen opened her bag, shut it, then opened it again. She took out a card and held it above the tray.

“You’re going to lose a customer over this.”

“After tonight, you won’t be eating here again,” Wade said.

Her hand stopped.

“What?”

“You’ll pay this bill. Then you won’t come back.”

She stared at him, and for the first time since the check arrived, she had nothing ready.

Then she found plenty.

“I brought business here. Those men bought drinks. They bought meals. You got paid every single time. You don’t get to act like I cost you money.”

Wade didn’t interrupt.

“And I didn’t force anybody. Grown men can say no. They wanted to take me out. They were happy to pay until they started complaining to you afterward.”

I wondered how happy those three men had looked at their cars.

She pointed her card toward me.

“He was paying half. You heard him. Now suddenly I’m some criminal because you decided to stick your nose in.”

“Your card, Colleen,” Wade said.

She put it on the tray hard enough to make it skip.

Dominic caught the edge before it went onto the floor.

He took the payment machine from his apron pocket and ran her card right there. She stared out the window while it worked.

Then he placed the receipt in front of her.

$162.00. Approved.

She checked the number twice.

I could have understood wanting to check. I just wished she’d developed the habit while holding the menu.

She signed and handed the pen back.

“Happy now?”

Wade passed her card back.

“Your bill is paid. You’re not welcome back.”

Colleen slid out of the booth. She faced me with her bag against her shoulder.

“You’ll be sitting alone at fifty.”

“Not with you.”

She walked past me and out through the front door.

The Gloves in the Window

The door closed, and I remained standing with my jacket bunched in my hand.

I expected to feel ten feet tall. Mostly, I felt like a man who’d picked a bad evening to wear a shirt that showed sweat.

Dominic gathered the plates.

“I’m sorry about that,” he said.

“You didn’t order the steak,” I said.

He smiled, but only a little.

I pulled my wallet out again.

Wade covered my check with two fingers.

“Your dinner’s on the house.”

“No. I ate it.”

“I know. You did a good job.”

That got a laugh out of me before I could stop it.

“I don’t need you buying it because she wouldn’t.”

“I’m not buying hers,” he said. “I’m buying yours. Thirty-four dollars. I can survive a chicken and a beer.”

I looked at Dominic.

He nodded toward Wade.

“Don’t argue with him about chicken. We’ll be here all night.”

Some of the tightness left my chest. I sat down long enough to put my jacket on properly instead of trying to force both arms into one sleeve.

Wade picked up my check.

“She knew we did bike night,” he said. “She kept choosing Wednesdays.”

I looked through the window at the row of motorcycles.

That stung. I’d thought she’d chosen somewhere we might have something in common. Maybe she had liked the food, too. I wasn’t going to spend the rest of my evening working out which part of me she’d mistaken for a wallet.

“Well,” I said, “the chicken was good.”

“It usually is.”

Dominic started to take the tray, and I put a twenty-dollar bill on it.

“That’s for you.”

“You don’t have to do that.”

“I know.”

He held the tray against his apron.

“Thanks, Russ.”

Hearing my name without a demand attached to it helped more than it should have.

Wade left us to it. He went back up the step into the bar room and asked someone to move a glass away from the edge. Owning a restaurant apparently meant dealing with catastrophes in descending order.

I zipped my wallet shut.

Dominic wiped a ring from the table, working around my folded gloves.

“What happened to your thumb?” I said.

He held it up.

“Cut it opening a box.”

“Brave choice of bandage.”

“My daughter picked it. She’s four. She said plain ones don’t work as good.”

“She’s probably right.”

“She checked it before I left for work.”

I pictured a little girl inspecting that man’s thumb and sending him off wearing a dinosaur. Then I pictured Colleen looking at it while asking for somebody competent.

I was glad I’d stood up. Bruised knee and all.

Dominic reached for the empty glasses.

“I thought you were going to pay it,” he said.

“So did I.”

“Why?”

I rubbed the back of my neck.

“I wanted to leave without everybody thinking I was cheap.”

He looked at me for a second.

Then he picked up the glasses.

“Nobody thought that.”

I let him have the last word. He’d earned it.

My phone was still on the table, open to the agreement we’d made before dinner. I closed the app and put the phone away.

There wasn’t anything left in those messages I needed to study.

I walked toward the door. Nobody clapped. Nobody made a speech. I was grateful for that, too. A man can be rescued from an embarrassing date without needing a parade through the salad station.

At the step into the bar room, Wade put a hand out.

I shook it.

“Thanks,” I said.

“Come back Wednesday.”

I looked past him at the twelve riders. One had an empty stool beside him. Another lifted his glass an inch.

“I don’t know,” I said. “Apparently I don’t know how to behave in restaurants.”

“You paid attention to the prices. That puts you ahead.”

I laughed again.

He pointed toward the side lot.

“Next week, park in the same place. We can see your bike from here.”

Outside, the air had cooled. I stopped beside the Road King and unzipped my jacket enough to get my keys.

Then I reached for my gloves.

My hands came up empty.

I’d spent the beginning of the evening folding those things like a nervous schoolboy, and the end walking away without them. A smooth operation from start to finish.

Before I could turn around, the door opened.

Dominic came down the walk holding them.

“Window seat,” he said.

“Thanks. Again.”

He handed them over, then pulled his phone from his pocket. There was a picture on the screen of a little girl wearing a bicycle helmet crooked over her forehead.

“That’s the bandage supervisor,” he said.

“Tell her she does good work.”

“I will.”

He went back inside. I pulled on my gloves, working the stubborn thumb into place.

Through the window, Wade pointed at the empty stool. I held up one finger for next Wednesday.

Then I took the gloves off again, tucked them into my jacket, and went back inside.

Wade moved the stool out with his boot.

“Coffee?”

“Yeah,” I said. “I’ve got time.”

Stories about people stepping in when someone crosses a line make for a gripping read – see what happened when Kyle Dempsey put his hand over a widow’s cash box, or when a biker showed up at a church supper. And for another roadside encounter that changed everything, there’s the call my mother made after recognizing my car.