My Dad Took Forty-Eight Envelopes From Me on Thursdays

Olivia Wright

The pastor’s wife had put a box of tissues at the end of every pew. Mine was empty by the first hymn. My mom kept handing me hers one at a time, folded in quarters, like she was paying out of a purse.

That was the only thing that moved at our end of the church until the back door opened.

Bentley was six. Leukemia, diagnosed at five, treated every Thursday from one-thirty to four-thirty while I ran a register at the hardware store in Muncie. My dad sat with him those afternoons. He charged me for it. “I’m retired, not free,” he said at my kitchen table, and I paid him a hundred and fifty dollars a week in an envelope on his dashboard. Forty-eight envelopes. Seven thousand two hundred dollars.

The man who came in that Saturday was the biggest person I have ever seen inside a church. Beard to his chest, ink to his wrists, a vest older than me. He knelt at my son’s white casket with one hand clamped to his side, and then he set a pewter bell next to Bentley’s pewter bell.

Bentley’s had hung on his IV pole all year. I’d never asked where it came from.

My father got up, took the stranger’s bell off the lid and said, “Get that biker trash away from my grandson.” Then he threw it out the side door into the gravel.

The man stood at the back wall through the whole eulogy. Dad called Bentley “my little Thursday buddy.”

Afterwards I walked out past my father and found eleven motorcycles backed in at the curb and the bell face down in the gravel. When the big man followed me out, he said, “He rang first. Every Thursday. I just rang back.”

Then a nurse I’d never met took my arm.

“Don’t let your dad leave yet,” she said.

The gray Buick

I didn’t ask her why. I’d like to say that was trust. It was mostly that my legs had decided for me.

I went back up the steps and stood one below my father, which put my eyes level with his tie. He’d worn the navy one with the little anchors. He wore it to every funeral, and to the bank.

“Stay a minute,” I said.

“Desiree, people are waiting at the hall. Your mother’s got the ham.”

“The ham will keep. Bentley kept.”

He looked at me the way he looks at a mower that won’t start. Behind him the doors were open and people were coming out in twos, slowing down on the steps because a grown woman had her father stopped in the doorway. Mom came last, holding her purse against her stomach with both arms.

Thuy came up beside me. Navy cardigan, flat shoes, the hands of someone who opens a lot of tape. The big man stayed at the bottom of the steps with the eleven riders behind him at the curb, nobody moving.

“Mr. Jacob,” Thuy said. “I’m Thuy. I had Bentley on Thursdays, room four-twelve.”

“I know who you are,” Dad said.

That was the first thing that made my stomach drop. He knew her. I didn’t.

“Then you know what I’m going to say,” she said.

“I don’t have time for this.” He held his keys up so the people on the steps could see them, like a man showing a ticket.

Thuy turned to me instead. She talked fast and low, the way you’d tell somebody where the fire exits are.

“Your father signed Bentley in almost every Thursday. One-thirty, sometimes one-twenty. He’d get him in the chair and get the line started and then he’d go. He’d be back about four-twenty-five. In time to sign him out.”

“Go where?” I said.

“I don’t know where he went the first few weeks,” she said. “I know where he went after. He left the stub on the tray table in November.”

She didn’t have to say the name. Everybody in our county knows the casino off the interstate. There’s a billboard with a cartoon slot machine wearing sunglasses.

Dad said, “That’s a lie.”

“I charted it,” Thuy said. “Every time. Guardian left unit at this time, patient alone, returned at this time. You can’t leave a child alone on that floor and not chart it. I charted it forty-one times.”

Forty-one. I did the math without wanting to. Forty-eight envelopes. Forty-one afternoons he’d taken the envelope off his dashboard and driven to a building with a cartoon slot machine on the sign.

“Why didn’t anyone call me?” I said. It came out higher than I meant.

“I called the number on file,” Thuy said. “Twice in October. It was his.”

Dad didn’t look at her. He looked at the cars.

I turned around on the steps. The big man was still at the bottom with one hand on his side.

“And you,” I said. “Where were you?”

He came up two steps, slow, so we were close enough to talk without shouting.

“Alfred,” he said. “Across the lot. Cancer center’s in the low building. I get my infusion Thursdays, one o’clock. They let me out about one-forty, and I’m not good for driving yet, so I’d sit on my bike a while. Your boy’s window looks right down on that lot.”

I knew that window. I’d seen it exactly twice, both times on days he was admitted, at night. Fourth floor. Parking lot under it like a gray lake.

“First time I saw him he had both hands on the glass,” Alfred said. “Just standing there in a paper gown. Nobody behind him. I waved. He waved. Next week, same. Third week I went in the gift shop and they had those little bells by the register. Two to a card. I asked the lady at the nurses’ desk if I could send one up.”

“That was me,” Thuy said. “He wrote on the card, ‘You ring yours, I’ll ring mine.’ Bentley couldn’t read it. I read it to him.”

I ring mine. He rings his.

My son had told me. Under his dinosaur blanket, grinning. And I had patted his head and given him his made-up friend.

“So every Thursday,” Alfred said, “I’d park under the window. He’d ring it at the glass. I’d ring mine back up. You can’t hear a bell four floors up. Didn’t matter. He could see me do it. Some weeks I brought a couple of the guys. He liked when they revved.”

He nodded at the curb. Eleven bikes.

“He’d count them,” Thuy said. “He’d tell me how many came.”

I put my hand over my mouth. Behind me, somebody on the steps said, “Oh, Lord,” the way church people say it, a real prayer and a remark at the same time.

My mother had stopped moving entirely.

Dad came down one step, so he was above me again, and said it to the whole crowd and not to me.

“I sat with that boy. I drove him. I paid for this funeral, sixty-eight hundred dollars. And I’m supposed to stand here while some druggie in a vest and a nurse with a grudge tell my daughter stories?”

“He’s on chemo, Dad,” I said. “Not drugs.”

“Same smell,” Dad said.

Alfred didn’t answer that. He just looked at the bell in my hand.

Room four-twelve

There’s a thing my father does when he’s losing an argument. He gets reasonable. He lowers his voice and spreads his hands like a man pricing a used truck, and everybody leans in because they think the shouting part is over.

He did it now.

“Desiree. Honey. You’re upset. You lost your boy. Nobody here blames you for anything you say today.” He looked up over my head at the people on the steps. “But this woman doesn’t know our family. I sat in that room.”

“Which chair?” Thuy said.

He blinked. “What?”

“Room four-twelve has two chairs. Which one did you sit in?”

He didn’t know. I watched him not know. It took about three seconds, and in those three seconds I saw every Thursday I’d pictured: Dad in a vinyl chair doing the crossword, Bentley falling asleep against his arm. I’d built that picture myself. I’d built it every week so I could stand at the register and sell people deck screws.

“The one by the window,” Dad said.

“The window doesn’t have a chair,” Thuy said. “Bentley stood there. That’s why he was always tired by four.”

My mother made a noise. It wasn’t a word. It was the noise a screen door makes.

“Carol,” Dad said, without turning around. “Go get in the car.”

She didn’t.

I’ll be honest about what I wanted to do then, because it wasn’t nice. I wanted to take the bell and put it in his mouth. I wanted to tell the whole church every envelope, the date, the bill it came out of. I’d gone without a winter coat to make those envelopes. I’d sold my grandmother’s ring at a pawn place on McGalliard for the March ones and told myself she’d have wanted Bentley sat with.

What I did was hold up my hand with the bell in it and ring it once.

Everybody on those steps went quiet. It’s a small bell. It isn’t loud. It’s just the only sound in a room where nobody else is making one.

“He came up the aisle today,” I said, “and he got on his knees. With whatever’s wrong with his side. In front of ninety people. And you threw his bell in the gravel.”

“I didn’t know what it was,” Dad said.

“You knew,” Thuy said. “You were there the day it came up. You told Bentley it was a cheap thing from the gift shop and he should put it in the drawer. He hid it in his blanket until you left.”

And there it was. The other thing I’d pretended. I’d figured Dad had bought it. That was the nicest thing I ever pretended about him, and he’d stood in that room and told my son to put it away.

Dad’s face went red from the collar up, like a thermometer.

“You want to do this here?” he said. “Fine. We’ll do it here. You want to talk about money? I spent sixty-eight hundred dollars on this morning. I spent a year of my retirement driving back and forth to that hospital. Gas isn’t free. My time isn’t free. A hundred and fifty a week is less than a babysitter gets.”

“Babysitters stay,” Alfred said.

It was the first thing he’d said to my father. He didn’t raise his voice. He said it the way you’d mention a tire was low.

Dad pointed at him. His hand was shaking. “You don’t talk to me. You don’t get to talk to me. You walked into my church looking like that, at my grandson’s funeral—”

“Your daughter’s son’s,” Alfred said.

Dad came down another step. I honestly thought he was going to swing. He’s sixty-seven and has a bad shoulder, and Alfred is the size of a vending machine, so I don’t know what he thought would happen. Maybe that’s the point. Men like my father have never in their lives expected anything to happen to them.

The pastor got between them. Pastor Dunham, little round man, used to coach my softball team. He put a hand flat on Dad’s chest.

“Jacob,” he said. “Stop.”

“You’re taking their side?”

“I’m asking you to stop on the church steps.”

Dad pushed the hand off. He looked around for somebody. He found my mother.

“Carol. Tell them.”

She had her purse in both arms still. Her lipstick had come off on a tissue during the first hymn and nobody had told her.

“Tell them what, Jacob?” she said.

“That I sat with him.”

My mother is sixty-five. She has said “you’re right, honey” to my father, by my count, about forty thousand times. She looked at the sugar bowl the night he named his price. She looked at it so long I thought the bowl might say something.

She looked at him now.

“You came home every Thursday at five,” she said. “Smelling like cigarettes. You don’t smoke.”

“Carol.”

“I thought you were at the hospital. I told the ladies at Bible study you were at the hospital. I asked them to pray for you.”

Something in my chest let go and something else grabbed on, both at once. I’d waited all year for somebody in my family to say one true thing out loud. I didn’t expect it from her. I’d stopped expecting anything from her somewhere around high school.

“We’re going,” Dad said. He held out his hand. To her. Like she was a dog off the porch.

She didn’t take it.

He stood there with his hand out in front of everybody, and the hand just stayed in the air.

“We’re going,” he said again.

Forty-one times

He put the hand in his pocket. I think that was the worst part for him, having nowhere else to put it.

“Okay,” he said. “Okay. I see how it is.” He turned to me and dropped the reasonable voice altogether. “You want your money? Is that what this is? You’ve been saving this up? You’ll get your money. I’ll write you a check right now. Seventy-two hundred, minus sixty-eight hundred for the funeral. Four hundred dollars, Desiree, if we’re doing math on the church steps.”

People actually gasped. I’d never heard a real gasp outside of television. It’s quieter than you’d think. More like a lot of people deciding not to breathe at once.

“I don’t want a check,” I said.

“Then what do you want?”

I thought about it. I really did. I had ninety people and a pastor and eleven bikers and my mother all looking at me, and the honest answer was I wanted Bentley back and Thursday afternoons that had happened the way I thought they had. Neither of those was available.

“I want you to say what you did,” I said. “Out loud. Where they can hear it.”

“I sat with him.”

“Forty-one times you didn’t,” Thuy said.

“Shut up.”

“She charted it,” I said. “Every one. One-forty. Four-twenty-five. My son alone in a paper gown with his hands on the glass.”

Dad looked down at Alfred. He actually looked at him, maybe for the first time.

“You were spying on my family,” he said.

“I was getting chemo,” Alfred said. “Your grandson waved at me.”

“He had a made-up friend,” I said. My voice cracked right down the middle of it. “That’s what I told myself. He told me, Dad. ‘I ring mine, he rings his.’ He told me and I thought it was a game, because I couldn’t imagine anybody leaving him. Because I paid somebody not to.”

That was when it got away from me. I didn’t sob. I sort of folded at the waist on the step, holding that bell against my stomach, and made a noise like the one my mother had made. Thuy got an arm around my back. Somebody’s hand landed on my shoulder from the step above, and I found out later it was Mrs. Menon from the choir, who I’d never said more than six words to.

When I could stand up again, my dad was looking at the church doors. Not at me. At who was in them.

Everybody he’d ever sat beside on a Sunday was in them.

“Say it, Jacob,” Pastor Dunham said.

“I don’t answer to you.”

“No,” the pastor said. “Answer to her.”

Dad opened his mouth. And I swear I saw it go through him, the whole calculation, every word he could say and what it would cost. He’d been good at that his whole life. He’d sold insurance for thirty-one years.

“I went for a few hours,” he said finally. “He was asleep. The nurses were right there. It’s a hospital, for God’s sake. It’s the safest place there is. What was I supposed to do, sit and watch a kid sleep for three hours?”

“Yes,” my mother said.

He swung around to her. “You stay out of this.”

“No,” she said.

She came down the steps. All the way down past him, past the pastor, past Mrs. Menon, the purse still in her arms. She stopped on the step beside me and took the hand that wasn’t holding the bell.

Her hand was ice. She held on so hard my ring finger went numb.

“You took her money,” she said up to him. “Seven thousand two hundred dollars. You took it out of her coat, Jacob, I watched her wear that same jacket all winter. You took it off your dashboard every Thursday and you drove to that place and you put it in a machine while our grandbaby stood at a window.”

Nobody on those steps made a sound.

“Carol,” he said. Quieter now.

“I’m going with Desiree.”

“To the hall?”

“Home. Hers.”

He looked at the keys in his hand. Gray Buick, the one with the dent in the back bumper from the Kroger lot. The one I’d left forty-eight envelopes on.

“You’re going to let a biker and a nurse do this to us,” he said. It wasn’t a question. It was the last thing he had.

My mother didn’t answer him. Neither did I.

He went down the steps alone. People moved out of his way the way you move away from something spilled. He had to walk right past Alfred to get to the lot, and he did it with his chin up, and Alfred didn’t turn his head.

He got to the Buick. He sat in it for a full minute with the door open, like he thought one of us would come. Then he shut the door and backed out wrong, crooked, the way he never parks.

Nobody went after him. The eleven riders at the curb didn’t even look up. One of them, a gray-haired man with reading glasses on a cord, just took a step back so the Buick could get by.

Then it was gone, and the lot was quiet, and my mother was still holding my hand.

Thursday at one-forty

He didn’t come to the reception. Mom went to the hall anyway and cut the ham herself and told anybody who asked that Jacob wasn’t feeling well. She said it with her chin up exactly like his.

Monday morning she drove to their bank on her own for the first time in forty-one years of marriage. She came out with a cashier’s check made out to me. Seven thousand two hundred dollars. On the memo line she’d written Thursdays.

“It’s half mine anyway,” she said. “Joint account. He’ll find out on his statement.”

He found out Tuesday. He called her eleven times. She let it ring on my kitchen counter and kept peeling potatoes.

By Wednesday the ladies at Bible study had heard all of it from Mrs. Menon, so I’m told, including the part about the window. Dad stopped going to the Wednesday breakfast. Then he gave his place on the deacons’ board to a man named Nordstrom who he has never liked. I heard that from Mom too. She said it without any expression at all, which in my mother is how you know she enjoyed it.

He sent one text that week. I hope you’re happy.

I wrote back: No. I hope he was. Then I put the phone in the drawer with the takeout menus.

I didn’t cash the check right away. I didn’t know what to do with it. It felt like it should buy something, and there was nothing left I needed to buy.

Thursday came. I’d taken the day off. I still had the shift, but the manager put me on the schedule as “off” without asking, and when I asked him about it he got very interested in a box of hinges.

At one-fifteen I drove to the hospital.

I hadn’t been back since the Sunday. I didn’t go in. I parked at the far end of the big lot, down by the low building where the cancer center is, and I looked up.

Fourth floor. Third window from the left. Somebody had put a paper turkey on the glass for November, a hand traced in brown crayon. Some other kid’s turkey now.

At one-forty a man came out of the low building walking like his body was arguing with him.

He saw my car. He didn’t look surprised. He walked over to his bike, a big black one with a cracked saddle, and leaned on it, one hand on his side. Then he waved me out.

I got out. My mother got out of the passenger side. She’d insisted on coming. She had on her good coat and she’d done her lipstick twice.

“Ma’am,” Alfred said to her.

“Carol,” she said. “You come to dinner Sunday. I’m not asking.”

He looked at me. I shrugged. “She’s not asking.”

He laughed. First time I’d heard him laugh. It hurt him, I could tell, and he did it anyway.

“How’s the side?” I said.

“It’s a side,” he said. “Doc says the scans are better. Two more months of Thursdays.”

“Then I’ll be here two more months of Thursdays,” I said.

He looked at me a long time.

Behind us, motors. One at a time, then more. They came in off the road in a line and backed in along the curb at that same angle. I counted them. I couldn’t help it. Bentley would have. Eleven.

The gray-haired man with the reading glasses on a cord walked over and shook my mother’s hand like it was a job interview.

I took Bentley’s bell out of my coat pocket. Alfred took his out of his vest, the string so frayed it was almost white. Mom had given me a new red ribbon for mine that morning. She’d cut it off a Christmas box she’d saved since 1998.

I held it up toward the window with the paper turkey.

“He rang first,” Alfred said. “Your turn.”

I rang it. You can’t hear a bell four floors up. You can’t hear it with eleven engines idling behind you either.

Alfred rang his back.

Then somebody at the curb leaned on his throttle, and then all eleven did, and the windows of the low building shook, and my mother put both hands over her ears and laughed until she had to sit down on the curb in her good coat.

Up on the fourth floor, behind the paper turkey, a small hand pressed flat against the glass.

I rang the bell again.

If this one got to you, send it to somebody who sits with someone on Thursdays.

For more family betrayals over money, read about a nephew who pocketed $2,500 before inheriting a farm and a sister who charged her widowed mom for a free motel room. There’s also an old veteran’s confrontation at the Legion Hall – another story where first impressions don’t tell the whole tale.